[Jords]

So far we've had 10 series, and 1 housemate always has to be that housemate evicted first, but out of the following:

BB1 Sada
BB2 Penny
BB3 Lynne
BB4 Anouska
BB5 Kitten
BB6 Mary
BB7 Bonnie
BB8 Shabnam
BB9 Stephanie
BB10 Beinazir

Whom do you think were big mistakes and either woulda come out of their shell after the first week nerves and have been really interesting or in general were entertaining and was a bit outragous they were gone after just Week 1?


Hadnt watched BB1 & BB2, but for me it was ridiculous that Stephanie and Shabnam were evicted first in their series (espicially out of 4 in Stephanie's case!). Both early favourites of mine and thought they were very entertaining in the week they were on the show.

[Stacey.]

i hardly remember the first evictees! But Steph always stood out for me
she was so pretty! i think she could have become a real character only given the chance!

[Joe.]

Steph obviously but I also have to say Beinizir, four days isn't long enough to show character and I think she should've stayed

[Braden]

Quite alot of them.

Beinazir,Stephanie,Kitten,Anouska,Sada and Bonnie had so much more to offer in my opinion.

Edit: I also think Kitten wasn't really an evictee.

[Raph]

Beinazir and Stephanie. I'd say Bonnie too, but she seemed too much a miserable character tbh. Maybe BB10 will bring a first evicted guy!

[ILoveTRW]

Bonnie, not because I liked her, because I hated Glyn

[Raph]

Originally Posted by ILoveDC

Bonnie, not because I liked her, because I hated Glyn

dude, Glyn was a legend man!

I also think Anouska should've stayed in longer. She seemed to be pretty charasmatic!

[biglover]

Shabnam as she was very funny and wierd, and annoyed the rest of them which was great viewing. Also Stephanie becuase she would have been good in the house and Mario should have gone !! She was just voted out becuase of jealous fat women X

[Loukas]

Benny and Shabs <3

[BigBrotherfan4ever]

Beinazir, Stephanie, Kitten.

[ILoveTRW]

Penny was an amazing character, sort of a female shahbaz

[30stone]

Stephanie

[Patrick]

I think everyone will agree, Stephanie.

She had so much to give, and would of made a good winner.
She is the fittest girl to ever enter the Big Brother House, End off.

She went because little girls are jealous of her and thats pathetic.

Mario or Lisa should of went in that week.


Also, she would of stayed and went on to win if Big Brother hadnt of ****ed it up for her.
Obviously by saying 'There is a secret couple in the house' everyone would of knowen *Facepalm*

[*mazedsalv**]

Stephanie for defenite. I actually still cant understand it. Where the hell all the Steph haters came in? She was pretty much really liked on every forum i went (here, DS and C4one they still had at the time)

Anouska as well. Her going was the end of BB4 IMO. I didnt really think much at the time, but by Week 4 i thought to myself how the hell could Anouska have been votes out over these dullards?

[Billy]

I said it at the time and I stand by my opinion that if Stephanie had stayed that week, she would have won the show. She was the calm of the house, brought BBlock and Luxury Bedroom together, there was no divide when she was there. Partly due to the fact it was week one maybe, but also down to the fact she got on with everyone. I thought she would have stayed after she took Alex down tbh

Also think Bonnie had loads to give. She never got the chance to shine, because week one was all about Shahbaz and Nikki, but I think she would have become great entertainment if she had gotten through that week.

['Conor]

Stephanie deffo !

Bonnie 2 !

and anoushka was the only entertaining housemate in bb4

[officialleafan]

I think it's obvious that Stephanie was the biggest first eviction mistake ever. It wasn't the fact she was the evicted, it was the fact that it seemed very manipulated by the producers for some reason, i can't understand what they had in mind when they wanted her out, i'm thinking maybe they wanted to keep Alexandra in, maybe they wanted the B Block/Luxuary Bedroom divide; i have no idea, but it was the biggest mistake they made to be honest and partly the reason why a lot of people lost faith in BB9.

[Patrick]

Originally Posted by Billy

I said it at the time and I stand by my opinion that if Stephanie had stayed that week, she would have won the show. She was the calm of the house, brought BBlock and Luxury Bedroom together, there was no divide when she was there. Partly due to the fact it was week one maybe, but also down to the fact she got on with everyone. I thought she would have stayed after she took Alex down tbh

I agree completely Billy.

Like you said, she got on with everyone had she had not been part of that task and stayed, she would of never been up for eviction.

She wasnt even given a proper shot at the show, it angers me how many bores got to stay in and Stephanie went and you could tell how much the fans and she herself, wanted her to stay in.

She would of made an amazing winner.

[Patrick]

Originally Posted by officialleafan

I think it's obvious that Stephanie was the biggest first eviction mistake ever. It wasn't the fact she was the evicted, it was the fact that it seemed very manipulated by the producers for some reason, i can't understand what they had in mind when they wanted her out, i'm thinking maybe they wanted to keep Alexandra in, maybe they wanted the B Block/Luxuary Bedroom divide; i have no idea, but it was the biggest mistake they made to be honest and partly the reason why a lot of people lost faith in BB9.

Tbh the reason people didnt watch BB9 was because of BB8 though.
I have asked people I know and people on here who have stopped watching and they all said after BB8 that was the end for them.

Which is a shame, BB9 really made up for 8 so if they had given that a chance then Big Brother's Ratings for 9 and 10 would of turned out alot better.

[LemonJam]

Stephanie and (depending if count Beinazir as a housemate) Sophia

[Jords]

Originally Posted by Patrick

I agree completely Billy.

Like you said, she got on with everyone had she had not been part of that task and stayed, she would of never been up for eviction.

She wasnt even given a proper shot at the show, it angers me how many bores got to stay in and Stephanie went and you could tell how much the fans and she herself, wanted her to stay in.

She would of made an amazing winner.

Its funny because thinking about it gets me quite annoyed too! If the public wernt so stupid at times with their votes, and people like Stephanie wernt evicted for gawd knows reason but was actually the most interesting out the 4 up [though I became very fond of Lisa halfway through], then maybe BB wouldnt be axed right now.

[officialleafan]

Originally Posted by Patrick

Tbh the reason people didnt watch BB9 was because of BB8 though.
I have asked people I know and people on here who have stopped watching and they all said after BB8 that was the end for them.

Which is a shame, BB9 really made up for 8 so if they had given that a chance then Big Brother's Ratings for 9 and 10 would of turned out alot better.

I mean people that actually watched BB9, for example, Stentionhouse supported Stephanie on the DS forums, he always uploading his youtube videos but when she was evicted, he said it was the "final straw" with BB and he just closed his account down. Most of my friends stop watching after Steph went, i did watch it, but it wasn't as hooked to it as i was with previous years. I know BB8 annoyed a lot of people, but the fans that actually watched BB9 at the start will say that they lost interest after Steph left.

[*mazedsalv**]

Originally Posted by officialleafan

I think it's obvious that Stephanie was the biggest first eviction mistake ever. It wasn't the fact she was the evicted, it was the fact that it seemed very manipulated by the producers for some reason, i can't understand what they had in mind when they wanted her out, i'm thinking maybe they wanted to keep Alexandra in, maybe they wanted the B Block/Luxuary Bedroom divide; i have no idea, but it was the biggest mistake they made to be honest and partly the reason why a lot of people lost faith in BB9.

yes I agree. I was annoyed! she was the calm of the house BUT what would have happened if she stayed?? producers maybe wanted the divide and they got it two weeks later with Spitgate, which lets be honest, was entertaining and one of the most rememerable moments of recent years.

[MeMyselfAndI]

my friend stopped watching after Stephanie went aswell

[iRyan]

Steph, by far.

She had so much to bring to the table. Even within one week she was one of the most entertaining. The show would've been alot more different if she stayed, it would've been better.