[Legend killer]

Bye Bye Katie

[sexyb4ck]

[Patrick]

She tried far too hard

[Legend killer]

Originally Posted by Patrick

She tried far too hard

It was a poor poor song choice. If u were to give her any KOL song lt sld have been something like Use Sombody which is much more suited to her voice

[Jordan.]

Lets just look at it like atleast she gave a performance instead of standing in the same spot every week, mentioning no names.

[Pyramid*]

Jeesus....how bad was that.

it looked as though she gave up half way through it. The only judge who was honest about that performance was Danni.

Katie, you were crap love. As usual.

[Mystic Mock]

she turned one of my favourite songs ever into pop rock.

but she will go through because she was on last again.

[Legend killer]

Originally Posted by Pyramid*

Jeesus....how bad was that.

it looked as though she gave up half way through it. The only judge who was honest about that performance was Danni.

Katie, you were crap love. As usual.

[Mystic Mock]

and her sex wasnt on fire either.

[Legend killer]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

and her sex wasnt on fire either.

She was about as sexy as her nan

YUK!!!!

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Legend killer

She was about as sexy as her nan

YUK!!!!

she less sexy than her nan.

[Legend killer]

Jedward i am very pleased to see u are supporting Lord Wagner

[ElProximo]

Originally Posted by Legend killer

Bye Bye Katie

It was a living example of just mediocre, half-arsed, pointless exercise, dreadfully average amateur 'singing'.

How on earth she is still in this competition is more baffling than Wagner. She is doing nothing but barely faking her way through a song and does nothing but stand there looking like she is obviously struggling and incompetent.

People were savvy enough to boot that song-abusing Aiden and yet they can't get rid of this zero-talent?

Lets hope.

[nanaimo]

Originally Posted by Legend killer

Bye Bye Katie

I concur

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Legend killer

Jedward i am very pleased to see u are supporting Lord Wagner

well if the judges are gonna keep katie in then we shall play them at there own game.

[Stacey.]

I thought she killed it, both her songs sounded great..

Wouldn't be surprised if she's in the sing-off though.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Stacey.x

I thought she killed it, both her songs sounded great..

Wouldn't be surprised if she's in the sing-off though.

so when you say killed it do you mean she was terrible then?

[Stacey.]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

so when you say killed do you mean she was terrible then?

No, they were both good.

I won't say "killed it" next time actually, because everyone seems to get the wrong meaning of it. I mean it as in she smashed it, did good.

[ElProximo]

Originally Posted by Stacey.x

I thought she killed it, both her songs sounded great..

I promise I am not being 'flaming' or mean this in any personal way but if you seriously thought Katie 'sounded great' there is something seriously wrong with either your physical hearing and/or you have some kind of 'cognition' or 'perception' problems or weakness.

Again, I seriously pledge I am not 'flame-baiting' or anything but you honestly need to take a look at yourself and decide whether you should ever again comment or make any sort of judgments about music.

Maybe it is some 'relative comparison' you want to make? IF we were at a Karaoke pub night thing then you could say Katie 'sounded great' (compared to other drunks and first-timers and silly fun time amateurs),
but,
If you mean she 'sounded great' compared to most X-Factor contestants then wow.
Just wow.

[Stacey.]

Originally Posted by ElProximo

I promise I am not being 'flaming' or mean this in any personal way but if you seriously thought Katie 'sounded great' there is something seriously wrong with either your physical hearing and/or you have some kind of 'cognition' or 'perception' problems or weakness.

Again, I seriously pledge I am not 'flame-baiting' or anything but you honestly need to take a look at yourself and decide whether you should ever again comment or make any sort of judgments about music.

Maybe it is some 'relative comparison' you want to make? IF we were at a Karaoke pub night thing then you could say Katie 'sounded great' (compared to other drunks and first-timers and silly fun time amateurs),
but,
If you mean she 'sounded great' compared to most X-Factor contestants then wow.
Just wow.

She did really well with them both, "Sex On Fire" was amazing, I was well impressed actually. Thought she'd murder it, but she performed and sang great.

Everyone has different opinions of her, so you can't really say my opinion is wrong. :/

[fitz2k2]

elton did better verison on sex on fire but katie sex wasnt on fire.i felt like she stretched out her vocals n she was off