[alex_front2]

BB11 winner Josie - for reasons I will never understand - was extremely popular and accrued 76% of the final vote (even though her toughest opposition was evicted before the final imho*).

Anyway, how do you rate this finalists as potential winners against her?




* At least no weak newbies made the final this year (JJ2 and Andrew last year)

[Vicky.]

I actually prefer ALL of this years finalists to Josie.

[Locke.]

Josie is one of the worst housemates ever, nevermind just the worst winner.

Even Tom offered more than her as a housemate

[MTVN]

I dunno tbh, I didn't really have a particularly strong opinion on her, she was overrated and dull but not really unlikeable

[Roy Mars III]

Worst winner ever, and one of the worst housemates of all time.

[alex_front2]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

I actually prefer ALL of this years finalists to Josie.

Ha ha!

I can't decide who I find more loathsome Jay or Josie. It's a toughie but I'll plump for Jay. At least Josie pooed in the toilette.

[BigBrotherfan4ever]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

I actually prefer ALL of this years finalists to Josie.

Me too Vicky appart from Jay, can't stand the guy.

[Pyramid*]

The BB Freezer that got shat in, deserved to win more than Josie did.

[Colbert-Bump]

Josie played the 'I'm Big & Dizzy' card last year, always a good tactic that one. Trying to pull Dave on the 'Gay Religion' stuff was a dirty move.

[HBB1508]

Can't stand Josie and not a worth winner in my opinion - the final 5 this year easily out rank her.

[lime]

Think Josie would have come 4th/5th if she was in this years final.

[alex_front2]

She wouldn't have been as popular as Alex. Which is why I find her support of Alex a bit weird as Alex will probably replace her as the 'Go to' non-threatening BB bubby blond.

[MeMyselfAndI]

She is better than them all but Aaron

[alex_front2]

I am shocked - i thought i was the only person in the planet who couldn't stand her!!

[Samuel.]

She was better than Louise, but that's not saying much.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by vicky.

i actually prefer all of this years finalists to josie.

this^

[Kazelle]

Anyone but Josie. I couldn't stand her and still can't along with anyone I've ever spoken to. How she won is beyond me.

[Alf]

here's a better match up, battle of the dark lords
aaron vs marcus bb10

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Pyramid*

The BB Freezer that got shat in, deserved to win more than Josie did.

[alex_front2]

Originally Posted by Kazelle

Anyone but Josie. I couldn't stand her and still can't along with anyone I've ever spoken to. How she won is beyond me.

She had no opposition in the final (like Sophie Read BB10) - no Ben, no Corin, even 'crab eyes' would have been better - all evicted a few nights before in the quadruple pre-final eviction. She was always going to beat the newbies Andrew and Jo-John, Mario peaked on day 5 with the mole task and creepy Dave annoyed many with his religious 'I'm drunk on the Lord' spiel.

But this year, I reckon she definitely would have been up for eviction and been evicted when Aden went.

[Angus]

Apart from Anthony and Brian Bellend, Josie is the worst BB winner ever, as fake as a three pound note, and a nasty piece of work under all that blubber.

[Doogle]

Aaron > Alex > Josie > Tom > Jay > Louise

[alex_front2]

Originally Posted by angus58

Apart from Anthony and Brian, Josie is the worst BB winner ever, as fake as a three pound note, and a nasty piece of work under all that blubber.

Which Brian (I think both were poor - Dowling had no opposition and Belo is just a professional numpty)

I reckon she would have clashed with Anton had she had entered this year. Sigh, would have loved to have seen that.

[Omah]

I'm in the "Josie was worst ever" camp - she doesn't deserve consideration in any list of BB HMs .....

[Marmalite]

Ugh! Josie

I tend not to rate her....ever!