[Andrew.]

http://xfactor.********.co.uk/judges...-x-factor.html

Apparently they're ALL calling for her to be replaced. However i find it ironic, that Tulisa is now doing it, cause initially when Tulisa was announced as new judge, immediately she was compared to Cheryl! Still is. But i couldnt agree less! IMO, Kelly could be the only retain able judge (along with Gary) for NEXT years show. Apparently EVERYONE whos seen kelly in action, LOVE her! apparently shes going to be big over here when the show airs...

But i feel sorry for her, shes a good judge, i think everyone will see that, do you think people are bothered with Cheryl coming back? also, didnt Louis dislike Chezza?

[Jordan.]

Don't believe anything you read

[Novo]

I agree with her

[Marc]

Meh they'll all pretend to love each other if asked about it

[Marsh.]

Sharon and Dannii started with the faux pleasantries at the start of series 4 and then it escalated. Not that this is the same.

But I think Tulisa shouldn't have been made a judge precisely because it's the money that's drawn the chav in. She made no secret of the fact she hated X Factor and everything it stood for (no problem with that) but now she's cashing in on it.

[bbfan1991]

I agree Marsh, it's a bit hypocritical re Tulisa slagging the show off but in terms of her solo career and the opportunity to give people advice who are trying to break into the music industry was probably too much to turn down and the dosh of course.

However i've read thoughts of people who went to auditions and from what they said it looks like the new panel get on, so some people need to stop believing every press article but of course the show thrives from some of these stories even if they are bull****.

[joeysteele]

If she has said that then all I hope for is that no one takes any notice and does not even make a single attempt to get Cheryl back on X Factor.

[CharlieO]

Originally Posted by AndrewWyld

http://xfactor.********.co.uk/judges...-x-factor.html

Apparently there ALL calling for her to be replaced. However i find it ironic, that Tulisa is now doing it, cause initially when Tulisa was announced as new judge, immediately she was compared to Cheryl! Still is. But i couldnt agree less! IMO, Kelly could be the only retain able judge (along with Gary) for NEXT years show. Apparently EVERYONE whos seen kelly in action, LOVE her! apparently shes going to be big over here when the show airs...

But i feel sorry for her, shes a good judge, i think everyone will see that, do you think people are bothered with Cheryl coming back? also, didnt Louis dislike Chezza?

*they're

[Joelle.]

If anyone should be replaced, its Tulisa the hypocritical chav

[cub]

The link to the OP is broken. What's the story?

[Niamh.]

Oh really? Cheryl replaced by an American on the US Version and then the American on the UK version to be replaced by Cheryl?? I smell a big fat publicity hungry rat.