[Beso]

No real point in it is there, not once this series has the singing been judged in the sing off. How the hell that odiuos wee **** cher got through after slaughtering whatever it was she was warblng against p[aige is beyond me..****test part of the show, why not just call it the cash cow round.

[Niamh.]

yeah, they really should should forget about doing a sing off and just choose as it is pretty pointless, Dannii is the only one who seems to judge them on it

[Marc]

5 judges. 3 acts each. Or 3 judges 5 acts each.

No tie, no deadlock.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Marczipan

5 judges. 3 acts each. Or 3 judges 5 acts each.

No tie, no deadlock.

no, the point is that they don't judge them on the sing off song anyway so why do they have to sing it, why not just pick one of them without having them sing

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by NingleBells

yeah, they really should should forget about doing a sing off and just choose as it is pretty pointless, Dannii is the only one who seems to judge them on it

Dannii is the only one to take the sing off on board.

I think though the time has come especially with X Factor on a saturday and Sunday now that the judges votes as to who goes out should be done away with.

Deadlock as it stands is unfair too since the public vote on the Saturdays performances.they have no prior knowledge of who will be in the bottom 2, unlike when the Judges vote in the sing off, they then know who is the bottom 2 and supposedly should vote on the sing off performances.

What could be done now though is to have the bottom 2 announced at the start of the Sunday show,have a sing off,then open those 2 acts lines again, (as they do in the final),have the public vote agin on those 2 acts only for the near remainder of Sundays show then announce as they do now who got the least votes then and so goes out.

Have the Judges judge the auditions, boot camp and subsequently who goes in to the live finals,but then the judges become mentors only and the rest is as it should be, down to the public using their time and money to say and decide who stays and goes all through.

[Vicky.]

Yeah the singoff is a bit useless now.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

Dannii is the only one to take the sing off on board.

I think though the time has come especially with X Factor on a saturday and Sunday now that the judges votes as to who goes out should be done away with.

Deadlock as it stands is unfair too since the public vote on the Saturdays performances.they have no prior knowledge of who will be in the bottom 2, unlike when the Judges vote in the sing off, they then know who is the bottom 2 and supposedly should vote on the sing off performances.

What could be done now though is to have the bottom 2 announced at the start of the Sunday show,have a sing off,then open those 2 acts lines again, (as they do in the final),have the public vote agin on those 2 acts only for the near remainder of Sundays show then announce as they do now who got the least votes then and so goes out.

Have the Judges judge the auditions, boot camp and subsequently who goes in to the live finals,but then the judges become mentors only and the rest is as it should be, down to the public using their time and money to say and decide who stays and goes all through.

I love that idea

[Marc]

Originally Posted by NingleBells

no, the point is that they don't judge them on the sing off song anyway so why do they have to sing it, why not just pick one of them without having them sing

Missed the whole gist of the thread! Haha what am I likkkke!