[DrunkerThanMoses]

Is he boring?

[Stephanie]

yes

[Jords]

Yeah sort of, compared to Jedward, Stacey, and Olly, who have big personalities.
But his singing is very good, and want him to be in the final with Stace and Danyl, or to keep everybody else happy, Olly

[Ross]

He's not boring at all.
He just doesn't need to have an annoying laugh or have weird hair to get noticed.

[Princess]

He's not boring!He's sweet and lovely.

[Jords]

Im sort of inbetween on the poll. I dont find him boring, but not as entertaining personality-wise as others.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

I jsut find his performances very forgetful.

[Novo]

Cheryl summed him up

He hasn't got a big personality at all he just goes out there and gets the job done
He will start getting more confident now though as more and more people go he will be noticed more

[MrGaryy]

yes, he's ridiculously dull.

[MarkWaldorf]

I think Ross is right. In a series full of scandal and media intrusion, Joe is one of the few who hasn't relied on what he says or does to get him noticed. He's also 18, so I don't think he has much life experience to appear edgy or what not. He's beating all the odds though and is the best vocalist there. Good for him.

[Z]

It's a shame, because he comes across as boring in comparison to all of the big personalities he's up against. He's very consistent, but I kind of wish he would either completely smash a performance or have one bad week; because it seems almost unnatural that he's been delivering decent performances every week. I know that's a strange criticism to make, but it's just what I think when I see him perform; it's good, it's alright, but his performances never make you rave on about how good he is, or how bad he is, there's just nothing to talk about other than "it was okay".

[kellybsblover]

I've been in love with the kid since he's first audition. He is absolutely amazing to begin with and will only get better!

[CaraRawr]

Joe isn't boring at all. Just because he isn't loud and in-your-face doesn't mean he has no personality. If you watch any backstage videos with him in them, you'll see that he's actually very sweet and genuine and by no means boring. So I agree with Ross and Mark <3

[Stacey.]

very boringg GET JOE OUT!

[Fom]

I don't find him boring and I think he will win.

[LemonJam]

For the record, I don't find his personality boring, just his voice.

[alc09]

So ****ing boring it's unreal, good singer though.

[Harry!]

Dull as dishwater

[aiv]

He's a good singer but he should move a bit.

[Firewire]

He is great.

Best vocalist, but not best entertainer.

[Patrick]

Hes so boring and forgetful!

On Xtra Factor I actually forget hes there until Holly eventually says Joe.

[setanta]

I think he seems like a really nice and genuine young lad and it's a pity he gets such stick for it.