View Full Version : My Journey Through 35 Seasons of Survivor [COMPLETED - SEASON RANKING NOW]
14 eps, not including the reunion
So literally there are thirteen episodes and then a ninety minute finale?
I was hoping I was closer to the end lol
That was such a strange episode :joker: Such a bizarre twist, as surely the returnees are unlikely to have any traction in the game?
Anyway, I am struggling for favourites in this... I like Jon and Rupert cos of their messiness as characters, and I also think Sandra and Christa are likable.
JerseyWins
15-09-2016, 10:05 PM
Fairplay :love: Sandra after a while :love:
rk3388
15-09-2016, 11:37 PM
Christa and Rupert <3
And Lillian and Fairplay for the entertainment they brought
I did warn you
I know, but I had no idea what you meant (until the very moment it was revealed people were returning :joker:)
I don't understand why Burton and Lil are competing, I thought they had automatic immunity from the first TC?
I am quite happy Rupert went tbh, I'd grown tired of him. I really couldn't stand his arrogance at times. Ok his final confessional was quite sad though.
I really am beginning to really like Jonny Fairplay, he is just TV gold.
Next one looks like a bit of a corker, I hope Jon doesn't leave though?
Just a shame next week's episode is so unmemorable and uneventful
Just a shame next week's episode is so unmemorable and uneventful
You already used that one (or are you being serious this time?)
Jack_
18-09-2016, 09:22 PM
Watch the next episode immediately
FFS I need to have an early night :(
I will watch it tomorrow night.
I just want to reiterate how much I'm looking forward to All-Stars. I know it's rubbishy apparently, I'm just so intrigued to see what it's like.
Macie Lightfoot
18-09-2016, 09:25 PM
MB sometimes lies but sometimes he tells the truth.
Rupert :love: his boot episode is all-time though (but so is just about every episode this season lol), the imagery of the snake crushing the lizard's neck and eating it whole gives me the chills every time. The foreshadowing and symbolism was at an all time high that episode.
Jack_
18-09-2016, 09:26 PM
I felt the same regarding All Stars, I have a bit of a penchant for them :laugh:
I liked it more than I thought I would because of the criticism but it's not amazing by any stretch of the imagination and there's a lot of negatives, both metaphorically and literally.
Oh oops, so Ep11 really is bad? It didn't look it.
MB sometimes lies but sometimes he tells the truth.
:love:
Ep11 is one grand mother of an episode
Ep11 is one grand mother of an episode
Tbh most of the Pearl Islands episodes have been very eventful, compared to say Australia (which, on reflection is possible my second least favourite out of the first seven?)
MB sometimes lies but sometimes he tells the truth.
Rupert :love: his boot episode is all-time though (but so is just about every episode this season lol), the imagery of the snake crushing the lizard's neck and eating it whole gives me the chills every time. The foreshadowing and symbolism was at an all time high that episode.
I don't get whatever symbolism it was meant to be :worry:
rk3388
18-09-2016, 11:00 PM
Is it Jon the snake and Rupert the lizard? Haven't seen the season for years but just a guess
Poor Christa taking the blame :(
Poor Jon with his grandma dying :(
You are joking
Omg Jonny :shocked:
I am gobsmacked :joker:
Macie Lightfoot
19-09-2016, 08:20 PM
where's that snake mother****er Jon
Macie Lightfoot
19-09-2016, 08:20 PM
ain't nobody trust that bitch
Jack_
19-09-2016, 08:23 PM
You are joking
Omg Jonny :shocked:
I am gobsmacked :joker:
One of only three times I've ever literally had my jaw hit the floor when watching a TV show
One of only three times I've ever literally had my jaw hit the floor when watching a TV show
Did it hurt when your jaw literally hit the floor?
(sorry)
I think my favourite part was that production called home to give their condolences and his grandma answered the phone
darrah has to be one of the most irrelevant castaways of all time, and that really says something
You can just see Jeff's disgust with Jon
Macie Lightfoot
19-09-2016, 08:48 PM
One of only three times I've ever literally had my jaw hit the floor when watching a TV show
what were the other two hun...x
Lol I love how Darrah at F6 is like 'people are tryna sway votes, I'm just gonna let people come up to me and see what i can do'.
Yes, because that worked so well for Christy.
Also, I can't believe Helen Glover has never returned :( She was definitely one of my favourites so far.
darrah has to be one of the most irrelevant castaways of all time, and that really says something
Shut your dirty mouth
I was pretty meh on her during my watch but then I realised she was an icon
Macie Lightfoot
19-09-2016, 09:00 PM
Lol I love how Darrah at F6 is like 'people are tryna sway votes, I'm just gonna let people come up to me and see what i can do'.
Yes, because that worked so well for Christy.
being the swing is a really good position to be in though. It just didn't work for Christy because she has absolutely no social tact and got super cocky and literally proudly declared herself as in the driver's seat. She was so off-putting she blew it for herself :love:
being the swing is a really good position to be in though. It just didn't work for Christy because she has absolutely no social tact and got super cocky and literally proudly declared herself as in the driver's seat. She was so off-putting she blew it for herself :love:
This is true I guess. Christy <3 Lmao at her saying at tribal council 'I am in complete control of who goes tonight' when everyone else bar Butch knew full well she was outta there :joker:
Ugh the complex game play is sooo hard to keep up with this season
Jack_
19-09-2016, 09:28 PM
what were the other two hun...x
Two separate scenes on House of Cards :laugh: anyone who watches should know which ones I mean
(I know I said I loved Darrah, but by the same logic, Carter is in my top three of Philippines so maybe I'm not the guy to ask)
Ugh the complex game play is sooo hard to keep up with this season
Then Cambodia will be an... interesting experience for you (which is more than the rest of us can say for it)
can someone give me a teaser about the 'very uncomfortable incident that was not handled well' from All-Stars?
...an unwanted Dick?
I knew you wouldn't disappoint!
I don't see nothing wrong with a little bump 'n' grind
I am glad Lill took a stand against Jon's treatment of her (even if I liked him) :clap1:
I am glad they are finally having the jury members up in order of elimination. Just a little thing that annoyed me :laugh:
I loved Lill's final jury statement :love:
Pearl Islands:
Lillian
Jon
Sandra
Christa
Tijuana
Rupert
Darrah
Trish
Burton
Nicole
Ryan O
Andrew
Ryan S
Michelle
Osten
Shawn
Pretty great cast tbh, and such entertaining episodes :clap1:
It sits in my second tier, below Borneo, on the level of Africa and Marquesas I'd say?
rk3388
21-09-2016, 12:31 AM
Pretty near perfect ranking!
I actually didn't mind Osten and felt for skinny Ryan, but other than those 2 that is very similar to what I would put!
I am watching the start of all-stars now!
How I feel about each person coming back:
Jenna - Yay, loved her.
Sue - Yay, loved her.
Rudy - He was a character, glad he's back.
Richard - He was a staple, it will be interesting to see how his gamplay compares, now the game has changed.
Amber - Meh, she was irrel.
Alicia - Yay, she was robbed.
Colby - Meh, wasn't a fan.
Jerri - Glad.
Tina - I really like her, so glad.
Ethan - I liked him, he was a tad dull though, and not that interested in seeing him again.
Tom & Lex - Not really interested tbh.
Rob M - Yas, I really liked him by the time he was voted out of Marquesas.
Kathy - SO HAPPY. She was robbed :love:
Shii Ann - She too was robbed, and definitely deserved a second chance.
Not too bothered about Rob C, Jenna M and Rupert tbh.
Poor Tina :(
I really enjoyed that tbh, really enjoyed seeing most of them back, and intrigued to see how the game will pan out.
It... pans out, that's for sure
rk3388
21-09-2016, 07:17 PM
All these early seasons just remind me of when the episodes could get 30 million + viewers and everyone at school loved to watch it!
Rob C is much hotter this season lol.
Omg Shii Ann on Richard 'he may not be impressive downstairs, but he's certainly impressive in other ways'.
:joker:
It was so bizarre how Jeff was asking people about their opinions about why Jenna was leaving :umm2:
Omg that is so sad :( Poor Jenna
Richard was hilarious this time, I am kinda gutted he's gone, he was such a troll :laugh:
I am intrigued to see what gets under Sue's skin next time
Macie Lightfoot
25-09-2016, 03:20 PM
well sexual assault might be one thing
What did he actually do? It was glossed over in the episode, and I missed the exact moment when it happened
On a separate note, I genuinely can't see Borneo being topped. It just had that X factor.
Not another quitter. All-Star is such amess :worry: How many episodes?
Jack_
25-09-2016, 04:14 PM
14 + two reunions
Jack_
25-09-2016, 04:16 PM
oops wait no it's 16 + 2 reunions welp
oops wait no it's 16 + 2 reunions welp
16? D:
Jack_
25-09-2016, 05:19 PM
Yeah, it's a long season to get through :laugh:
Macie Lightfoot
25-09-2016, 05:26 PM
yup fasten your seatbelt bc you're in for a loooooooong ride
Ok I feel much worse now, I might've felt okay if I knew I was pretty much half way now :laugh:
Yas Colby's blindside :clap1: Really didn't enjoy him this time, so cocky.
I am loving Jerri as a villain this time :love:
I decided to finish All-Stars - I'm up to Episode 12 now. And my oh my, Alicia is such a bitch :joker: Like initially I found it entertaining, but I am quite sick of her demeanour and the patronizing way she speaks to people - her reaction to the game where the tribe had to identify people of a certain trait was kinda pathetic.
Shii Ann is my current favourite but I know her days are numbered :( In fact I know who the winner and runner up are which is kinda annoying.
Macie Lightfoot
30-10-2016, 03:39 PM
yeah Alicia suuuuuucks
omg Shii Ann winning immunity was such an amazing moment :clap1:
"Oh yeah, there are secrets in this tribe. None about who's going, but there are secrets." The words of a true winner in spirit.
And s t f u Alicia, when Shii Ann was celebrating saying "take that" and Alicia was like "be careful Shii Ann, remember who you have to walk back home with tonight". :bored: Such a bitch.
Alicia and Jenna are both insufferable. They're definitely the two who've fallen furthest from grace in my eyes.
LukeB
30-10-2016, 10:02 PM
Legend Shii Ann
why are none of these airheads realizing they need to get rid of Rob
Would "because it happened thirteen years ago now get onto Vanuatu" be too obvious an answer
Oh Shii Ann </3
I didn't care for her massively in Thailand but she has been sooo good in All-Stars. Calling out horrors such as Alicia and Jenna :clap1: Her speech at her final TC was so good.
And MB, I'm afraid I came back solely for All-Stars. (which, I might add, I am enjoying more than I thought I would - the sheer cut-throatness of it is quite compelling, I just wish Shii Ann hadn't been turned on).
EspeonBB
30-10-2016, 11:03 PM
I hated All Stars tbh. It was a bitter, hate filled season for me (mainly Lex and Kathy but others too) and I think I preferred everyone on their original seasons
reece(:
30-10-2016, 11:04 PM
Jerri scalped but most of the others were trash.
EspeonBB
30-10-2016, 11:07 PM
Yeah Jerri was by far the best :love:
The only other people I liked were Shii Ann, Rupert, Ethan, Jenna M and Rudy lol
Jack_
30-10-2016, 11:12 PM
The problem I had with All Stars is the majority of the people I was looking forward to watching again the most were voted off early (Richard, Rudy, Rob C) and then absolute fodder like Jenna L (literally who?), Tom and Amber made it to the end
It wasn't as bad as I was expecting it to be, but it's still pretty ****ty
Macie Lightfoot
30-10-2016, 11:13 PM
yeah All-Stars was not fun at all. Everyone took things wayyyyyyy too seriously and ended up getting their feelings hurt big time, and like Espeon said everyone just came out of it looking worse. It's right in line with TAR and BBUS with ridiculously underwhelming [first] All-Star seasons.
I hated All Stars tbh. It was a bitter, hate filled season for me (mainly Lex and Kathy but others too) and I think I preferred everyone on their original seasons
But I like it lol, I like it how desperately seriously they're taking it.
Yes, Kathy, Lex, Alicia and Jenna L ruined their reputations big time, but it's kind of entertaining.
Watching the All-Stars final now.
That FTC was so, so brutal. I loved Shii Ann clocking the bitter jurors :clap1: Tom's 'don't be stupid, stupid' was hilariously cruel. Kathy made me cringe, and Lex is a hypocrite. Also, what has Jenna L done to her nose?
All-Stars:
Shii Ann
Jerri
Amber
Ethan
Rob M
Rupert
Sue
Richard
Rudy
Tina
Rob C
Kathy
Jenna M
Jenna L
Colby
Lex
Tom
Alicia
Macie Lightfoot
01-11-2016, 11:21 PM
Shii Annoying using her jury speech as an opportunity to bash everyone for being bitter only to vote for Amber to win :love::love::love:
DouglasS
01-11-2016, 11:47 PM
yeah All-Stars was not fun at all. Everyone took things wayyyyyyy too seriously and ended up getting their feelings hurt big time, and like Espeon said everyone just came out of it looking worse. It's right in line with TAR and BBUS with ridiculously underwhelming [first] All-Star seasons.
I loved TAR Allstars 1 :laugh:
Mirna and Charla were such legends that season and compelled me until the very end. I also liked all the drama in the season
rk3388
02-11-2016, 04:07 AM
I loved TAR Allstars 1 :laugh:
Mirna and Charla were such legends that season and compelled me until the very end. I also liked all the drama in the season
YES! This was the first season I watched and I remember loving those two.
reece(:
02-11-2016, 04:38 AM
XNdl4IPwAiE
What's the consensus on Vanuatu? I kinda knew this would happen but I couldn't resist starting it. I'm watching it kinda casually.
I don't like how they've got 18 castaways - too many. I'm halfway through Ep2.
**** YOU GOOGLE!!!! Just saw who the runner up of Vanuatu is :bored:
The last fecking season I saw where I had no idea who got to the end was Marquesas :rolleyes:
I can't believe the runner-up of Vanuatu became a porn star
reece(:
03-11-2016, 05:37 PM
What's the consensus on Vanuatu? I kinda knew this would happen but I couldn't resist starting it. I'm watching it kinda casually.
I don't like how they've got 18 castaways - too many. I'm halfway through Ep2.
There's 20 in later seasons :joker:
And there's 24 in Australian Survivor, if you ever feel sadistic enough
Oh I kinda liked Dolly :/ But she should have known it's never a good decision to play two sides of a tribe.
Jack_
03-11-2016, 06:09 PM
**** YOU GOOGLE!!!! Just saw who the runner up of Vanuatu is :bored:
The last fecking season I saw where I had no idea who got to the end was Marquesas :rolleyes:
Stop Googling things until you've finished a season :joker: and even then don't bother, I've ended up spoiling future winners by reading Wiki entries for a season
It's just hilarious how the girls immediately imparted to John how they'd voted last time :laugh:
ok that TC with Ami saying how Twila should get in touch with her feminine side has made me love them both :love:
Love the drama between Twila and Mia (is that her name?) too
Okay well that feud was over quickly
I liked Lisa :(
Vanuatu is quite good so far tbf.
As much as I'm glad that Twila and Julie survived on Lopevi, idg the guys' logic in not voting out a woman.. I also liked John so it's a shame he's gone.
One thing I don't like about this seaon is the messy editing - the first three men to go went with next to no airtime.
I've realised who Eliza reminds me of:
http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2013/06/07/article-2337211-05240447000005DC-484_634x443.jpg
Eliza deserves so much better than to be compared to that little imp, how dare you
Macie Lightfoot
08-11-2016, 10:47 PM
the whole Shii Ann/Christy/Eliza archetype of plucky underdogs who are actually SUPER grating :love::love::love:
I looove Shii Ann (for All-Stars) and Christy, Eliza is kinda meh to me.
JerseyWins
09-11-2016, 07:31 PM
Eliza >>>>>>>> Christy and idk who Shi Ann is tbh.
Okay Twila is actually really obnoxious, and Scout disappointed me when they were both laughing at Eliza when she was annoyed about them hiding food
Side note - Vanuatu is realllly bad for rootable characters
What does Scout mean 'rediscover your roots Jules, go back to your roots...' :unsure:
Eliza's vote-off was so cruel. Chris and Twila's nonchalance was pretty disgusting :bored:
Vanuatu:
Eliza
Scout
Julie
Lisa
Ami
Mia
Chris
John K
Rory
Dolly
LeAnn
Chad
Travis
John P
Brady
Brooke
Twila
Sarg
Well, Vanuatu is an interesting one. It was entertaining enough throughout and I loved the FTC - Twila's final statement was so emotional, I had to ensure it didn't make me forget I hated her for most of the season. However, the casting was pretty bad.
I honestly didn't strongly like anyone, and there were so many meh, wishy-washy characters, and a few who didn't even seem to make the edit.
Just watched the first like 60 seconds of Palau and even more ew at 20 castaways :umm2: It's simply too many.
Macie Lightfoot
09-11-2016, 11:38 PM
Twila hate is UNACCEPTABLE
Jack_
09-11-2016, 11:38 PM
My mind will forever boggle at the fact Julie and Jeff dated for four years
Twila hate is UNACCEPTABLE
As well as quite common I'd imagine.
My mind will forever boggle at the fact Julie and Jeff dated for four years
Why? According to Wiki she was let on the show solely because of him.
Two episodes into Palau - I much prefer this cast on first impressions; seems like a much more interesting, eclectic mix.
Don't really have a favourite so far - wish Jolanda had stayed, she seemed like a big characcter. James is an ass. I'm not sure if I liked the twist in Episode 1 - very gimmicky and unfair.
Wanda will have her revenge one day
Wanda will have her revenge one day
She returns in Season 11 doesn't she? :laugh:
I knew that 2 Palau players return for 11, and 15 mins into Palau I'm pretty sure I knew who who they are
I... erm... probably wouldn't get my hopes up if I were you
Imagine Wanda being the Stepheme-esque villain of Guatemala <3
Not four votes in a single episode :omgno:
Also, Angie was kinda screwed over by that unnecessary immunity twist.
Macie Lightfoot
11-11-2016, 05:09 PM
As well as quite common I'd imagine.
Not really? I think a lot of the Survivor community views her as someone veeeeery similar to Sue Hawk. I think Sue's the stronger character, but Twila has the stronger storyline and is possibly even more Raw N Real.
Not really? I think a lot of the Survivor community views her as someone veeeeery similar to Sue Hawk. I think Sue's the stronger character, but Twila has the stronger storyline and is possibly even more Raw N Real.
She's soo obnoxious and nasty tho :laugh: I can see the Sue Hawk similarity.
I'm really liking Palau. It's what I'd imagine Survivor is like nowadays?
Also, Bobby Jon is so goddamn hot.
JerseyWins
11-11-2016, 07:54 PM
Palau was pretty good on the tribe that Stephenie & Bobby Jon were on. The other tribe made it meh.
reece(:
11-11-2016, 08:03 PM
Palau was pretty good on the tribe that Stephenie & Bobby Jon were on. The other tribe made it meh.
Let Janu live
Macie Lightfoot
11-11-2016, 08:10 PM
I think Koror is a much more interesting tribe :3 and I'm very whatever on Palau as a season. It's great on a first watch bc of the obvious reasons but after that, eh.
EspeonBB
11-11-2016, 08:29 PM
Steph is by far my fave from Palau but I thought Koror was better as a tribe too
Macie Lightfoot
11-11-2016, 08:40 PM
http://tinyurl.com/cepqkps
Yeah I think Koror is better, cos it has crazy Janu and Caryn, and bitchy Katie. It's a much better mix, whereas Ulong was mainly the good-looking people.
lol just starting my sixth episode of Palau today, I have no classes on Friday, that's my excuse
lmao, I love how they didn't do the merge at F10, seemingly to give Ulong a final chance to win, only for them to lose again.
On a side note, expecting a merge and it not happening sucks.
Oh Bobby Jon you will be missed </3 I just (accidentally) found out he returns for Guatemala, so at least that's something.
I don't want any spoiler/confirmation but I feel it's pretty obvious Steph will win from her popularity on here and the way the edit has gone?
Anyway, here's how I'd rank the Final 9:
1. Steph
2. Janu
3. Coby (he's messy)
4. Jenn
5. Katie
6. Gregg
7. Ian
8. Caryn
9. Tom
Janu's so ****ing messy :joker:
Chundering on the reward and then nibbling on the desert they brought back for the other tribemates, and then quitting the challenge as soon as Jeff says 'are you beginning to panic?'
Okay that was a literal jaw-drop moment! I was sooo convinced Steph was the winner of Palau
Macie Lightfoot
12-11-2016, 10:50 PM
I mean... lol it was literally eight against one so she would have had to win every Immunity Challenge, and then win over a jury of people she only spent like two weeks with.
I mean... lol it was literally eight against one so she would have had to win every Immunity Challenge, and then win over a jury of people she only spent like two weeks with.
The edit made it look like Caryn was gonna go though, and the whole series so far felt like it was Survivor: The Tale of Stephenie, about how she battled the elements and overcame the odds... Am I the only one who saw this? :joker:
I felt like she was gonna pull a Chris.
Also, it's not like Koror were overly tight - Steph seemed quite popular amongst them.
Probst I feel turns into a bigger nob every season.
'You guys are laughing, I'm serious, we're getting down to the nitty gritty here for a million bucks!!'
:rolleyes:
That F5 TC was honestly one of the best I've seen in all ten seasons of Survivor I've seen - so much drama! And finally we saw the return of crazy Caryn..
I was ready for Ian to go though, I'm not a big fan.
Katie's actually really grown on me and I kinda want her to win now, or Jenn.
Poor Jen :( ---- Just found out she was 32, I'm so shocked!
Ian is such a weasel, my god
I might also add, with about 50 minutes left, I think Palau may be a contender for my favourite season yet.
Poor Jen :( ---- Just found out she was 32, I'm so shocked!
It's sad to think that she seemed younger than she was when the rest of her life turned out as it did </3
(yeah Palau's pretty dark but it's a good first watch. I won't say anything else but you'll probably enjoy the next immunity challenge)
Macie Lightfoot
13-11-2016, 04:57 PM
Poor Jen :( ---- Just found out she was 32, I'm so shocked!
Ian is such a weasel, my god
that's not gonna be the only time you say poor Jenn, unfortunately :(
that's not gonna be the only time you say poor Jenn, unfortunately :(
Is it a Survivor spoiler? Or is it something worse?
Just found out, that's so sad :(
Macie Lightfoot
13-11-2016, 05:23 PM
She died, dude.
She died, dude.
I know. Very sad, as I said
Trust Troy to manage to throw in a Pearl Islands reference there ey
(but yes, sad)
Trust Troy to manage to throw in a Pearl Islands reference there ey
(but yes, sad)
Oh lol how did i not recongize that
I think i will rank the seasons after I finish this.
Daniel.
13-11-2016, 05:34 PM
I wanna watch pearl islands because ive heard its grea
I wanna watch pearl islands because ive heard its grea
It is really good :love: Do you watch Survivor?
Daniel.
13-11-2016, 05:37 PM
No nor BBUS but I wanna watch both
Macie Lightfoot
13-11-2016, 05:38 PM
I wanna watch pearl islands because ive heard its grea
DANIEL WATCH omfg it's up there as an all-time great season of reality TV. Like, BBUK6 and ANTM3 and [insert best season of whatever other franchise you want] levels of good.
Macie Lightfoot
13-11-2016, 05:38 PM
BBUS you can easily pass on though lol
Daniel.
13-11-2016, 05:39 PM
DANIEL WATCH omfg it's up there as an all-time great season of reality TV. Like, BBUK6 and ANTM3 and [insert best season of whatever other franchise you want] levels of good.
My favourite seasons of RTV are BB6 and BB5 UK so sounds good! Is it better than the best BBUS and best BBUK season?
I'd watch Borneo first. Borneo as a season is so great; I love how it starts so innocent and then unfolds into devious backstabbing, betrayal and Snakes & Rats.
Macie Lightfoot
13-11-2016, 05:41 PM
BBUS without a doubt, BBUK it's tough to compare bc of the different formats and airing schedules (14 episodes of Survivor versus like... 60 episodes of BBUK at minimum) but Pearl Islands is essential viewing. And a lot of other seasons too tbh.
Daniel.
13-11-2016, 05:44 PM
I guess I should start with whatever seasons would suit me best which seems to be Pearl Islands? then go fro the.
I guess I should start with whatever seasons would suit me best which seems to be Pearl Islands? then go fro the.
Borneo is the first season and is like universally loved (and also essential viewing).
reece(:
13-11-2016, 05:48 PM
You'll probably enjoy high drama seasons too like Nicaragua, China, Gabon, Cagayan, Panama etc
Daniel.
13-11-2016, 05:51 PM
whats your fave rice
whats your fave rice
Palau/Pilau
whats your fave rice
Eat yo rice
reece(:
13-11-2016, 05:56 PM
whats your fave rice
Gabon or China
Macie Lightfoot
13-11-2016, 06:16 PM
Tom do you know who besides Bobby Jon returns for Guatemala or should I just shut up
Tom do you know who besides Bobby Jon returns for Guatemala or should I just shut up
I don't and I'd rather not know! Praying it's Steph tho :fc:
Palau:
Stephenie
Janu
Katie
Jenn
James
Bobby Jon
Tom
Caryn
Jolanda
Kim
Angie
Jeff
Ashlee
Gregg
Ibrehem
Willard
Coby
Ian
Brilliant season! Definitely one of the best casts of Survivor, and I just found it to be relentlessly entertaining. :love: Not quite the ending I'd have hoped for, but at least it wasn't Ian - Tom was a nice guy with a good game, and I should have known realistically Katie had no chance :laugh: Also, I think Stephenie may be my favourite castaway of all time... Up there with Kathy (Marquesas), Christy (Amazon) and Shii-Ann (All-Stars).
Season Rankings
Palau
Borneo
Marquesas
Pearl Islands
Africa
The Austrlian Outback
The Amazon
Vanuatu
Thailand/All-Stars
Love
Like
Meh
Jack_
13-11-2016, 07:04 PM
Steph is literally the ideal woman :love:
Macie Lightfoot
13-11-2016, 07:12 PM
Imagine sitting through Palau and having Ian Rosenberger as your least favorite of the season.
Imagine sitting through Palau and having Ian Rosenberger as your least favorite of the season.
v v annoying
i am watching ep 1 of Guatemala now cos i wanna know who returns, what is my life
Imagine sitting through Palau and having Ian Rosenberger as your least favorite of the season.
who are your faves/least faves of Palau?
Might not wanna go around calling him BJ
Macie Lightfoot
13-11-2016, 07:53 PM
yeah that's gay and retarded (TM)
ugh s11e02 appears to be missing.
have i missed anything important by skipping it?
Macie Lightfoot
14-11-2016, 09:57 PM
here's a link
http://www.alluc.ee/l/Survivor-S11E02-PDTV-XviD-TCM-avi/qbyvkvm
here's a link
http://www.alluc.ee/l/Survivor-S11E02-PDTV-XviD-TCM-avi/qbyvkvm
Thanks, but it's not working? At least for me
hmm must be the uni internet service :(
ah well, is ep2 a big loss?
Another link here (http://daclips.in/embed-nz88qg7bepbh-960x500.html)
(I hope that link works, because otherwise I'll come round and reenact the bloody episode myself)
(I hope that link works, because otherwise I'll come round and reenact the bloody episode myself)
Nope! I'll PM you my address!!
I just realised Guatemala doesn't really have any ethnic minorities.. Idk if Lydia counts?
This would surely never happen now?
What do people think of Steph saying 'Bobby Jon gets so gay, I can't stand it!'
She's not the same this time :( Seems a bit controlling and superior.
wtf is wrong with Bobby Jon :laugh: He's just so...weird. Like his reactions to losing immunity are often just so bizarre
I might also just say, I don't think Guatemala is holding up terribly well against Palau for me. What do others think of it?
Could someone do me a favour? The final speech of Blake was cut out of the episode, so could someone lmk who voted for who, as idk where to find it spoiler free?...
reece(:
15-11-2016, 09:04 PM
Brandon and Blake for Brian and Amy, Brian, Bobby Jon, Gary and Danni for Blake
Brandon and Blake for Brian and Amy, Brian, Bobby Jon, Gary and Danni for Blake
Thank you Reece!!
Not Margaret </3
Judd is just abhorrent and an embarrassment. A typical case of a dimwit intimidated by someone intelligent and eloquent and as a result all they do in response is shout aggressively. Fool.
reece(:
15-11-2016, 10:29 PM
Margaret :love:
rk3388
15-11-2016, 11:19 PM
I thought it was a good season! I agree I went off Steph and not defending her actions AT ALL but it was a very different time back then so I feel like people could get away with the comments she made more easily.
rk3388
15-11-2016, 11:19 PM
So I feel like she still had a lot of fan support
I thought it was a good season! I agree I went off Steph and not defending her actions AT ALL but it was a very different time back then so I feel like people could get away with the comments she made more easily.
I definitely think the season has gotten better as it goes. I mean Steph hasn't massively gone down in my estimation, but I think the initial reason a lot of us loved her because she was an underdog - this time she's quite the opposite and so of course acts differently.
Amy is my current favourite. I like Lydia, Bobby Jon, Steph and did like Brian and Margaret.
Jack_
15-11-2016, 11:35 PM
Steph's definitely more rootable as an underdog I agree but she's still amezzin :love: I found Guatemala a decent enough season but
(don't click this Tom)
No really, don't. You have been warned!
I was blindsided by the result and such fodder winning really sours the ending
Ok I went to find out if Lindsey Richter ever returns bc it means a lot and I'm v upset by the answer
reece(:
16-11-2016, 12:42 AM
Yas Amy :love:
rk3388
16-11-2016, 12:45 AM
And be pumped for Panama <3 Under-rated season. Easily top 10
Steph's definitely more rootable as an underdog I agree but she's still amezzin :love: I found Guatemala a decent enough season but
(don't click this Tom)
No really, don't. You have been warned!
I was blindsided by the result and such fodder winning really sours the ending
um Danni is not fodder wash your mouth out
why why why did Amy have to go :( Three of my favourites have literally gone in a row!
Ah well, I'm glad it's the merge now.
Guatemala is really warming up now :love: I LOVE the Bobby Jon/Jamie feud :laugh:
Jamie is messy. Even picking fights with Cindy and Gary now
Yas Jamie's blindside :clap1: Seeing the look on Juddas' face was awesome.
Guatemala has truly flourished! Didn't look set to be a good season in the first few episodes, but it's thoroughly enjoyable now.
Current faves: Cindy, Steph and Gary (for his underdog status).
Lydia clocking Stephenie :clap1: Really didn't like Steph's reaction to the reward/food situation.
ugh really wanted Gary to stay, glad he outed Judd's lie at TC.
Judd is just vile. Genuinely my most hated Survivor contestant in the first 11 seasons.
normally i'd be sooo happy if a twat like Judd was voted out but the fact he gets an opportunity to rip into the finalists on the jury takes that satisfaction away
Guatemala:
Amy
Stephenie
Danni
Bobby Jon
Lydia
Brian
Margaret
Gary
Cindy
Rafe
Brooke
Morgan
Brandon
Brianna
Jim
Jamie
Blake
Judd
Really wasn't sure about Guatemala initially, but it got really interesting after the merge, and the cast really came into their own.
Danni, although I liked her, was a bit of a meh winner.
I think a good 75% of why I like Danni so much is because she's a dead ringer for The Pricey
That's so sad about Tina's son :( I like her so far - she reminds me of Kathy. I like Cirie too: "I didn't know I was old?!" :joker:
Not-so-fun fact: Tina was supposed to be in Guatemala but pulled out when her son died
Not an Episode 2 tribe switch
I'm not really hooked on Panama yet, even though it's really entertaining. I think it's cos I don't have time to watch it much cos I'm busy at uni atm.
My favourites 5 episodes in are Cirie, maybe Shane (for the comedy villian factor) and maybe Aras?
EspeonBB
21-11-2016, 10:52 PM
Panama is amazing :love: Cirie is one my fave RTV contestants ever and Shane & Courtney are hilarious messes too
Really the entire Casaya tribe is hilarious
That would have been a reaaaally tense vote off had I not known that Aras wins in the end. Y'know how I know? A task in TIBB Survivor :laugh:
I'd grown to like Austin, shame he's gone.
Here's a ranking of the Final 8:
Cirie
Courtney
Sally
Danielle
Shane
Bruce
Terry
Aras
I actually find this group really likeable. Panama has posed the question to me though... without an Episode 4/5 tribe switch, will there ever be any real post-merge power shift?
screaming @ Bruce shunning Courtney's singing
Also, Shane's entitlement really annoys me
rk3388
23-11-2016, 06:05 PM
Shane and Courtney's secret sexual tension <3 :joker:
Courtney praying that Danielle goes at F4 TC is a scream
Macie Lightfoot
24-11-2016, 09:27 PM
Danielle :love: Courtney :love: Panama :love:
Terry ****ing suuucks though but he's the only one pretty much?
reece(:
24-11-2016, 09:29 PM
Cirie, Courtney, Bruce, Shane, Sally <3
Danielle :love: Courtney :love: Panama :love:
Terry ****ing suuucks though but he's the only one pretty much?
Why do you hate Terry? I think I just about prefer him to Aras.
LukeB
24-11-2016, 09:31 PM
You're nearly on China where you will see the best Courtney ever. :love: (not a returnee)
You're nearly on China where you will see the best Courtney ever. :love: (not a returnee)
I can't wait for the S15-17 run which I've heard is really good, and HvV.
reece(:
24-11-2016, 09:43 PM
15-17 is the best run <3
Courtney's jury speech is perhaps one of my favourite of all time <3
I love how she told them what lessons they'd learned after they asked her question about that :laugh:
"I'm not gonna have chips on my shoulder, cos chips way you down, and I'm a bird, and birds gotta fly"
Shane's was really intense too :worry:
EspeonBB
24-11-2016, 10:41 PM
I can't wait for the S15-17 run which I've heard is really good, and HvV.
Yeah all of these seasons are great <3
After that it declines a lot but it does recover with 25 & 28-29
Yeah all of these seasons are great <3
After that it declines a lot but it does recover with 25 & 28-29
How's the current season? :)
EspeonBB
24-11-2016, 10:46 PM
How's the current season? :)
Absolutely terrible (although I haven't watched the last 3 eps)
Panama - Exile Island:
Cirie
Courtney
Danielle
Terry
Bruce
Sally
Tina
Austin
Shane
Aras
Misty
Ruth Marie
Melinda
Dan
Nick
Bobby
Panama was a pretty good season. Not the best, but no where near the worst. I loved the whole EI/immunity idol twist. Lots of great characters as well! The gameplay wasn't as interesting this year - for a good while it was just 'how long can Terry et al survive?'
Absolutely terrible (although I haven't watched the last 3 eps)
(the last 2 eps have been an improvement but the words 'polish' and 'turd' come to mind)
rk3388
25-11-2016, 04:29 AM
GABON <3 Crystal Cox, Kenny, Sugar and Matty are all favourites. Randy was also great when he didn't try so hard. S/O to Susie and Ace for providing entertainment that season too ugh such a great cast
JerseyWins
25-11-2016, 05:20 AM
Cirie & Shane were absolute gold. Courtney is pretty damn annoying but without her (and Danielle) then Shane probably provides less drama & entertainment so whatever. It was a pretty fun season with them as, like, frenemies.
Also, as said... China Courtney is the best Courtney. :clap1:
Macie Lightfoot
25-11-2016, 05:30 AM
You people are talking about The Best Courtney as if Courtney Marit isn't a top 30 Survivor or something
http://static.gofugyourself.com/uploads/2006/09/43421_71729723.jpg
Macie Lightfoot
25-11-2016, 04:16 PM
Why do you hate Terry? I think I just about prefer him to Aras.
He's a smug, condescending jerk with no self-awareness. Like aside from his general selfish, pretentious, entitled, judgmental nature, his lecture to Aras after the family visit reward about how some relationships are more valuable than others and his relationship with his wife is inherently more important than Aras's relationship with his mom was legit disgusting. Also, "maybe one day your conscience will speak up and tell you you should've taken the Navy pilot" like how can someone be so self-unaware???
Also, part of this comes from watching live but oh my goddddd Probst jerking himself off to Terry every week and good portion of the audience doing so was nauseating. Not only did he get away with being a smug and entitled jerk because he's An All-American Hero, but of course it turned into people thinking he was actually a great player because he made it to the F3 literally only by going on an IC streak? He's a prideful douche was zero skills at the game. Every time he tried to make a move he presented himself as "hey I'm going to offer you the opportunity to be at the bottom of my alliance :smug:" so no wonder why everyone hated your guts?
Basically, it comes down to the fact that Terry was ridiculously ****ing arrogant despite NEVER being in a position of power, and as you'll soon see with Cook Islands, I give Terry a lot of credit for ruining part of the modern Survivor format :)
He's a smug, condescending jerk with no self-awareness. Like aside from his general selfish, pretentious, entitled, judgmental nature, his lecture to Aras after the family visit reward about how some relationships are more valuable than others and his relationship with his wife is inherently more important than Aras's relationship with his mom was legit disgusting. Also, "maybe one day your conscience will speak up and tell you you should've taken the Navy pilot" like how can someone be so self-unaware???
Also, part of this comes from watching live but oh my goddddd Probst jerking himself off to Terry every week and good portion of the audience doing so was nauseating. Not only did he get away with being a smug and entitled jerk because he's An All-American Hero, but of course it turned into people thinking he was actually a great player because he made it to the F3 literally only by going on an IC streak? He's a prideful douche was zero skills at the game. Every time he tried to make a move he presented himself as "hey I'm going to offer you the opportunity to be at the bottom of my alliance :smug:" so no wonder why everyone hated your guts?
Basically, it comes down to the fact that Terry was ridiculously ****ing arrogant despite NEVER being in a position of power, and as you'll soon see with Cook Islands, I give Terry a lot of credit for ruining part of the modern Survivor format :)
Hmm interesting. Being smug (which he was, I agree) isn't such a crime, is it? Also, yes, he was never in power, but he did try and make some moves such as at the Final 8 which I think he deserves credit for.
The family reward thing was really bad though I agree - however it was balanced out (in fact, Aras was worse) when Aras accused him of misogyny.
Macie Lightfoot
25-11-2016, 05:18 PM
It kind of is? Every Terry moment turned into a gigantic lecture either to the other players or to the audience about how he's the 46 year old with life experience and he's the mature one, and poor Terry for having to live with all these insufferable 24 year olds (even though they often displayed more maturity than him.)
Not to mention that being so smug all the damn time and having zero humility is precisely why he couldn't gain any leverage in the game and he was perpetually at the bottom. He literally offered people to be at the bottom of his alliance and then was completely dumbfounded when they just laughed in his face and openly mocked him.
Macie Lightfoot
25-11-2016, 05:30 PM
Other examples of Terry's suckitude: his lecturing of Cirie for where she put her torch after Shane's vote off, his godawful jury speech, throwing a temper tantrum when Aras beat him in the ropes reward challenge, and that's all with me not having watched Panama in years.
reece(:
25-11-2016, 05:32 PM
And then his hero arc on Cambodia (even without the family emergency) even though he was on the bottom the whole time ((YET AGAIN))
Macie Lightfoot
25-11-2016, 05:37 PM
I'll put this in spoilers even though it's not about a specific season but more of a Survivor format change, but
I place a lot of the blame on Terry's existence for the show's switch to a final three :rolleyes:
I'll put this in spoilers even though it's not about a specific season but more of a Survivor format change, but
I place a lot of the blame on Terry's existence for the show's switch to a final three :rolleyes:
oh i read it, and ew
EspeonBB
25-11-2016, 07:29 PM
Would Terry even have won if it was a final 3? Yes the La Minas would've voted for him but the Casayas hated his guts and would've voted for Aras/Danielle over him
I actually really liked Aras in Panama and if Cirie couldn't win I was glad that he did (plus he's super hot which helps)
Omg JP is so freakin' hot. That's all I have to say three episodes into Cook Islands.
Macie Lightfoot
28-11-2016, 05:16 PM
that's probably all you'll have to say after you finish the season......x
I've just restarted Cook Islands! On Episode 4.
vBulletin® v3.8.11, Copyright ©2000-2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.