[JerseyWins]

1. Godfrey (BBCAN3)
2. Emmett (BBCAN1)
3. Jillian (BBCAN1)
4. Talla (BBCAN1)
5. Jon (BBCAN2)
6. Philippe (BBCAN4)
7. Sarah (BBCAN2)
8. Heather (BBCAN2)
9. Loveita (BBCAN4)
10. Nikki (BBCAN4)

Honorable mentions for Bobby/Brittnee/Kenny mainly. Maybe Bruno will crack my top 10 representing BBCAN5 but I don't think so at this point. Dallas is also close to top 10 status for both of his seasons.

[DouglasS]

Did you watch live feeds of BBCAN4, Phil was so awful and arrogant and generally just a tyrant. Can never understand why anyone would like him, Jared or Kelsey just for the self superiority they felt they had.

[JerseyWins]

Lol Phil was a general mess. He was arrogant in a sense that he thought he was playing an incredible game but it was all very, very entertaining to me. Watching him and/or Nick get themselves in a sh*tty position and then managing to squeak by the week anyway was constantly fun to watch. I like the way Phil played... he was very strategic and overall made pretty good decisions but he just lacked the personal relationships or likability with a lot of people. Very unique how the brothers got through the game. So many great moments, his moments with Nikki, cluster**** HOH's, getting fooled by Tim/Cass that they were related, almost self-evicting during the double eviction + the aftermath, etc. Even blaming Nick for everything was typically hilarious to me. Literally a cluster**** of a gamebot.

[DouglasS]

I think Big Brother involves a lot luck to get to the end, especially regarding comp wins, and with Rachel Reilly and Nicole - the luckiest players to ever win Big Brother internationally [Maybe Sarah too as much as I love her, but the twists were moreso in Britnee's favour, Sarah had already won POV].

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

Lol Phil was a general mess. He was arrogant in a sense that he thought he was playing an incredible game but it was all very, very entertaining to me. Watching him and/or Nick get themselves in a sh*tty position and then managing to squeak by the week anyway was constantly fun to watch. I like the way Phil played... he was very strategic and overall made pretty good decisions but he just lacked the personal relationships or likability with a lot of people. Very unique how the brothers got through the game. So many great moments, his moments with Nikki, cluster**** HOH's, getting fooled by Tim/Cass that they were related, almost self-evicting during the double eviction + the aftermath, etc. Even blaming Nick for everything was typically hilarious to me. Literally a cluster**** of a gamebot.

I didn't think Phil was that strategic tbh I think he just got lucky because of his brother who won most of the comps and saved their butt with the speeches but then Kelsey might have helped them win because her speech was umm basic and it felt like she didn't want it at all.

[Raph]

Originally Posted by Raph

Updated Top 10:

1. Naeha BBCAN3 (-)
2. Kenny BBCAN2 (-)
3. Willow BBCAN3 (-)
4. Jordan BBCAN3 (-)
5. Sarah BBCAN3 (-)
6. Cassandra BBCAN4/5 (+2)
7. Alec BBCAN1 (-)
8. William BBCAN5 (NEW)
9. Kevin BBCAN3/5 (-3)
10. Topaz BBBCAN1 (-1)

I should really wait till the end of a season to decide this but updated haha

1. Naeha BBCAN3
2. Kenny BBCAN2
3. Willow BBCAN3
4. Jordan BBCAN3
5. Sarah BBCAN3
6. Alec BBCAN1
7. Neda BBCAN2/BBCAN5
8. Kevin BBCAN3/BBCAN5
9. Cassandra BBCAN4/BBCAN5
10. A toss up between William BBCAN4, Topaz BBCAN1 and Nikki BBCAN4

[Raph]

Ugh Big Brother Canada is sooo goood - combining the nations:

1. Dan BB10USA
2. Naeha BBCAN3
3. Kenny BBCAN2
4. Willow BBCAN3
5. Jordan BBCAN3
6. Sarah BBCAN3
7. Alec BBCAN1
8. Neda BBCAN2/5
9. Kevin BBCAN3/5
10. Cassandra BBCAN4/5

Lololololol only Dan would beat out any of my BBCAN top 9

[JerseyWins]

Interesting, I wonder what my top 10 combined would look like. Too tough to think about right now.

I think mine would be more BBUS dominated tbh but Godfrey would be like top 3 at least and my #1-5 are all worthy enough where it might be 5 each for my top 10. I think I might prefer BBCAN casting as a whole but since there's way more seasons of BBUS, there's still a bunch of characters I like just as much (or more) than BBCAN castings.

[Raph]

Yeah BBCAN casting is sooo damn good. You'd think the US would be better with a larger pool to pick from but I feel like the executive producers of BBUSA are much more shallow allowing for wayy more basic people being cast every year. Hasn't been a good BBUSA cast imo since BB10USA.

[Raph]

Top 10 now that BBCAN5 is over...

1. Naeha Sareen BBCAN3
2. Kenny Brain BBCAN2
3. Jordan Parhar BBCAN3
4. Kevin Martin BBCAN3/5
5. Willow Macdonald BBCAN3
6. Sarah Hanlon BBCAN3
7. Neda Kalantar BBCAN2/BBCAN5
8. Bruno Ielo BBCAN3/BBCAN5
9. Alec Beall BBCAN1
10. Cassandra Shahinfar BBCAN4/BBCAN5

[LemonJam]

Brand new ranking of every houseguest ever, returning appearances ranked seperately

Spoiler:

1. Gary Levy (Season 1)
2. Jon Pardy
3. Karen Singbeil
4. Talla Rajaei
5. Andrew Monaghan
6. Brittnee Blair
7. Sarah Hanlon
8. Bobby Hlad
9. Nikki Grahame
10. Adel Elseri
11. Heather Decksheimer
12. Suzette Amaya
13. Godfrey Mangwiza
14. Dre Gwenaelle
15. Gary Levy (Season 5)
16. Topaz Brady
17. Neda Kalantar (Season 2)
18. Allison White
19. Jillian MacLaughlin
20. Emmett Blois
21. AJ Burman
22. Sarah Miller
23. William Laprise Desbiens
24. Sabrina Abbate
25. Loveita Adams
26. Cassandra Shahinfar (Season 4)
27. Jackie McCurrach
28. Sindy Nguyen (Season 3)
29. Joel Lefevre
30. Raul Manriquez
31. Mitchell Moffit
32. Naeha Sareen
33. Risha Denner
34. Aneal Ramkissoon
35. Danielle Alexander
36. Ashleigh Wood
37. Zach Oleynik
38. Phillipe Paquette
39. Jared Kelser
40. Cassandra Shahinfar (Season 5)
41. Kyle Shore
42. Kelsey Faith
43. Mark Chrysler
44. Dallas Cormier (Season 4)
45. Dallas Cormier (Season 5)
46. Alec Beall
47. Demetres Giannitsos
48. Anick Gervais
49. Ramsey Aburaneh
50. Sharry Ash
51. Paige Distranski
52. Willow MacDonald
53. Johnny Colatruglio
54. Pilar Nemer
55. Ika Wong (Season 2)
56. Nick Paquette
57. Rachelle Diamond
58. Paul Jackson
59. Kat Yee
60. Bruno Ielo (Season 5)
61. Sindy Nguyen (Season 5)
62. Christine Kelsey
63. Jordan Parhar
64. Emily Hawkin
65. Neda Kalantar (Season 5)
66. Bruno Ielo (Season 3)
67. Kevin Martin (Season 3)
68. Kevin Martin (Season 5)
69. Ika Wong (Season 5)
70. Liza Stinton
71. Dillon Carman
72. Andrew Gordon
73. Kenny Brain
74. Tim Dormer
75. Maddy Pavle
76. Peter Brown
77. Graig Merritt
78. Tom Plant
79. Arlie Shaban

[Raph]

ooh i'm gonna do the same later today LJ! Can't believe Arlie is your least favorite of all time though

[JerseyWins]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

1. Godfrey (BBCAN3)
2. Emmett (BBCAN1)
3. Jillian (BBCAN1)
4. Talla (BBCAN1)
5. Jon (BBCAN2)
6. Philippe (BBCAN4)
7. Sarah (BBCAN2)
8. Heather (BBCAN2)
9. Loveita (BBCAN4)
10. Nikki (BBCAN4)

Honorable mentions for Bobby/Brittnee/Kenny mainly. Maybe Bruno will crack my top 10 representing BBCAN5 but I don't think so at this point. Dallas is also close to top 10 status for both of his seasons.

I guess I'd put Bruno in my top 10 (at #10) but not in place of Nikki... I just realized that I think I've overrated Sarah a bit. I love her A LOT but she's kinda forgettable and not really top 10 all-time status in the grand scheme of things. I'd probably rank her exactly #11 though or might change my mind in the future to put her back in the bottom of my top 10.

1. Godfrey (BBCAN3)
2. Emmett (BBCAN1)
3. Jillian (BBCAN1)
4. Talla (BBCAN1)
5. Jon (BBCAN2)
6. Philippe (BBCAN4)
7. Heather (BBCAN2)
8. Loveita (BBCAN4)
9. Nikki (BBCAN4)
10. Bruno (BBCAN5)

I did like Bruno in BBCAN3 too but if I'm ranking him #10 it's strictly for BBCAN5.

[Raph]

1. Naeha Sareen (BBCAN3)
2. Kenny Brain (BBCAN2)
3. Jordan Parhar (BBCAN3)
4. Kevin Martin (BBCAN3/BBCAN5)
5. Willow Macdonald (BBCAN3)
6. Sarah Hanlon (BBCAN3)
7. Neda Kalantar (BBCAN2/BBCAN5)
8. Bruno Ielo (BBCAN3)
9. Alec Beall (BBCAN1)
10. Cassandra Shahinfar (BBCAN4/BBCAN5)
11. Topaz Brady (BBCAN1)
12. Nikki Grahame (BBCAN4)
13. Emmett Blois (BBCAN1)
14. Godfrey Mangwiza (BBCAN3)
15. Talla Rejaei (BBCAN1)
16. Joel Lefevre (BBCAN4)
17. Zach Oleynik (BBCAN3)
18. Demetres Giannitsios (BBCAN5)
19. Mitch Moffit (BBCAN4)
20. Sabrina Abbate (BBCAN2)
21. William Laprise Desbiens (BBCAN5)
22. Arlie Shaban (BBCAN2)
23. Jackie McCurrach (BBCAN5)
24. Rachelle Diamond (BBCAN2)
25. Pilar Nemer (BBCAN3)
26. Ika Wong (BBCAN2/BBCAN5)
27. Kyle Shore (BBCAN2)
28. Allison White (BBCAN2)
29. Bobby Hlad (BBCAN3)
30. Maddy Pavle (BBCAN5)
31. Anick Gervais (BBCAN2)
32. Jon Pardy (BBCAN2)
33. Ashleigh Wood (BBCAN3)
34. AJ Burman (BBCAN1)
35. Suzette Amaya (BBCAN1)
36. Karen Singbeil (BBCAN5)
37. Sharry Ash (BBCAN5)
38. Paige Distranski (BBCAN4)
39. Dre Gwenaelle (BBCAN5)
40. Loveita Adams (BBCAN4)
41. Jillian MacLaughlin (BBCAN1)
42. Adel Elseri (BBCAN1)
43. Sindy Nguyen (BBCAN3/BBCAN5)
44. Tim Dormer (BBCAN4)
45. Jared Kessler (BBCAN4)
46. Graig Merritt (BBCAN3)
47. Ramsey Aburaneh (BBCAN4)
48. Peter Brown (BBCAN1)
49. Liza Stinton (BBCAN1)
50. Dillon Carmon (BBCAN5)
51. Heather Decksheimer (BBCAN2)
52. Emily Hawkin (BBCAN5)
53. Sarah Miller (BBCAN2)
54. Mark Chrysler (BBCAN5)
55. Nick and Phil Pacquette (BBCAN4)
56. Tom Plant (BBCAN1)
57. Gary Levy (BBCAN1/BBCAN5)
58. Risha Denner (BBCAN3)
59. Kat Yee (BBCAN1)
60. Dallas Cormier (BBCAN4/BBCAN5)
61. Johnny Colatruglio (BBCAN3)
62. Andrew Gordon (BBCAN2)
63. Andrew Monaghan (BBCAN1)
64. Kelsey Faith (BBCAN4)
65. Aneal Ramkissoon (BBCAN1)
66. Paul Jackson (BBCAN2)
67. Brittnee Blair (BBCAN3)
68. Christine Kelsey (BBCAN4)
69. Danielle Alexander (BBCAN1)
70. Raul Manriquez (BBCAN4)

[Dominic]

1. Karen Singbeil

[Cal.]

1. Nikki Grahame - S4
2. Ika Wong - S2/S5
3. Gary Levy - S1/S5
4. Naeha Sareen - S3
5. Talla Rajaei - S1
6. Demetres Giannitsos - S5
7. Heather Decksheimer - S2
8. Suzette Amaya - S1
9. Topaz Brady - S1
10. Cassandra Shahinfar - S4

[LemonJam]

Originally Posted by Raph

ooh i'm gonna do the same later today LJ! Can't believe Arlie is your least favorite of all time though

Yeah it was a toss up between him and Tom but I went with Arlie because he's just SUCH a cliche IMO. "Oh look, Arlie is streaking" "Oh look, Arlie is throwing a comp, what a great strategist!" "Oh look, Arlie is having a self-congratulatory moment in the storage room" To me he added essentially nothing to the show while just being insaaanely irritating so yeah he can go.

Honestly though in comparison if I compiled it with BBUS contestants he probably wouldn't even reach to bottom 20.

[reece(:]

1. Nikki
2. Suzette
3. Talla
4. Ika
5. Gary
6. Naeha
7. Sarah
8. Heather
9. Karen
10. Topaz

[DouglasS]

1] Nikki Grahame [BB4]
2] Gary [BB1/BB5]
3] Sarah [BB3]
4] Demetres [BB5]
5] Jon [BB2]
6] Sabrina [BB2]
7] Cassandra [BB4/5]
8] Britneee [BB3]
9] Ika [BB2/5]
10] Mitch [BB4]

Special mentions to; Talla, Suzette, Heather, Adel, Godfrey, Tim, Dre and Karen - On another day some of these would likely swap with 8-10.

[Raph]

Originally Posted by LemonJam

Yeah it was a toss up between him and Tom but I went with Arlie because he's just SUCH a cliche IMO. "Oh look, Arlie is streaking" "Oh look, Arlie is throwing a comp, what a great strategist!" "Oh look, Arlie is having a self-congratulatory moment in the storage room" To me he added essentially nothing to the show while just being insaaanely irritating so yeah he can go.

Honestly though in comparison if I compiled it with BBUS contestants he probably wouldn't even reach to bottom 20.

Haha I feel ya, everyone on BBCAN pretty much is likeable and that's why the show is so great! I can think of sooo many people that I dislike more than people like Brittnee from BBCAN, when it comes to BBUSA - Nicflop, Aryan, Ginamarie, Spencer, Frankie, Kaitlyn... the list goes on.

The BBCAN family

[Raph]

Originally Posted by Cal.

1. Nikki Grahame - S4
2. Ika Wong - S2/S5
3. Gary Levy - S1/S5
4. Naeha Sareen - S3
5. Talla Rajaei - S1
6. Demetres Giannitsos - S5
7. Heather Decksheimer - S2
8. Suzette Amaya - S1
9. Topaz Brady - S1
10. Cassandra Shahinfar - S4

Originally Posted by reece(:

1. Nikki
2. Suzette
3. Talla
4. Ika
5. Gary
6. Naeha
7. Sarah
8. Heather
9. Karen
10. Topaz

I LOVE that Naeha is in both of your top 10's! Queen of BBCAN and my favorite ever female contestant on Big Brother, internationally #Slayha

[Dominic]

Probably something like this

1. Sabrina
2. Ika
3. Brittnee
4. Karen
5. Cassandra
6. Gary
7. Godfrey
8. Nikki
9. Kelsey
10. Suzette

[Maxxie.]

Only properly seen S4 & S5 and seen bits on S3 so only got them (S3 was all stars though so that's peobably fine):

1. Nikki (best housguest from a BBUK perspective)

2. Sarah (only seen clips of her and only know her as a good housemate but she must have been a great player if she ****en won!)

3. Tim (An amazing player for both formats! I'd go as far to even see him as a role model, and I feel I am a better person because of him)

4. Ika (hilarious, entertaining and played a great game without winning comps)

5. Cassandra (betchesssss)

6. William (was fun and I found him really hot which is probably what it was love his accent too

7. Dillon (really likeable, had a good game and should have gone further than 5th, it wasn't his fault that he left, Kevin's really)

8. Kevin (probably tried the hardest of BBCAN5 so therefore deserved to win (after Ika)

9. Gary

10. Joel

Honorable Mentions:
Demetres (was ****ing savage to Neda)
Karen (a North American Jane Connery basically)
Godfrey (now he could manipulate a vote!)

[LemonJam]

Originally Posted by LemonJam

Brand new ranking of every houseguest ever, returning appearances ranked seperately

Spoiler:

1. Gary Levy (Season 1)
2. Jon Pardy
3. Karen Singbeil
4. Talla Rajaei
5. Andrew Monaghan
6. Brittnee Blair
7. Sarah Hanlon
8. Bobby Hlad
9. Nikki Grahame
10. Adel Elseri
11. Heather Decksheimer
12. Suzette Amaya
13. Godfrey Mangwiza
14. Dre Gwenaelle
15. Gary Levy (Season 5)
16. Kaela Grant
17. Topaz Brady
18. Olivia Riemer
19. Neda Kalantar (Season 2)
20. Allison White
21. Jillian MacLaughlin
22. Emmett Blois
23. Veronica Doherty
24. Merron Haille
25. AJ Burman
26. Sarah Miller
27. William Laprise Desbiens
28. Sabrina Abbate
29. Loveita Adams
30. Cassandra Shahinfar (Season 4)
31. Jackie McCurrach
32. Sindy Nguyen (Season 3)
33. Joel Lefevre
34. Raul Manriquez
35. Mitchell Moffit
36. Naeha Sareen
37. Rozina Yaqub
38. Risha Denner
39. Aneal Ramkissoon
40. Maddy Poplett
41. Danielle Alexander
42. Johnny Mulder
43. Ashleigh Wood
44. Zach Oleynik
45. Phillipe Paquette
46. Jared Kelser
47. Alejandra Martinez
48. Cassandra Shahinfar (Season 5)
49. Kyle Shore
50. Kelsey Faith
51. Mark Chrysler
52. Dallas Cormier (Season 4)
53. Dallas Cormier (Season 5)
54. Jesse Larson
55. Alec Beall
56. Demetres Giannitsos
57. Anick Gervais
58. Ramsey Aburaneh
59. Sharry Ash
60. Paige Distranski
61. Willow MacDonald
62. Derek Kesseler
63. Johnny Colatruglio
64. Erica Hill
65. Pilar Nemer
66. Ika Wong (Season 2)
67. Nick Paquette
68. Rachelle Diamond
69. Paul Jackson
70. Andrew Miller
71. Kat Yee
72. Bruno Ielo (Season 5)
73. Sindy Nguyen (Season 5)
74. Christine Kelsey
75. Jordan Parhar
76. Hamza Hatoum
77. Emily Hawkin
78. Neda Kalantar (Season 5)
79. Bruno Ielo (Season 3)
80. Kevin Martin (Season 3)
81. Kevin Martin (Season 5)
82. Ika Wong (Season 5)
83. Liza Stinton
84. Dillon Carman
85. Andrew Gordon
86. Paras Atashnak
87. Kenny Brain
88. Will Kenney
89. Tim Dormer
90. Maddy Pavle
91. Peter Brown
92. Graig Merritt
93. Tom Plant
94. Arlie Shaban

update with BBCAN6~

[Matthew.]

1. Cassandra Shahinfar
2. Tim Dormer
3. Gary Levy
4. Erica Hill
5. Johnny Mulder
6. Olivia Riemer
7. Talla Rajaei
8. Jillian McLaughlan
9. Nikki Grahame
10. Loveita Addams