[nanaimo]

Katie should go out this week because firstly we all know by now she shouldn't have got through in bootcamp for failing in her performance but thats just the tip of the iceberg.
She is not popular been in the bottom two too much so i think that proves her popularity, She behaves like someone that has had a career already and she hasn't earned it yet, Madonna, Mariah, Whitney and so on worked hard for were they are and she needs to learn to be a bit more humble for her own sake and not act like a wannabe diva.
She always puts on the dramatics when in the sing off and is not very convincing, she is clearly getting special treatment from the judges for her antics.
This week Simon said Treyc was the better singer and still put through Katie who also forget lyrics (fail again) and Treyc who mightn't be the most exciting contestant sang and gave it her all and was far better, but still got kicked out, i feel so sorry for Treyc, her family and friends for getting screwed like this and i am furious at the clear violation and perversion
of the rules, Chery should not have been asked second, this was very staged and aimed clearly at keeping katie in, she should have demanded her vote at end to allow deadlock, if it was the other way round i think she would have made a fuss and demanded her vote to allow deadlock but why should she care it was only Treyc and suited her better.
What worries me about all this, this could have a backlash at great people on show like Rebecca, Matt, if this blatant make it up as we go along continues, i think at the end of the day Simon and Cheryl want Cher or Katie to win, god only knows whats going on in the backroom dealings, sorry for wall of text, just really angry at whats going on lately.

[Niamh.]

Brilliant post and I agree 100% with everything you said. Personally I think Katie knows someone involved in X-Factor who is pulling alot of strings for her.

[nanaimo]

Why did dermot not say we will come back to you cheryl, why jump straight in with majority thing, why did he have the power to decide this, he is only the presenter, did he have a cowell earpiece in, totally cheating and would say the same thing if it happened to katie

[Novo]

Originally Posted by nanaimo

Katie should go out this week because firstly we all know by now she shouldn't have got though in bootcamp for failing in her performance but thats just the tip of the iceberg.
She is not popular been in the bottom two too much so i think that proves her popularity, She behaves like someone that has had a career already and she hasn't earned it yet, Madonna, Mariah, Whitney and so on worked hard for were they are and she needs to learn to be a bit more humble for her own sake and not act like a wannabe diva.
She always puts on the dramatics when in the sing off and is not very convincing, she is clearly getting special treatment from the judges for her antics.
This week Simon said Treyc was the better singer and still put through Katie who also forget lyrics (fail again) and Treyc who mightn't be the most exciting contestant sang and gave it her all and was far better, but still got kicked out, i feel so sorry for Treyc, her family and friends for getting screwed like this and i am furious at the clear violation and perversion
of the rules, Chery should not have been asked second, this was very staged and aimed clearly at keeping katie in, she should have demanded her vote at end to allow deadlock, if it was the other way round i think she would have made a fuss and demanded her vote to allow deadlock but why should she care it was only Treyc and suited her better.
What worries me about all this, this could have a backlash at great people on show like Rebecca, Matt, if this blatant make it up as we go along continues, i think at the end of the day Simon and Cheryl want Cher or Katie to win, god only knows whats going on in the backroom dealings, sorry for wall of text, just really angry at whats going on lately.

[nanaimo]

Originally Posted by Novo

defeated, poor reply maybe you think there is some truth in what i say...haha

[Novo]

Originally Posted by nanaimo

defeated, poor reply maybe you think there is some truth in what i say...haha

No need to reply to that ****e post.. I'll let Katie do the replying

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by nanaimo

Why did dermot not say we will come back to you cheryl, why jump straight in with majority thing, why did he have the power to decide this, he is only the presenter, did he have a cowell earpiece in, totally cheating and would say the same thing if it happened to katie

he definitely had someone in his ear telling him what to do or told him before the results were announced

[ElProximo]

Originally Posted by Novo

No need to reply to that ****e post.. I'll let Katie do the replying

Right.. her revenge is another week of ****e singing. Agree - she is doing a fine job.

I'm not complaining because using my 'Jew System' I have done extremely well in predictions and Katie is proving me right week after week.

As for reasons she should go?
Well, she is a mediocre singer and performer. Lackluster. No real 'X-Factor' despite best attempts to create the 'next Amy Winehouse' sort of spoiled bad-girl Jewess thing.

Is she the worst in there?
Aiden and Wagner and Boy Band are all worse singers and 'dancers'.
Paige is not as good a singer but has some 'X-Factor' and is improving.

So yeah she 'should' go eventually but right now she could happily go at around 6th place.

Why should she stay might be the better question:
- She is undoubtedly the niece of some people who have a LOT of large-scale power in the media.
- There is some good fake media 'bad girl' scandal crap going on.
and,
How else are you going to jack up massive fan voting campaigns without making a 'Cher versus Katie' battle?
Chavs versus Goths in an epic million pound phone-battle is great for everyone working there!

(or whatever the various rival teen girl subcultures are today).

[IheartBB]

Gah all this deadlock malarky. What if Treyc was at the bottom of the vote (which unofficial figures say she was), would this even be an issue?

And as for the judges wanting Katie to stay - Dannii voted her off, Louis voted her off last week and Cheryl didn't vote. Only Simon has made it clear that he wants Katie to stay. And why shouldn't he have this opinion? He's a fecking judge!

[tate]

Originally Posted by nanaimo

Why did dermot not say we will come back to you cheryl, why jump straight in with majority thing, why did he have the power to decide this, he is only the presenter, did he have a cowell earpiece in, totally cheating and would say the same thing if it happened to katie

Dermot has an earpiece in, the producers would have been telling him that Louis's decision was final and that there would be no return to cheryl despite her saying she would take to deadlock

Shambles by the producers to keep katie in for publicity ... but a great OP

[LeatherTrumpet]

Yes lets let it all work out fair and we can have another epic fail winner like Joe....



no thanks

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by IheartBB

Gah all this deadlock malarky. What if Treyc was at the bottom of the vote (which unofficial figures say she was), would this even be an issue?

And as for the judges wanting Katie to stay - Dannii voted her off, Louis voted her off last week and Cheryl didn't vote. Only Simon has made it clear that he wants Katie to stay. And why shouldn't he have this opinion? He's a fecking judge!

then they would have allowed it to go to deadlock if treyc was bottom of the votes.

[Livia]

Katie's going to be in the bottom two until they have to throw her out and stop cheating. Then she'll disappear like every other useless wannabe from previous years.

[nanaimo]

Cole offered to go last to force a deadlock, O'Leary then announced it would be a majority vote ????????

[IheartBB]

Originally Posted by nanaimo

Cole offered to go last to force a deadlock, O'Leary then announced it would be a majority vote ????????

Why should any judge have the casting vote? If you ask me it they should vote confidentially then have it come up on screen in front of them or something to prevent them being swayed by other judges or (more likely) the crowd. The order in which Cheryl was asked should not matter - if she refuses to vote, she refuses to vote. No going back.

[Pyramid*]

Originally Posted by nanaimo

Katie should go out this week because firstly we all know by now she shouldn't have got though in bootcamp for failing in her performance but thats just the tip of the iceberg.
She is not popular been in the bottom two too much so i think that proves her popularity, She behaves like someone that has had a career already and she hasn't earned it yet, Madonna, Mariah, Whitney and so on worked hard for were they are and she needs to learn to be a bit more humble for her own sake and not act like a wannabe diva.
She always puts on the dramatics when in the sing off and is not very convincing, she is clearly getting special treatment from the judges for her antics.
This week Simon said Treyc was the better singer and still put through Katie who also forget lyrics (fail again) and Treyc who mightn't be the most exciting contestant sang and gave it her all and was far better, but still got kicked out, i feel so sorry for Treyc, her family and friends for getting screwed like this and i am furious at the clear violation and perversion
of the rules, Chery should not have been asked second, this was very staged and aimed clearly at keeping katie in, she should have demanded her vote at end to allow deadlock, if it was the other way round i think she would have made a fuss and demanded her vote to allow deadlock but why should she care it was only Treyc and suited her better.
What worries me about all this, this could have a backlash at great people on show like Rebecca, Matt, if this blatant make it up as we go along continues, i think at the end of the day Simon and Cheryl want Cher or Katie to win, god only knows whats going on in the backroom dealings, sorry for wall of text, just really angry at whats going on lately.

Only one thing to addto your excellent post above: Katie's pathetic OTT dramatics on stage, 'legs not holding her up, collapse to floor' style. If I wanted to see ham acting, I'd be attending my local amateur dramatics show.

[fruit_cake]

it seems to me that Simon wants to keep Cheryl happy so is supporting who he sees as one of Cheryl's favourites

[Livia]

Originally Posted by nanaimo

Cole offered to go last to force a deadlock, O'Leary then announced it would be a majority vote ????????

And poor, shy, retiring Cheryl Cole couldn't speak up? She's usually got a massive gob on her, strange she couldn't find the strength to speak up on Sunday.

[nanaimo]

i'm sure if it was treyc she would haved looked for her deadlock but katie would have went then for sure, but shes going this week

[LeatherTrumpet]

Girls are very jealous of Katie

saucer of milk...

[nanaimo]

More reasons why wurzel should go

1 had a recording contract under the name Lola Fontaine

2 Waissel has been on tour with East 17 and Andy Abraham

3 She was previously in a relationship with 2008 Apprentice contestant Michael Sophocles and she sold a story about their relationship to the newspapers at the time

4 At her audition she forgot some of the words to "We Are The Champions" and has done so since.

5 She fell to pieces when performing the song "Smile" in front of Cole and will.i.am at the judges' houses stage

6 novo is her biggest fan

[nanaimo]

i see we have a reasons why katies should stay thread, think i need to bump this up so people aren't decieved

[Niamh.]

They weren't very good reasons anyway so I wouldn't worry!

[nanaimo]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

They weren't very good reasons anyway so I wouldn't worry!

BB Katie

[Niamh.]