[nanaimo]

I would like to exclude wagner from this, because if it was Wagner v katie, we know Danni,Chavryl and $imon would vote to save her.

So if there is a scenario where katie is in the bottom two again! Would she be chosen over Aiden, Cher, Mary, Matt, The Biebers, Paije or even Rebecca

imo i think not a hope against Aiden, Matt, Rebecca but with others i am not too sure, after this weeks fiasco anything is possible.

[Niamh.]

No, I don't think she would survive against anyone now(bar Wagner) Of the remaining acts none of the others have been in the bottom 2 yet and katie will have been 4 times (incidentally is that a record?) the next time, I just don't think even Simon could ignore that fact next time.

[joeysteele]

With Wagner,Cher,Mary and Paige she would be kept in if in the bottom 2 with any of them, but One Direction as Simon's only act would get the support to stay from Dannii and Louis too.

She shouldn't,I stress shouldn't have any chance of all to stay over the others though

[Benjamin]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

No, I don't think she would survive against anyone now(bar Wagner) Of the remaining acts none of the others have been in the bottom 2 yet and katie will have been 4 times (incidentally is that a record?) the next time, I just don't think even Simon could ignore that fact next time.

Yep if she is now the only contestant to have survived 3 times in the bottom 2.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by ukturtle

Yep if she is now the only contestant to have survived 3 times in the bottom 2.

well, if she survives again, even against Wagner tbh, then the judges may as well just stand there and say ****** you public, cheers for the money though!

[nanaimo]

Sometimes i forget cheryl is rebeccas mentor, don't think she gives her the recognition she deserves, shes totally concentrating on Cherv and katie but when Rebecca wins (even though shes a winner now) I bet Cheryl will jump on the bandwagon then

[Benjamin]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

well, if she survives again, even against Wagner tbh, then the judges may as well just stand there and say ****** you public, cheers for the money though!

I lie, Chico also survived 3 and ended up finishing 5th.