[bbfan1991]

I think they will do well but a straightforward NO is my answer.

[Smithy]

I think Rebecca has the potential to be global, and if one direction have the right material then possibly them too.

Matt? Probably not

[Locke.]

4th place, yes. Not the top 3 though.

[Stacey.]

Cher will Not the top three though.

[MTVN]

Rebecca and Matt wont do much, One Direction will probably have about the same success as JLS though

[bbfan1991]

Originally Posted by MTVN

Rebecca and Matt wont do much, One Direction will probably have about the same success as JLS though

JLS are way better and will continue to be more successful than they will ever be.

[Zippy]

OD are gonna certainly be bothering the singles chart. Whether they can also sell albums is the real question.

Rebecca could make a hugely successful album. She has a timeless voice that always goes down well in the huge easy listening market. Matt could go either way...depends on his first single. Could be a poor mans James Blunt.

Cher is the one who'll create the big media buzz. Again, could go either way but definitely huge potential.

[bbfan1991]

Originally Posted by Zippy

OD are gonna certainly be bothering the singles chart. Whether they can also sell albums is the real question.

Rebecca could make a hugely successful album. She has a timeless voice that always goes down well in the huge easy listening market. Matt could go either way...depends on his first single. Could be a poor mans James Blunt.

Cher is the one who'll create the big media buzz. Again, could go either way but definitely huge potential.

In terms of who would be entertaining to see at a concert IMO Rebecca would be way behind the other three. She has the voice, however I can't understand why she doesn't make enough use the stage, some will say she doesn't need gimmicks etc but she can use at least some choreography and this will get the crowd even more having a good time.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by bbfan1991

In terms of who would be entertaining to see at a concert IMO Rebecca would be way behind the other three. She has the voice, however I can't understand why she doesn't make enough use the stage, some will say she doesn't need gimmicks etc but she can use at least some choreography and this will get the crowd even more having a good time.

A voice sells records, dancing doesn't, dancing sells tours.

Records > Tours

[Jevans]

Hopefully Rebecca will become a global megastar Matt should do well. 1D too. I think Mary will do well too, she won't get a number 1 but she'll be in the charts at like number 32.

[bbfan1991]

I'll be pleased if Rebecca becomes big as Leona Lewis because she has more personality, no at matching Alexandra Burke though.

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by bbfan1991

In terms of who would be entertaining to see at a concert IMO Rebecca would be way behind the other three. She has the voice, however I can't understand why she doesn't make enough use the stage, some will say she doesn't need gimmicks etc but she can use at least some choreography and this will get the crowd even more having a good time.

well yeah, she needs to learn how to perform more still. But she's progressed a lot. And on record she'll sound divine.

Plus, many of the great female voices of all time are not big performers on stage(Aretha, Barbara, Celine etc). Some are great singers, some are great performers. Horses for courses etc etc

[Harry!]

Originally Posted by Zippy

well yeah, she needs to learn how to perform more still. But she's progressed a lot. And on record she'll sound divine.

Plus, many of the great female voices of all time are not big performers on stage(Aretha, Barbara, Celine etc). Some are great singers, some are great performers. Horses for courses etc etc

A..B..C.. lol.

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by Harry!

A..B..C.. lol.

Hawk eye Harry strikes again!

[Supermum]

Think they'll all do well, even Cher!