[Jack_]

Basically, how you would've liked all of the Eliminations to go and how you'd like them go from this point onwards...

Here's mine:

#01 - One Direction
#02 - Katie
#03 - Cher
#04 - Matt
#05 - Nicolo
#06 - Diva Fever
#07 - Mary
#08 - Paije
#09 - Rebecca
#10 - Wagner

#11 - TreyC

#12 - Storm

#13 - Aiden
#14 - Belle Amie

#15 - F.Y.D
#16 - John

Though I wouldn't have minded where those top five would've placed, especially those top three.

But I think I'd prefer One Direction to win the most.

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Basically, how you would've liked all of the Eliminations to go and how you'd like them go from this point onwards...

Here's mine:

#01 - One Direction
#02 - Katie
#03 - Cher
#04 - Matt
#05 - Nicolo
#06 - Diva Fever
#07 - Mary
#08 - Paije
#09 - Rebecca
#10 - Wagner

#11 - TreyC
#12 - Storm

#13 - Aiden
#14 - Belle Amie

#15 - F.Y.D
#16 - John

Though I wouldn't have minded where those top five would've placed, especially those top three.

But I think I'd prefer One Direction to win the most.

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

i dont even care about half of the finalists so i cba to rate them but i would like

treyc
rebecca
mary
matt
one direction

top 5

[Smithy]

Jack that list is awful

[Mystic Mock]

1.aiden
2.paije
3.matt
4.treyc
5.rebecca
6.nicolo
7.wagner
8.john
9.mary
10.storm lee
11.katie
12.fyd
13.diva fever
14.one direction
15.cher
16.belle amie

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Jack that list is awful

No it's a great list

Gets the dullards out first, we keep Wagner for a bit of entertainment but then ditch him when there's talent left. And then we leave the most commerically viable acts to the last four...sounds perfect to me.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Jack_

No it's a great list

Gets the dullards out first, we keep Wagner for a bit of entertainment but then ditch him when there's talent left. And then we leave the most commerically viable acts to the last four...sounds perfect to me.

Your a viewer, not Simon Cowell

and the idea that Nicolo has more talent/is more commercially viable than Rebecca is laughable

[Novo]

#1 - Katie
#2 - Wagner
#3 - Storm
#4 - Cher


#5 - TreyC
#6 - John
#7 - Matt
#8 - Nicolo
#9 - Rebecca

#10 - Belle Amie
#11 - Aiden
#13 - FYD
#14 - Paije
#15 - One direction
#16 - Mary

[Twilight]

#01 - One Direction
#02 - Matt
#03 - Aiden
#04 - Belle Amie
#05 - Katie
#06 - TreyC
#07 - Paije
#08 - Rebecca
#09 - John
#10 - Storm
#11 - Diva Fever
#12 - Cher
#13 - Nicolo
#14 - F.Y.D
#15 - Mary
#16 - Wagner

[Tom]

1- Mary
2- Rebecca
3- Wagner
4- Treyc
5- Matt
6- Katy

no preference for the rest except

15th- Bellamy
16th- Wand erection

[MeMyselfAndI]

#1 Cher
#2 Treyc

#3 One Direction
#4 Matt
#5 Aiden

#6 Paije
#7 Belle Amie
#8 Rebecca
#9 FYD
#10 John Adeyleye

#11 Diva Fever
#12 Nicolo
#13 Storm
#14 Mary

#15 Katie
#16 Wagner

I want either Cher or Treyc to win
I also love One Direction,Matt and Aiden
couldn't really care less about the rest at all

[MeMyselfAndI]

Originally Posted by Jack_

No it's a great list

Gets the dullards out first, we keep Wagner for a bit of entertainment but then ditch him when there's talent left. And then we leave the most commerically viable acts to the last four...sounds perfect to me.

if you think Katie has more talent than treyc please.
Katy is not versatile, does one thing.
No vocal range, same tone singing.
TreyC can sing ABSOLOTELY ANYTHING.
good vocal range

no wonder katie has been in the bottom so much, she sounds the same ALWAYS

and btw Jack this is a singing contest not big brother...

[MeMyselfAndI]

Originally Posted by simonsays

i also agree
Treyc is a very good singer

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Your a viewer, not Simon Cowell

and the idea that Nicolo has more talent/is more commercially viable than Rebecca is laughable

Doesn't really matter, there's no point watching the show if we're not going to chose a commercially viable winner. What's the point in chosing a winner that's not going to be successful, just because they 'have talent'? We can't follow their progress then and eighteen weeks of shows have been a total waste of time.

And no, I'm not suggesting that - he's above merely because he was more interesting/entertaining than Rebecca.

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

if you think Katie has more talent than treyc please.
Katy is not versatile, does one thing.
No vocal range, same tone singing.
TreyC can sing ABSOLOTELY ANYTHING.
good vocal range

no wonder katie has been in the bottom so much, she sounds the same ALWAYS

and btw Jack this is a singing contest not big brother...

Every performance of Katie's have been different, apart from the last two weeks. What planet are you on?

She's gone from quirky and a big production, to a ballad with no production etc etc. TreyC has more vocal talent but she's got nothing 'different' and she isn't interesting and I don't look forward to her performances every week and I wouldn't buy her tour tickets etc etc. She's essentially another Alexandra...yawn.

I could ramble on and on like I've done before with you but it never ends up anywhere and you just end up trolling, so let's leave it at that

[MeMyselfAndI]

Originally Posted by Jack_

No it's a great list

Gets the dullards out first, we keep Wagner for a bit of entertainment but then ditch him when there's talent left. And then we leave the most commerically viable acts to the last four...sounds perfect to me.

Katys music does not fit in for pop music lmfao..!!
nor is she popular
nor is anyone going to buy an album that sounds the same.
her voice is to weak (weaker than leon jacksons)
and she sings like 1980s stuff tbf.

she is the least viable imo

and she only had press because she 'took gamus place'
which is the real reason.

and you seem to think gamu was crap had no policity and was dull! Yet she was so popular and the nation did love her tbf hence the anger to katie

[MeMyselfAndI]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Every performance of Katie's have been different, apart from the last two weeks. What planet are you on?

She's gone from quirky and a big production, to a ballad with no production etc etc. TreyC has more vocal talent but she's got nothing 'different' and she isn't interesting and I don't look forward to her performances every week and I wouldn't buy her tour tickets etc etc. She's essentially another Alexandra...yawn.

I could ramble on and on like I've done before with you but it never ends up anywhere and you just end up trolling, so let's leave it at that

its not trolling its my opinion..

and Treyc another alexandra.... GREAT! thats a platnum album

you probably thought leona was the same as treyc 'nothing different' well Jack 10 million albums. she was commercially viable. Hugely infact.. and so could treyc with the right songs

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Doesn't really matter, there's no point watching the show if we're not going to chose a commercially viable winner. What's the point in chosing a winner that's not going to be successful, just because they 'have talent'? We can't follow their progress then and eighteen weeks of shows have been a total waste of time.

Well we've done that with Steve, Leon, Joe and Shayne to an extent

[MeMyselfAndI]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Well we've done that with Steve, Leon, Joe and Shayne to an extent

Shayne has never flopped.. he is good
just bad record company

just like leonas second album which still sold more than JLS and alexandras album put together, yet say hers flopped

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

treyc ftw end of thread closed

[MeMyselfAndI]

and why do you think Katie got so much hate?

BECAUSE she was less talented as Gamu was.
Thats why the nation gave her bad press and all this. Yes it wasn't katies fault.
But everyone yes, pretty much everyone, realised gamu was very speacil, otherwise there wouldn't of been an uprising. And you can't denie Gamu was far more popular than Katie (favourite to win, when she wasn't in the competition)..

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

Katys music does not fit in for pop music lmfao..!!
nor is she popular
nor is anyone going to buy an album that sounds the same.
her voice is to weak (weaker than leon jacksons)
and she sings like 1980s stuff tbf.

she is the least viable imo

and she only had press because she 'took gamus place'
which is the real reason.

and you seem to think gamu was crap had no policity and was dull! Yet she was so popular and the nation did love her tbf hence the anger to katie

Katie's music? She has no music of her own yet, ROFL. To be quite honest I see her as another Diana Vickers [except without the support].

At the end of the day, you only hate her because she took Gamu's place. And for the record, no, that's not the only reason she's got press, and no, the large majority of the British public do not still care that Gamu didn't go through. They are over it. So it's time you got over it too. I never said Gamu was crap, infact I liked her, there were just better acts than her [the three Cheryl originally chose].

Oh, and 'policity' isn't a word - LMFAO

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

its not trolling its my opinion..

and Treyc another alexandra.... GREAT! thats a platnum album

you probably thought leona was the same as treyc 'nothing different' well Jack 10 million albums. she was commercially viable. Hugely infact.. and so could treyc with the right songs[/QUOTE]

Yes...but the way you put it across is often trolling...

LOL no, Leona had outstanding vocal talent and it was evident she wasn't going to be massive during her time on X Factor.

I'm not saying TreyC wouldn't be successful [although she'd need a bit more support], but why would we want two winners that are exact carbon copies of each other? That's pretty dull in itself. Let's have something different for a change, eh?

[MeMyselfAndI]

Originally Posted by simonsays

treyc ftw end of thread closed

[Adamw92]

1. Rebecca
2. Treyc
3. Belle Amie
4. Matt
5. One Direction
6. Katie
7. Paije
8. Mary
9. Cher
10. John
11. F.Y.D
12. Wagner
13. Diva Fever
14. Nicolo
15. Aiden
16. Storm

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

Shayne has never flopped.. he is good
just bad record company

just like leonas second album which still sold more than JLS and alexandras album put together, yet say hers flopped

In comparison with Leona and Alex, he hasn't been as sucessful, which is why I said to an extent

And compared to Spirit, Echo flopped, although it had good sales and got #1 it couldn't reach the success of the debut