Home Menu

Site Navigation


Notices

Survivor Discuss all versions of the CBS reality show.

 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Prev Previous Post   Next Post Next
Old 25-05-2017, 03:45 AM #1
JerseyWins's Avatar
JerseyWins JerseyWins is offline
Meow Meow
 
Join Date: Aug 2014
Posts: 21,292

Favourites (more):
BBUSA22: Enzo
BBCanada 8: Jamar
JerseyWins JerseyWins is offline
Meow Meow
JerseyWins's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2014
Posts: 21,292

Favourites (more):
BBUSA22: Enzo
BBCanada 8: Jamar
Default TIBB's Greatest Survivors Of All Time Ranking

34 seasons of Survivor have now passed. It's time to find out which Survivor castaways are considered to be the best by this forum. I did this for BBUS (and I think BBCAN) a while ago. Why not try it with Survivor?

I'll post all the casts here. Then when we all do our rankings, I'll count up the final results based on average scores, and announce the final list at some point in the future. You do NOT need to watch every season to participate in this and you don't need to make rankings for every season if you just don't want to but the more the better.

Step 1: Rank the casts from favorite to least favorite. Make sure every cast member is on there and if you don't use full names in your ranking make sure everyone is still identifiable (especially on seasons where 2 people have the same first name).

Step 2: For each individual season, give a point scale from 25 to 1 based on how much you like (or dislike) the characters. 25 being favorite, 1 being least favorite. There will be numbers that you'll need to skip as there are only 16-20 castaways in each season (and your fave/least fave of a season don't NEED to receive 25 or 1 point, respectively). There's no using the same number twice for the same season, and no using decimals or numbers outside of the 25-1 scale.


There's a lot of seasons so it should definitely take a little bit of time to do but the end result should be worth it! Although it honestly seems like more work than it actually is. I'll leave this open for a few months as well so there should be plenty of time to get these rankings done. Hopefully we see a good turnout of people willing to take part in this. You can post your rankings at any time and add/update your post whenever you'd like until I officially announce the deadline.

Estimated results reveal: Summer 2017 (late July to late August)


CASTS

Spoiler:

Borneo
Spoiler:

B.B. Andersen
Colleen Haskell
Dirk Been
Gervase Peterson
Greg Buis
Gretchen Cordy
Jenna Lewis
Joel Klug
Kelly Wiglesworth
Ramona Gray
Richard Hatch
Rudy Boesch
Sean Kenniff
Sonja Christopher
Stacey Stillman
Sue Hawk


Australian Outback
Spoiler:

Alicia Calaway
Amber Brkich
Colby Donaldson
Debb Eaton
Elisabeth Filarski
Jeff Varner
Jerri Manthey
Keith Famie
Kel Gleason
Kimmi Kappenberg
Maralyn Hershey
Michael Skupin
Mitchell Olson
Nick Brown
Rodger Bingham
Tina Wesson


Africa
Spoiler:

Brandon Quinton
Carl Bilancione
Clarence Black
Diane Ogden
Ethan Zohn
Frank Garrison
Jessie Camacho
Kelly Goldsmith
Kim Johnson
Kim Powers
Lex van den Berghe
Linda Spencer
Lindsey Richter
Silas Gaither
Teresa Cooper
Tom Buchanan


Marquesas
Spoiler:

Gabriel Cade
Gina Crews
Hunter Ellis
John Carroll
Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien
Neleh Dennis
Paschal English
Patricia Jackson
Peter Harkey
Rob Mariano
Robert DeCanio
Sarah Jones
Sean Rector
Tammy Leitner
Vecepia Towery
Zoe Zanidakis


Thailand
Spoiler:

Brian Heidik
Clay Jordan
Erin Collins
Ghandia Johnson
Helen Glover
Jake Billingsley
Jan Gentry
Jed Hildebrand
John Raymond
Ken Stafford
Penny Ramsey
Robb Zbacnik
Shii Ann Huang
Stephanie Dill
Tanya Vance
Ted Rogers


Amazon
Spoiler:

Alex Bell
Butch Lockley
Christy Smith
Daniel Lue
Dave Johnson
Deena Bennett
Heidi Strobel
Janet Koth
Jeanne Hebert
Jenna Morasca
JoAnna Ward
Matthew von Ertfelda
Rob Cesternino
Roger Sexton
Ryan Aiken
Shawna Mitchell


Pearl Islands
Spoiler:

Andrew Savage
Burton Roberts
Christa Hastie
Darrah Johnson
Jon "Jonny Fairplay" Dalton
Lillian Morris
Michelle Tesauro
Nicole Delma
Osten Taylor
Rupert Boneham
Ryan Opray
Ryan Shoulders
Sandra Diaz-Twine
Shawn Cohen
Tijuana Bradley
Trish Dunn


All Stars
Spoiler:

Alicia Calaway
Amber Brkich
Colby Donaldson
Ethan Zohn
Jenna Lewis
Jenna Morasca
Jerri Manthey
Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien
Lex van den Berghe
Richard Hatch
Rob Cesternino
Rob Mariano
Rudy Boesch
Rupert Boneham
Shii Ann Huang
Sue Hawk
Tina Wesson
Tom Buchanan


Vanuatu
Spoiler:

Ami Cusack
Brady Finta
Brook Geraghty
Chris Daugherty
Dolly Neely
Eliza Orlins
James "Chad" Crittenden
John "J.P." Palyok
John Kenney
Julie Berry
Lea "Sarge" Masters
Leann Slaby
Lisa Keiffer
Mia Galeotalanza
Rory Freeman
Scout Cloud Lee
Travis "Bubba" Sampson
Twila Tanner


Palau
Spoiler:

Angie Jakusz
Ashlee Ashby
Bobby Jon Drinkard
Caryn Groedel
Coby Archa
Gregg Carey
Ian Rosenberger
Ibrehem Rahman
James Miller
Janu Tornell
Jeff Wilson
Jennifer Lyon
Jolanda Jones
Jonathan Libby
Katie Gallagher
Kim Mullen
Stephenie LaGrossa
Tom Westman
Wanda Shirk
Willard Smith


Guatemala
Spoiler:

Amy O'Hara
Blake Towsley
Bobby Jon Drinkard
Brandon Bellinger
Brian Corridan
Brianna Varela
Brooke Struck
Cindy Hall
Danni Boatwright
Gary Hogeboom
Jamie Newton
Jim Lynch
Judd Sergeant
Lydia Morales
Margaret Bobonich
Morgan McDevitt
Rafe Judkins
Stephenie LaGrossa


Panama
Spoiler:

Aras Baskauskas
Austin Carty
Bobby Mason
Bruce Kanegai
Cirie Fields
Courtney Marit
Dan Barry
Danielle DiLorenzo
Melinda Hyder
Misty Giles
Nick Stanbury
Ruth Marie Milliman
Sally Schumann
Shane Powers
Terry Deitz
Tina Scheer


Cook Islands
Spoiler:

Adam Gentry
Anh-Tuan "Cao Boi" Bui
Becky Lee
Billy Garcia
Brad Virata
Candice Woodcock
Cecilia Mansilla
Cristina Coria
J.P. Calderon
Jenny Guzon-Bae
Jessica "Flica" Smith
Jonathan Penner
Nathan "Nate" Gonzalez
Ozzy Lusth
Parvati Shallow
Rebecca Borman
Sekou Bunch
Stephannie Favor
Sundra Oakley
Yul Kwon


Fiji
Spoiler:

Alex Angarita
Anthony Robinson
Cassandra Franklin
Dre "Dreamz" Herd
Earl Cole
Edgardo Rivera
Erica Durosseau
Gary Stritesky
James "Rocky" Reid
Jessica deBen
Kenward "Boo" Bernis
Liliana Gomez
Lisette "Lisi" Linares
Michelle Yi
Mookie Lee
Rita Verreos
Stacy Kimball
Sylvia Kwan
Yau-Man Chan


China
Spoiler:

Aaron Reisberger
Amanda Kimmel
Ashley Massaro
Courtney Yates
Dave Cruser
Denise Martin
Erik Huffman
Jaime Dugan
James Clement
Jean-Robert Bellande
Leslie Nease
Michael "Frosti" Zernow
Peih-Gee Law
Sherea Lloyd
Steve "Chicken" Morris
Todd Herzog


Micronesia
Spoiler:

Alexis Jones
Amanda Kimmel
Ami Cusack
Chet Welch
Cirie Fields
Eliza Orlins
Erik Reichenbach
James Clement
Jason Siska
Joel Anderson
Jon "Jonny Fairplay" Dalton
Jonathan Penner
Kathleen "Kathy" Sleckman
Mary Sartain
Michael "Mikey B" Bortone
Natalie Bolton
Ozzy Lusth
Parvati Shallow
Tracy Hughes-Wolf
Yau-Man Chan


Gabon
Spoiler:

Ace Gordon
Charlie Herschel
Corinne Kaplan
Crystal Cox
Dan Kay
Danny "GC" Brown
Gillian Larson
Jacquie Berg
Jessica "Sugar" Kiper
Kelly Czarnecki
Ken Hoang
Marcus Lehman
Matty Whitmore
Michelle Chase
Paloma Soto-Castillo
Randy Bailey
Robert "Bob" Crowley
Susie Smith


Tocantins
Spoiler:

Benjamin "Coach" Wade
Brendan Synnott
Candace Smith
Carolina Eastwood
Debra "Debbie" Beebe
Erinn Lobdell
James "J.T." Thomas
Jerry Sims
Joe Dowdle
Sandy Burgin
Sierra Reed
Spencer Duhm
Stephen Fishbach
Sydney Wheeler
Tamara "Taj" Johnson-George
Tyson Apostol


Samoa
Spoiler:

Ashley Trainer
Ben Browning
Betsy Bolan
Brett Clouser
Dave Ball
Elizabeth "Liz" Kim
Erik Cardona
Jaison Robinson
John Fincher
Kelly Sharbaugh
Laura Morett
Marisa Calihan
Mick Trimming
Mike Borassi
Monica Padilla
Natalie White
Russell Hantz
Russell Swan
Shannon "Shambo" Waters
Yasmin Giles


Heroes vs. Villains
Spoiler:

Amanda Kimmel
Benjamin "Coach" Wade
Candice Woodcock
Cirie Fields
Colby Donaldson
Courtney Yates
Danielle DiLorenzo
James "J.T." Thomas
James Clement
Jerri Manthey
Jessica "Sugar" Kiper
Parvati Shallow
Randy Bailey
Rob Mariano
Rupert Boneham
Russell Hantz
Sandra Diaz-Twine
Stephenie LaGrossa
Tom Westman
Tyson Apostol


Nicaragua
Spoiler:

Alina Wilson
Ben "Benry" Henry
Brenda Lowe
Chase Rice
Dan Lembo
Holly Hoffman
Jane Bright
Jill Behm
Jimmy Johnson
Jimmy Tarantino
Jud "Fabio" Birza
Kelly BrunoTyrone Davis
Kelly Shinn
Marty Piombo
Matthew "Sash" Lenahan
NaOnka Mixon
Shannon Elkins
Wendy Jo DeSmidt-Kohlhoff
Yve Rojas


Redemption Island
Spoiler:

Andrea Boehlke
Ashley Underwood
David Murphy
Francesca Hogi
Grant Mattos
Julie Wolfe
Krista Klumpp
Kristina Kell
Matt Elrod
Mike Chiesl
Natalie Tenerelli
Phillip Sheppard
Ralph Kiser
Rob Mariano
Russell Hantz
Sarita White
Stephanie Valencia
Steve Wright


South Pacific
Spoiler:

Albert Destrade
Benjamin "Coach" Wade
Brandon Hantz
Christine Shields-Markoski
Dawn Meehan
Edna Ma
Elyse Umemoto
Jim Rice
John Cochran
Keith Tollefson
Mark "Papa Bear" Caruso
Mikayla Wingle
Ozzy Lusth
Rick Nelson
Semhar Tadesse
Sophie Clarke
Stacey Powell
Whitney Duncan


One World
Spoiler:

Alicia Rosa
Bill Posley
Chelsea Meissner
Christina Cha
Colton Cumbie
Greg "Tarzan" Smith
Jay Byars
Jonas Otsuji
Kat Edorsson
Kim Spradlin
Kourtney Moon
Leif Manson
Matt Quinlan
Michael Jefferson
Monica Culpepper
Nina Acosta
Sabrina Thompson
Troy "Troyzan" Robertson


Philippines
Spoiler:

Abi-Maria Gomes
Angie Layton
Artis Silvester
Carter Williams
Dana Lambert
Denise Stapley
Jeff Kent
Jonathan Penner
Katie Hanson
Lisa Whelchel
Malcolm Freberg
Michael Skupin
Pete Yurkowski
Roberta “R.C.” Saint-Amour
Roxanne “Roxy” Morris
Russell Swan
Sarah Dawson
Zane Knight


Caramoan
Spoiler:

Alexandra "Allie" Pohevitz
Andrea Boehlke
Brandon Hantz
Brenda Lowe
Corinne Kaplan
Dawn Meehan
Edward "Eddie" Fox
Erik Reichenbach
Francesca Hogi
Hope Driskill
John Cochran
Julia Landauer
Laura Alexander
Malcolm Freberg
Matt Bischoff
Michael Snow
Phillip Sheppard
Reynold Toepfer
Shamar Thomas
Sherri Biethman


Blood vs. Water
Spoiler:

Aras Baskauskas
Brad Culpepper
Caleb Bankston
Candice Cody
Ciera Eastin
Colton Cumbie
Gervase Peterson
Hayden Moss
John Cody
Kat Edorsson
Katie Collins
Laura Boneham
Laura Morett
Marissa Peterson
Monica Culpepper
Rachel Foulger
Rupert Boneham
Tina Wesson
Tyson Apostol
Vytas Baskauskas


Cagayan
Spoiler:

Alexis Maxwell
Brice Johnston
Cliff Robinson
David Samson
Garrett Adelstein
Jefra Bland
Jeremiah Wood
J'Tia Taylor
Kass McQuillen
Lindsey Ogle
LJ McKanas
Morgan McLeod
Sarah Lacina
Spencer Bledsoe
Tasha Fox
Tony Vlachos
Trish Hegarty
Woo Hwang


San Juan del Sur
Spoiler:

Alec Christy
Baylor Wilson
Dale Wentworth
Drew Christy
Jaclyn Schultz
Jeremy Collins
John Rocker
Jon Misch
Josh Canfield
Julie McGee
Keith Nale
Kelley Wentworth
Missy Payne
Nadiya Anderson
Natalie Anderson
Reed Kelly
Val Collins
Wes Nale


Worlds Apart
Spoiler:

Carolyn Rivera
Dan Foley
Hali Ford
Jenn Brown
Joaquin Souberbielle
Joe Anglim
Kelly Remington
Lindsey Cascaddan
Max Dawson
Mike Holloway
Nina Poersch
Rodney Lavoie
Shirin Oskooi
Sierra Dawn Thomas
So Kim
Tyler Fredrickson
Vince Sly
Will Sims


Cambodia
Spoiler:

Abi-Maria Gomes
Andrew Savage
Ciera Eastin
Jeff Varner
Jeremy Collins
Joe Anglim
Kass McQuillen
Keith Nale
Kelley Wentworth
Kelly Wiglesworth
Kimmi Kappenberg
Monica Padilla
Peih-Gee Law
Shirin Oskooi
Spencer Bledsoe
Stephen Fishbach
Tasha Fox
Terry Deitz
Vytas Baskauskas
Woo Hwang


Kaoh Rong
Spoiler:

Alecia Holden
Anna Khait
Aubry Bracco
Caleb Reynolds
Cydney Gillon
Darnell Hamilton
Debbie Wanner
Jennifer Lanzetti
Joe Del Campo
Julia Sokolowski
Kyle Jason
Liz Markham
Michele Fitzgerald
Neal Gottlieb
Nick Maiorano
Peter Baggenstos
Scot Pollard
Tai Trang


Millennials vs. Gen X
Spoiler:

Adam Klein
Bret LaBelle
Chris Hammons
Ciandre "CeCe" Taylor
David Wright
Hannah Shapiro
Jessica "Figgy" Figueroa
Jessica Lewis
Justin "Jay" Starrett
Ken McNickle
Lucy Huang
Mari Takahashi
Michaela Bradshaw
Michelle Schubert
Paul Wachter
Rachel Ako
Sunday Burquest
Taylor Stocker
Will Wahl
Zeke Smith


Game Changers
Spoiler:

Andrea Boehlke
Aubry Bracco
Brad Culpepper
Caleb Reynolds
Ciera Eastin
Cirie Fields
Debbie Wanner
Hali Ford
James "J.T." Thomas
Jeff Varner
Malcolm Freberg
Michaela Bradshaw
Ozzy Lusth
Sandra Diaz-Twine
Sarah Lacina
Sierra Dawn Thomas
Tai Trang
Tony Vlachos
Troy "Troyzan" Robertson
Zeke Smith


Good luck. It'd be great to see a lot of rankings completed so that there's an interesting, dynamic overall result.
__________________

Last edited by JerseyWins; 01-06-2017 at 05:25 PM.
JerseyWins is offline   Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
 

Bookmark/share this topic

Tags
alltime, greatest, ranking, survivors, tibb, time


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:48 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
 

About Us ThisisBigBrother.com

"Big Brother and UK Television Forum. Est. 2001"

 

© 2023
no new posts