[Dominic]

Both considered the sexiest music videos in pop culture and both are Knee's/Xtina's ~cute teen gal to sexy diva~ anthems from early 00s! Which song and which video is better?

[Dominic]

Dirrty the song is better as it's more boppable and also has rapping which suits it perfectly!

Slave video is better bc it has better choreography and is generally sexier idk

[Jamie89]

Originally Posted by Brenda.

Dirrty the song is better as it's more boppable and also has rapping which suits it perfectly!

Slave video is better bc it has better choreography and is generally sexier idk

I agree

[Nicky91]

for song: Dirrty

for video: Slave

[Daniel.]

Too dirty to clean my act up

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by Daniel_

Too dirty to clean my act up

you're so funny

[Samm]

Slave for both

[Pete.]

Slave

[Jordan.]

Dirrty is a BOP, Slave is boring so

[Shaun]

agree with Jordan

can't really remember Slave's video that much, only thing that springs to mind with that song is the performance with the snake

[reece(:]

Dirrty for both

[Natalie.]

Slave for both

[Firewire]

Dirrty song and Slave video

[Jessica.]

Dirrty

[_Tom_]

am a slav 5 u

[iRyan]

Slave is iconic, Dirrty was Xtina's desperate attempt to keep up

[Amy Jade]

Originally Posted by iRyan

Dirrty was Xtina's desperate attempt to keep up

It worked and sold better than Britney's desperate attempt though

[iRyan]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

It worked and sold better than Britney's desperate attempt though

Both of these statements are false hun, except maybe in the UK. I still bop to Dirrty but you can't deny both the song and video reek of desperation far beyond Slave.

[ChristmasNeeve]

Dirrty, I prefer Xtina in general too

[Pete.]

Slave's video and VMA performance will go down in history, Dirrty is being forgotten

[Amy Jade]

Originally Posted by Pete.

Slave's video and VMA performance will go down in history, Dirrty is being forgotten

She'll always be remembered for shaving her head and twatting a car with a brolly over any of her music anyway now

[iRyan]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

She'll always be remembered for shaving her head and twatting a car with a brolly over any of her music anyway now

No matter how you chose to remember her, Britney will always remain more relevant, successful, and iconic than Floptina.

[Amy Jade]

Originally Posted by iRyan

No matter how you chose to remember her, Britney will always remain more relevant, successful, and iconic than Floptina.

That really depends doesn't it.

Has she sold more music? Yes.

Christina has the better voice and had transitioned to TV much more successfully than britney who flopped on X Factor.

Also Britney's last album was a bigger flop than Lotus in a America, she just has more worshippers who don't like it brought up on here...and Pretty Girls flopped hard while Say Something was rather successful

[iRyan]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

That really depends doesn't it.

Has she sold more music? Yes.

Christina has the better voice and had transitioned to TV much more successfully than britney who flopped on X Factor.

Also Britney's last album was a bigger flop than Lotus in a America, she just has more worshippers who don't like it brought up on here...and Pretty Girls flopped hard while Say Something was rather successful

Britney's acted on very successful shows including Glee, How I Met Your Mother, Will & Grace, and Jane The Virgin and gave them peak ratings. She never needed X-Factor and chose not to return, then the show ratings tanked to literally less than half of the viewership when she was a judge and they had to cancel. Christina's career right now revolves around being a judge on a talent show, congrats to her.

Britney Jean flopped because it was a terrible album, and Pretty Girls was **** as well honestly. But it was hardly a bigger flop than Lotus, only by 25,000 copies, and it charted better than Lotus and sold more the first week.

[Pete.]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

She'll always be remembered for shaving her head and twatting a car with a brolly over any of her music anyway now

Legend of overcoming mental instability