[Ammi]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

Whitney is by far the best out of these three.

..and yes.....

[Benjamin]

Celine.

I used to absolutely hate her when i was a kid, but now I love her voice.

[Joelle.]

Whitney by miles. Her discography is flawless - How Will I Know, I Wanna Dance.., So Emotional, Queen of the Night, etc. and those two dont even compare. Doesn't help Mariah's case that shes an utter **** as well. Celine has a better voice than Mariah imo too.

[Nia-96]

Whitney
Mariah
Celine

[Harry!]

Whitney > Celine > Mariah

[Niamh.]

In her prime Whitney was by far the best of the 3

[reece(:]

Mariah by far, although her standards are slipping

[Z]

I can't get into Mariah's music, other than All I Want For Christmas Is You, I feel like she's an extremely American-centric artist whereas Celine and Whitney have music that has a more European friendly feel to it?

[Kate!]

Originally Posted by Shaun

Whitney by far in terms of discography. Then Mariah, and I barely register Celine Dion as a musician - she's just a moose that occasionally ventures out of the forest for some water.

This.

Whitney is head and shoulders above Mariah in talent and consistency, Celine hmm well she can sing but I have no interest in her, she's bland.

[Z]

To be honest I don't really appreciate any of them as artists; Whitney has more songs I know by name and I can appreciate that they are all amazingly talented singers but the whole sassy diva persona that comes with that I find totally unappealing and contrived.

[Lee.]

I can't stand Mariah's voice.. Whitney has had some great songs, but Celine's voice is

[Z]

I think Mariah's a bit cringe worthy nowadays, her voice is meant for belting big songs, not breathy R'n'B-lite features on other artists' songs to try and keep her "young". Think it's about time she accepted a residency somewhere and stopped trying to act half her age.

[Lee.]

Originally Posted by Zee

I think Mariah's a bit cringe worthy nowadays, her voice is meant for belting big songs, not breathy R'n'B-lite features on other artists' songs to try and keep her "young". Think it's about time she accepted a residency somewhere and stopped trying to act half her age.

Even as a belter, I find her voice unbearable. I think she has something like an 8 octave range.. But is there any need to demonstrate that range in one short line of a song? No I do not think so

[Z]

Originally Posted by Lee.

Even as a belter, I find her voice unbearable. I think she has something like an 8 octave range.. But is there any need to demonstrate that range in one short line of a song? No I do not think so

Ugh I know, being able to go as high as a dog whistle doesn't mean you should do it at every opportunity

[Lee.]

Originally Posted by Zee

Ugh I know, being able to go as high as a dog whistle doesn't mean you should do it at every opportunity

I'll bet your shower singing is better x 100

[Z]

Originally Posted by Lee.

I'll bet your shower singing is better x 100

I bet fewer people have told me to shut up and go away when I'm singing than Mariah's had

[Saph]

Youtube video

>>>

[Z]

Yeah but she's no Zee in the shower is she