[Scarlett.]

This below has to be my favourite part of Silent Hill 2, the only way to go forward in the game is by jumping into a big black hole, of course, you don't REALLY have a choice after jumping down the first one, but the game decides to ask you, then rewards you by seemingly trapping you in a well...happy days!

Spoiler:

Also, pretty much any part of Project Zero/Fatal Frame - The game that forces you to take pictures of fricking freaky looking ghosts to kill them xD

[Patrick]

Being on multiplayer with a bunch of geeks who take the game really seriously in Left 4 Dead.

As you approach a dark alley, the people on the other end of their mics actually begin whispering to you rather than talking, as if talking would wake the witch.

And then I always end up shooting the witch in the leg, and she goes bonkers and floors everybody and they all start screaming in terror.
Brilliant.

[Scarlett.]

Lmao xD What about that moment in Resident Evil 1, with the long corridor, and the window...and the dog xD