[Tom]

Just interested into which category most people fit

[Stacey.]

Like her.

[Legend killer]

Can't stand her

[MTVN]

Love her.

[Kerry]

Indifferent for me. She's likable but I couldn't care if she vanished from our stages

[Z]

I think she's quite cool, the kind of person you'd love to call a friend, she seems very funny and sharp; but she's very tame as a judge on the live shows which is where it counts, IMO, she's too scared of media backlash over any kind of negativity to give proper criticism of people, whereas Louis, Dannii and (formerly) Simon couldn't give a toss what the media says about them.

[Shaun]

she's dull. and pointless. and overexposed. and untalented.

[Jordan.]

Like.

[Beastie]

Overall I like her. Not sure if I am keen on her winning the X Factor 3 years in a row though!

[GiRTh]

Unprintable.

[Livia]

I think Cheryl is a really lovely looking girl. That's it. That's all she's got to offer. She's not a fabulous singer, she's not a talented writer or musician, she hasn't got any experience of anything except having her photo taken and "singing" in an over-produced girl band. Being pretty is the only contribution she makes. She is decorative but pointless.

[Ammi]

Originally Posted by Livia

I think Cheryl is a really lovely looking girl. That's it. That's all she's got to offer. She's not a fabulous singer, she's not a talented writer or musician, she hasn't got any experience of anything except having her photo taken and "singing" in an over-produced girl band. Being pretty is the only contribution she makes. She is decorative but pointless.

Agree with this. As part of a girl band she was ok and as the face of L'Oreal she's fine because she has got lovely hair and she is very attractive - but thats where it ends. To me she's just a prettier, younger Katie Price - everything she does seems to be carefully planned to court the media and gain attention. I find it hard have any respect anyone who does not offer anything back except a pretty face

[cub]

I think there's more to her than being pretty. As a judge she's far better (far, far better) than Mrs Overall, I mean Osbourne. She speaks a lot of sense.

Dannii, for example, is being too nice this year.

[Crimson Dynamo]

Originally Posted by Livia

I think Cheryl is a really lovely looking girl. That's it. That's all she's got to offer. She's not a fabulous singer, she's not a talented writer or musician, she hasn't got any experience of anything except having her photo taken and "singing" in an over-produced girl band. Being pretty is the only contribution she makes. She is decorative but pointless.

this

[M X]

Love her.
She's from very humble beginnings and she's made such a success of her life, it's been nice to watch her rise to super stardom.

[joeysteele]

I can't stand her at all but that's all I am saying now since it appears you should only go on threads of Cheryl if you like her and praise her for fear of being insulted by her supporters.
However, this thread asks what we think of her and I dare bet more won't like her than will.

[\PJ/]

I love her,if im honest the only people who seem to HATE her is dog rough plain girls there so jealous.

[Livia]

Originally Posted by \PJ/

I love her,if im honest the only people who seem to HATE her is dog rough plain girls there so jealous.

Oh... please. Grow up and stop making yourself look stupid.

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by Livia

Oh... please. Grow up and stop making yourself look stupid.

Well said Livia, I am an 18year old guy, so I also don't fit into the generalised category from the poster either. Still its more evidence of the blinkered logic of Cheryl rules all.

[\PJ/]

CHERYL RULES ALL.
That is going in my signature thanks for that Joeysteele,im also 18 and male what has that got to do with anything? LOL

[Callum]

Love her, but I do see why people would hate her.

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by \PJ/

I love her,if im honest the only people who seem to HATE her is dog rough plain girls there so jealous.

????? Well, you are the one who made the above comment that the only people who hate her are dog rough plain girls which actually is a very derogatory comment in itself, but, since I am not female I certainly don't fit into your category of who should be someone who hates Cheryl.
So what do you not understand to my comment?

You say(in your comment above,grossly insulting it is to some ladies too), only the above rather insultingly described by you are people who seem to hate Cheryl.
As I am not one of those so then 'you' must be wrong in your generalisation, what's not to understand about that???

[\PJ/]

I get it now you need to calm down aswell.

[red]

Originally Posted by \PJ/

CHERYL RULES ALL.
That is going in my signature thanks for that Joeysteele,im also 18 and male what has that got to do with anything? LOL

.....

[_Seth]

I'm quite indifferent.