[Patrick]

Last Year Lucie Jones, Jedward, Danyl Johnson, Stacey Solomon, Kandy Rain, Olly Murs, Jamie Archer etc

This Year Cher Lloyd, Wagner, Mary Byrne, Katie Waissel, Aiden Grimshaw, Paije Richardson, Belle Amie etc

[Jack_]

This year.

I thought you were going to say out of all of the series - in which case it was Series 5 up until this year, but I think now I prefer this series.

[Smithy]

Stacey Rebecca Stacey Rebecca arghh idk I'm torn

Probably last year, because we got rid of the joke act sooner than this year and I liked a couple others, whereas this year I really dont

[KG.]

Series 6 was the worst in terms of talent with series 4.

Although this year is still pretty awful.

[Stacey.]

I loved it last year with Jedward, Danyl and Lucie.

But then this year with Cher, Aiden, Diva Fever and Nicolo..

I'd have to go for this year, probably only because we're actually in this year if that makes sense?

[Kerry]

Very tricky but going to say this year as it's the only year I've wanted to buy someones album (Matts)

[Locke.]

Last year just about. My favourite series overall aswell.

[Patrick]

Originally Posted by Jack_

This year.

I thought you were going to say out of all of the series - in which case it was Series 5 up until this year, but I think now I prefer this series.

Series 5 was amazing

Yeah but I was wondering earlier what the majority of on here thought when looking back on last year which if I remember correctly was criticized as being the worst because of Jedward.

Looking back though on the contestants themselves, they didn't seem too bad like with Lucie and that

But the talent this year is much bigger I guess, And this series as a whole is pretty interesting and shocking like you think someone is safe and they go, or you think the opposite and they stay.

Quite good really.

[bbfan1991]

Series 6 because I backed Danyl from day one, liked Jedward in the live shows... Lucie was a favourite of mine in the auditions and Jamie too, plus I didn't mind Joe but wanted him to win the final that year.

[MTVN]

This year, didnt care about any of the contestants last series

[bbfan1991]

I liked the year with JLS, Diana, Ruth and Alexandra too... didn't get the hype with Austin Drage and Laura White but each to their own, both who we haven't heard from since that year finished.

This year has been great, most of the contestants have something different about them and divide opinions more than ever e.g. Katie, Cher and Wagner who the producers will be loving the controversy they provide and the fact we get wound up proves them right.

[Saph]

This Year. Last year was **** apart from Stacey

[Lewis.]

This year as the talent is better and the acts are all very different in terms of the style of their performances. But series 5 is a series that I don't think can be beaten. WE had a great final 12, even Eoghan was slightly good, and it had a few nice twists (Laura leaving so early etc.) leading up to the final and then we had an amazing winner who didn't flop and is still making music today.

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

series 5 > all

[MTVN]

Originally Posted by bbfan1991

I liked the year with JLS, Diana, Ruth and Alexandra too... didn't get the hype with Austin Drage and Laura White but each to their own, both who we haven't heard from since that year finished.

This year has been great, most of the contestants have something different about them and divide opinions more than ever e.g. Katie, Cher and Wagner who the producers will be loving the controversy they provide and the fact we get wound up proves them right.

Laura did actually release a single, it didnt do very well though

[Jordan.]

This year for me. There has been far better acts and its been really hard to decide who goes each week.

[M X]

This year. It's been more interesting. However, Wagner has kinda ruined it.

And we had Gaga on last year.

Hmmmm.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Last year by far.

Series 5 > Series 3 > Series 6 > Series 2 > Series 7 > Series 4 > Series 1

although 2 and 6 are close

Danyl - Olly - Lucie - Miss Frank

[Pato]

last year was pritty bad only Olly and Stacey were the only decent acts. Although series 5 is the best ever

[_Seth]

I went with last year because it brought me Joe McElderry. <3

[Callum]

This year

[Z]

Last year was ruined by the fact that the talented contestants got eliminated early on; leaving us with a very average selection of finalists. Don't get me wrong, I think Joe, Olly and Stacey were all good singers, just nothing particularly exciting. Rikki Loney, Miss Frank, Rachel Adedeji, Lucie Jones, Jamie Archer and even Kandy Rain were all a bit different and I preferred them to the top 6. Jedward and Lloyd Daniels were awful. This year I don't really like any of them that much, last year Miss Frank were my favourites but this year I just don't have one. I'm not voting for either .

[fruit_cake]

Lucie and Danyl last year

[james130]

This year as the only good thing about last year was Lucie Jones oh and Holly on Xtra Factor.

[Marc]

Matt & Wagner > Joe & Jedward