[Mystic Mock]

but what do you expect when louis gives john a song that didnt suit him and cheryl gives treyc a song that most of the x factor audience probably havent heard in there life.

the bottom 2 should have been cher and one direction as they are both so overhyped.

[red]

belleamie should've gone

[Legend killer]

Totally agree with u i feel soz for John Louis let him down this week

[Jordan.]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

but what do expect when louis gives john a song that didnt suit him and cheryl gives treyc a song that most of the x factor audience probably havent heard in there life.

the bottom 2 should have been cher and one direction as they are both so overhyped.

Anyway..... It was 'Guilty Pleasures' week so they obviously had to give there act something different to what they normally sing.

[Vicky.]

Felt so sorry for John, and I dont even like the bloke. Especially when he forgot his words in the singoff...but thats life.

Appalled at TreyC being in the bottom though

[Stacey.]

Cher and One Direction are great and they'll go far!

John shouldn't have been there, don't really care about TreyC though, she just shouts.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Stacey.x

Cher and One Direction are great and they'll go far!

John shouldn't have been there, don't really care about TreyC though, she just shouts.

and what cher dosent shout? and one direction cant even harmonise together so how are they great?

[Stacey.]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

and what cher dosent shout? and one direction cant even harmonise together so how are they great?

Cher doesn't shout... she sings and raps.

One Direction sound good together I think, Liam and Zain mostly.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Stacey.x

Cher doesn't shout... she sings and raps.

One Direction sound good together I think, Liam and Zain mostly.

i think cher shouts her raps out and one direction are all over the place when they harmonise together imo.

[Braden]

Originally Posted by red

belleamie should've gone

[Z]

Originally Posted by Braden

They were wailing at points in their song last night and it was a really underwhelming song choice, they were only safe tonight by virtue of it being a bottom two and benefiting from the vote boost that acts in a previous bottom two receive. They'll be out next week unless they're fantastic, which I doubt they'll manage. :/

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Zee

They were wailing at points in their song last night and it was a really underwhelming song choice, they were only safe tonight by virtue of it being a bottom two and benefiting from the vote boost that acts in a previous bottom two receive. They'll be out next week unless they're fantastic, which I doubt they'll manage. :/

and they say i stand by who instead of you.

[Braden]

Originally Posted by Zee

They were wailing at points in their song last night and it was a really underwhelming song choice, they were only safe tonight by virtue of it being a bottom two and benefiting from the vote boost that acts in a previous bottom two receive. They'll be out next week unless they're fantastic, which I doubt they'll manage. :/

But I think they're such good singers. There's a reason why they broke the charm of a girl group leaving first for the past two years

[Z]

Originally Posted by Braden

But I think they're such good singers. There's a reason why they broke the charm of a girl group leaving first for the past two years

I think the reason they avoided going in the first week was because there were 16 acts. If it had just been 12 acts, I think they'd have been out first. Anyway, they were in the bottom two in Week 2, it's near enough the same thing. They're still here because they could fade into the middle ground; now the crap acts are being picked off and they still haven't pulled it together - they'll be gone this week or next at best. I really don't think they gel together as a group at all; the blonde girl seems resentful towards the other three.

[red]

Originally Posted by Braden

srry but they were poo yesterday imo & should have been in the bottom 2

[Braden]

Originally Posted by Zee

I think the reason they avoided going in the first week was because there were 16 acts. If it had just been 12 acts, I think they'd have been out first. Anyway, they were in the bottom two in Week 2, it's near enough the same thing. They're still here because they could fade into the middle ground; now the crap acts are being picked off and they still haven't pulled it together - they'll be gone this week or next at best. I really don't think they gel together as a group at all; the blonde girl seems resentful towards the other three.

I think we can't say anything until the voting results are revealed. Everyone was so certain they were going this week. There odds shortened and they didn't give their best performance. But still they beat out somebody who was about 25/1. I think they could still easily still make it through this week. Treyc, Paige, Wagner and Katie could all still land in the bottom two next week.

[Z]

Originally Posted by Braden

I think we can't say anything until the voting results are revealed. Everyone was so certain they were going this week. There odds shortened and they didn't give their best performance. But still they beat out somebody who was about 25/1. I think they could still easily still make it through this week. Treyc, Paige, Wagner and Katie could all still land in the bottom two next week.

Obviously it does all come down to the voting at the end of the day; but what Belle Amie have achieved so far on the show has been pretty dire. They were crap in week 1, they had a couple of good moments in week 2 but landed up in the bottom two and survived by virtue of being up against a novelty act, and then were dire in week 3. They need to be markedly improved next week, like Katie has been in the weeks since her bottom two appearance, and then keep going from there. Continuing to misfire is just going to see them off very quickly. Treyc, like Katie and Belle Amie before her, will be fine next week by virtue of her bottom two appearance. Paije is at risk too, and who knows how popular Wagner really is?

[Z]

Although I will say; girl with the red hair sounded pretty good in the group performance!

[stewart64]

Treyc only has herself to blame last night. That Led Zep rendition was almost unlistenable. I was at a friends last night and her dog started to bloody whine and stick its ears back when that row came on, he was fine with the rest. What the ****** was she thinking of and what were the judges on about.

If Simon had been brave enough to put it to the public vote she would have been out.

Look there are too many contestants trying vocal gymnastics and bloody murdering the songs.

There is a lot of ire against Katie and Cher, but tbh they are a lot ******ing easier on the ear than some of b***ds who think they can sing and do a Whitney Houston belter or Darius/ Craig david f*&*k about.

Stop ******ing about with the melodies and sing it straight, stop ******ing trying to show off.

[MeMyselfAndI]

i know

Wagner should of gone tbf

[MeMyselfAndI]

Originally Posted by stewart64

Treyc only has herself to blame last night. That Led Zep rendition was almost unlistenable. I was at a friends last night and her dog started to bloody whine and stick its ears back when that row came on, he was fine with the rest. What the ****** was she thinking of and what were the judges on about.

If Simon had been brave enough to put it to the public vote she would have been out.

Look there are too many contestants trying vocal gymnastics and bloody murdering the songs.

There is a lot of ire against Katie and Cher, but tbh they are a lot ******ing easier on the ear than some of b***ds who think they can sing and do a Whitney Houston belter or Darius/ Craig david f*&*k about.

Stop ******ing about with the melodies and sing it straight, stop ******ing trying to show off.

no she has the cameras to blame.

She didn't connect with the audience as the camera was constantly zoomed out and was barely zoomed in on her. The wide cameras shot ruined it for her. I don't know whether or not it was purpose or not.. but not fair

[MeMyselfAndI]

Originally Posted by stewart64

Treyc only has herself to blame last night. That Led Zep rendition was almost unlistenable. I was at a friends last night and her dog started to bloody whine and stick its ears back when that row came on, he was fine with the rest. What the ****** was she thinking of and what were the judges on about.

If Simon had been brave enough to put it to the public vote she would have been out.

Look there are too many contestants trying vocal gymnastics and bloody murdering the songs.

There is a lot of ire against Katie and Cher, but tbh they are a lot ******ing easier on the ear than some of b***ds who think they can sing and do a Whitney Houston belter or Darius/ Craig david f*&*k about.

Stop ******ing about with the melodies and sing it straight, stop ******ing trying to show off.

why would he put it to deadlock if she sang better in the sing off?
Judges are meant to vote on whos better in it.. it's there job. They got told off last year for constantley taking the safe root out to deadlock

Katie obvioiusly isnt that easy on the year as she was in the bottom 3 in the FIRST WEEK!

[stewart64]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

why would he put it to deadlock if she sang better in the sing off?
Judges are meant to vote on whos better in it.. it's there job. They got told off last year for constantley taking the safe root out to deadlock

Katie obvioiusly isnt that easy on the year as she was in the bottom 3 in the FIRST WEEK!

I'm not anti-Treyc. I know she has talent. Her decision to sing that rubbish and Cheryl must take some of the blame too.

When I put the contestants in order on another thread before the weekend I had Treyc and Rebecca in the middle. Rebecca picked the right song ( as an American vamp) and has gone right up in my estimation and Treyc needs to recover from this disaster and obviously not rely on her judgement.

At least we both agree on Cher.

[Rawrbear]

Who should of been bottum 2
John:was write as he was the worst and would of landed out with out the sing off if it was a double
Wagner:at first he was funny then oh same as last week and yet again all his preformances are the same he shoudl go next week
followed by
Mary:unless she sing's a recent song as no oen will be buying her album if she wins
Paige:bit lost in the compatiton
Katie: loved her on saturday but i dont think she'll keep it up (Cheryl needs to lose a girl soon)
Cher:even though i like Cher as soon as big band night comes she's a goner

[ElProximo]

I'm still confused a little about where this John fellow came from or what he was doing there. Was he a replacement or something?

Yeah, two more should have gone. Tracy Cohen did not deserve to be there but I agreed her performance was somehow 'not connecting' even though i thought it was interesting.