[Kate!]

Grrrr Louis you bloody obnoxious little man, Wtf is wrong with you.

He said he wanted to save Carolynne and you could see her relief. Then he backtracked. Cruel Bastard.

Nicole can **** out as well.

[Munchkins]

ME, I CAN'T DO THIS
absolute ****e show lost credibility

[Saph]

He made a stupid decision. Now everyone will hate him for changing his mind, hate Rylan for staying and hate Nicole because shes Rylans mentor

[Jake.]

only watched the results and it just shows what a moron he is. This show has gone to the pits. Hope it falls below a million by next week and channel 5 buy it.

[Locke.]

Louis would beat you all up

[Jordan.]

Couldn't stand him for years now but tonight the hate has reached a new level.

[Apple202]

No I want to seriously maim the producer that whispered the order into his ear.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

To be fair, Dermot usually says "I have to accept your first answer" but tonight he didn't. Obvious fix.

CAROLYYYNE! SO MUCH POTENTIAL

[abcd]

Originally Posted by Apple202

No I want to seriously maim the producer that whispered the order into his ear.

is the correct answer

why do people who claim to have a keen interest in the show still believe that the judges have any say whatsoever as to what happens with regards to the contestants

[Pyramid*]

Originally Posted by abcd

is the correct answer

why do people who claim to have a keen interest in the show still believe that the judges have any say whatsoever as to what happens with regards to the contestants

Fair point !!

[reece(:]

Louis is just happy there's a novelty act and will support it throughout the competition.

[Maia]

I'm more annoyed at how Dermot etc didn't just take his decision to save Carolynne as his final decision...it's like they were clearly vying for him to just give in and send it to deadlock

He's still an utter fool though

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Originally Posted by Mollie.

I'm more annoyed at how Dermot etc didn't just take his decision to save Carolynne as his final decision...it's like they were clearly vying for him to just give in and send it to deadlock

He's still an utter fool though

Yep what I just said above you.

[Maia]

Originally Posted by Ithinkiloveyoutoo

Yep what I just said above you.

Good minds think alike girl

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Originally Posted by Mollie.

Good minds think alike girl

Indeed.

[Pyramid*]

No, I have no desire to seriously hurt Louis Walsh because I didn't agree with his decision.

This type of thing is one of the reasons the show has gone down the pan in recent years - good acts, people who do have a real talent are booted off in favour of acts that are kept in for nothing more than the controversy and attempts at pulling viewers in - knowing that they will never make the grade. It's been this way for years and imo, it's ruined a good show.

[LemonJam]

I don't mean to sound patronizing but the show has ALWAYS placed a controversial act over someone who's half decent. It's an entertainment show and the fact people are only saying now the show has lost credibility or is rigged is slightly hilarious because it's always been like this.

[Pyramid*]

Originally Posted by LemonJam

I don't mean to sound patronizing but the show has ALWAYS placed a controversial act over someone who's half decent. It's an entertainment show and the fact people are only saying now the show has lost credibility or is rigged is slightly hilarious because it's always been like this.

Partly agree with you but it is getting worse (or perhaps I'm just fed up of seeing the same old routine and stunt being pulled year after year).

[MTVN]

Originally Posted by LemonJam

I don't mean to sound patronizing but the show has ALWAYS placed a controversial act over someone who's half decent. It's an entertainment show and the fact people are only saying now the show has lost credibility or is rigged is slightly hilarious because it's always been like this.

lol yeah, anyone who's ever seen this show shouldn't have expected anything else

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Originally Posted by LemonJam

I don't mean to sound patronizing but the show has ALWAYS placed a controversial act over someone who's half decent. It's an entertainment show and the fact people are only saying now the show has lost credibility or is rigged is slightly hilarious because it's always been like this.

That's because each year we hope they have seen sense. Obviously we're wrong to keep hope alive

[Doogle]

Originally Posted by LemonJam

I don't mean to sound patronizing but the show has ALWAYS placed a controversial act over someone who's half decent. It's an entertainment show and the fact people are only saying now the show has lost credibility or is rigged is slightly hilarious because it's always been like this.

Very true. I don't get how people are only saying it now when it's been like this since Jedward.

[joeysteele]

I am devastated Carolynne has gone, however for me, I would rather who went out was the act who got the least votes from the public so I am glad it went to deadlock in a way.
I don't like the sing offs and judges saying who goes out as well as mentoring acts,the public should decide this all through.Usually half the judges votes are already decided no matter how well an act may sing in the sing offs anyway.

In fact I believe it is what Louis wanted to do anyway,I don't blame him, he was the last judge, he had Dermot yelling for a name after spending most of the show with inane chatter and not leaving enough time for the sing off and vote afterwards. Louis also had huffy Gary on his feet screaming at him to save Carolynne and also Nicole yelling for him to save Rylan too.
He liked both acts and I think in that scenario I would have taken it to deadlock,never believing that Carolynne had polled the least votes however.

At the end of the day, unbelievably and impossible to understand why but Carolynne did actually get the least votes from the viewing public who voted.
How she did though,is a total mystery to me.She really is a great singer.

[mizzy25]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

I am devastated Carolynne has gone, however for me, I would rather who went out was the act who got the least votes from the public so I am glad it went to deadlock in a way.
I don't like the sing offs and judges saying who goes out as well as mentoring acts,the public should decide this all through.Usually half the judges votes are already decided no matter how well an act may sing in the sing offs anyway.

In fact I believe it is what Louis wanted to do anyway,I don't blame him, he was the last judge, he had Dermot yelling for a name after spending most of the show with inane chatter and not leaving enough time for the sing off and vote afterwards. Louis also had huffy Gary on his feet screaming at him to save Carolynne and also Nicole yelling for him to save Rylan too.
He liked both acts and I think in that scenario I would have taken it to deadlock,never believing that Carolynne had polled the least votes however.

At the end of the day, unbelievably and impossible to understand why but Carolynne did actually get the least votes from the viewing public who voted.
How she did though,is a total mystery to me.She really is a great singer.

this although carolynne im afraid bored me.

[Locke.]

At the end of the day Rylan received more votes than Carolynne and Louis as usual just proved he was in touch with the public

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by Locke.

At the end of the day Rylan received more votes than Carolynne and Louis as usual just proved he was in touch with the public

Yes, but that kind of defeats the object of a judges vote if you think that the person with the lowest votes should always leave.