[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by Lee.

But the suggested series of events aren't logical kizzy. Surely you don't agree with the theory that PC whateverhisnameis came up with? It doesn't make sense?

I don't know who PC whateverhisnameis is lee, so it's hard to say.
In many cases those related to or closely associated with missing children are implicated, so the feeling that this may be the case here is not altogether illogical is it in fairness?

Originally Posted by Kizzy

Whether you think others research or interest is logical or not is irrelevant though.

That's not what I said, and when someone asks you a direct question about your opinion, then your opinion, for no other reason than to answer the question, sort of becomes relevant.

[Lee.]

Originally Posted by Kizzy

I don't know who PC whateverhisnameis is lee, so it's hard to say.
In many cases those related to or closely associated with missing children are implicated, so the feeling that this may be the case here is not altogether illogical is it in fairness?

To me it is.. None of it makes sense. I think the McCanns are right in suing PC whateverhisnameis for defamation (sorry I cba looking up his name) and I really hope they win their case against him next month .

I also hope that if they do, something is also done about these dreadful websites where people are allowed to make completely unfounded allegations. I find them very distasteful and it must be very upsetting for the McCanns and their families.

[Kizzy]

Yes well we're going round in circles now that's all been said before in about 6 different ways hasn't it?
It's screamingly obvious that your view and mine don't tally so there's not much else to say is there?
I respect your right to think how you wish.

[chuff me dizzy]

Originally Posted by Lee.

To me it is.. None of it makes sense. I think the McCanns are right in suing PC whateverhisnameis for defamation (sorry I cba looking up his name) and I really hope they win their case against him next month .

I also hope that if they do, something is also done about these dreadful websites where people are allowed to make completely unfounded allegations. I find them very distasteful and it must be very upsetting for the McCanns and their families.

I doubt very much they will lose the case, this is the 4th case they have spent the search fund money on and to date 3 fails and this will be the 4th ,truth will out

[Vicky.]

Portuguese are reopening case. They said they wouldn't unless there was new evidence, wonder whats happened in the past few weeks.

Does this mean Kate, Gerry and Murat are all arguidos again? IIRC they weren't actually 'cleared', the case was just shelved.

Also, I wonder if the Tapas 9 will go back to Portugal for the reconstruction now, after declining last time. PJ wanted that but T9 said it was pointless.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Portuguese are reopening case. They said they wouldn't unless there was new evidence, wonder whats happened in the past few weeks.

Does this mean Kate, Gerry and Murat are all arguidos again? IIRC they weren't actually 'cleared', the case was just shelved.

Also, I wonder if the Tapas 9 will go back to Portugal for the reconstruction now, after declining last time. PJ wanted that but T9 said it was pointless.

Oh that is an interesting development. Bit weird that they wouldn't cooperate with the police as well for a reconstruction, although tbh I do find it hard to believe that they were all somehow in on it (whatever it may be)

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Portuguese are reopening case. They said they wouldn't unless there was new evidence, wonder whats happened in the past few weeks.

Does this mean Kate, Gerry and Murat are all arguidos again? IIRC they weren't actually 'cleared', the case was just shelved.

Also, I wonder if the Tapas 9 will go back to Portugal for the reconstruction now, after declining last time. PJ wanted that but T9 said it was pointless.

They must have found some new evidence.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

Oh that is an interesting development. Bit weird that they wouldn't cooperate with the police as well for a reconstruction, although tbh I do find it hard to believe that they were all somehow in on it (whatever it may be)

They said they didnt think it would help, and would be traumatizing..etc

I kinda get that, however you would put that aside if there was even a small chance that the girl was found. IMO anyway

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

They said they didnt think it would help, and would be traumatizing..etc

I kinda get that, however you would put that aside if there was even a small chance that the girl was found. IMO anyway

Absolutely, God you'd think anything at all that might help you would do, wouldn't you?

[Vicky.]

Also some of the friends thought if they went back to Portugal they would also be made arguidos.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Also some of the friends thought if they went back to Portugal they would also be made arguidos.

Very weird. I hope whatever the Portuguese Police have is good, I would love for this case to be solved once and for all

[Vicky.]

Indeed. As Andy Redwood said..this has gone on for far too long.

Never a truer word spoken tbh

[Kizzy]

The fact that some refused is strange and may have more to do with the fact some darn't go back, wonder who it was?

[Marsh.]

That "it may be traumatising" reason is a tad strange because Kate and Gerry have kept the search going, kept the media interest in the case and for all intents and purposes are determined to find there daughter. So, a reconstruction isn't going to make it any more or less traumatic for them.

It would be what they want surely?

[Cherie]

Just watched this on the news the PJ it seems have reopened to case following new leads, and also presumably because of the British Police reopening the files. The new focus of the PJ is on abduction, apparently this was not the initial focus of the investigation when Madeline first went missing.

[chuff me dizzy]

IMO the only way justice will ever be done is if one of tapas group breaks their pact of silence, Do they all want dragging back into papers,news ,internet ? they were never very close friends before this happened(apart from Mcs and Paynes) , and as far as i know have never holidayed together since ,Tanner has been outed as the liar we knew she was for the last 6 .5 yrs,the whole case has hinged on her statement of seeing "eggman" so in that case the whole case is a total lie ,Im hoping they have done a deal with Tanner that if she speaks out they will not charge her with perjury and hindering a police case as the are able to do now ,Then it would be classed as new evidence ,Kate IMO will HAVE to answer police questions this time or Sy will wonder why she refused ,Im no optimist Im not expecting anything out of this but we can but hope ,I love how in news Mcs are"delighted" its getting reopened, ? Kate could have had it reopened on the same day it was shelved ,if she answered the police questions ,did recon that would be new evidence, she chose not to ,Dont believe this "Its what they wanted" because this is NOT what they wanted this is their worst nightmare come back to bite them on the arse

[chuff me dizzy]

Originally Posted by Cherie

Just watched this on the news the PJ it seems have reopened to case following new leads, and also presumably because of the British Police reopening the files. The new focus of the PJ is on abduction, apparently this was not the initial focus of the investigation when Madeline first went missing.

British police are re VIEWING ,they cannot re OPEN it, its not their case its a Portuguese case ,they cannot arrest anyone in connection to it

[fingers]

Gawd! that startled looking Llama on the left does my nut in!

[chuff me dizzy]

Originally Posted by fingers

Gawd! that startled looking Llama on the left does my nut in!

And mine shes one ugly munter Fingers lol ... im looking for a new one, but not sure what to have

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

British police are re VIEWING ,they cannot re OPEN it, its not their case its a Portuguese case ,they cannot arrest anyone in connection to it

Okay thanks, why would the British Police review the files unless they were asked to do so by someone?

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

Tanner has been outed as the liar we knew she was for the last 6 .5 yrs,the whole case has hinged on her statement of seeing "eggman" so in that case the whole case is a total lie ,Im hoping they have done a deal with Tanner that if she speaks out they will not charge her with perjury and hindering a police case as the are able to do now ,Then it would be classed as new evidence

She saw a man carrying a child away from the apartments, wrapped in a blanket.

How on earth was that a lie?

It's not her fault that it took six years for this man to think it was him and come forward so that he can be eliminated from the investigation.

[Nedusa]

No apparently both British and Portuguese police forces are re-opening the McCann case, perhaps it was an abduction after all and new evidence has come to light and re-ignited the case.

Does this development put the McCanns in the clear ??

[the truth]

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

IMO the only way justice will ever be done is if one of tapas group breaks their pact of silence, Do they all want dragging back into papers,news ,internet ? they were never very close friends before this happened(apart from Mcs and Paynes) , and as far as i know have never holidayed together since ,Tanner has been outed as the liar we knew she was for the last 6 .5 yrs,the whole case has hinged on her statement of seeing "eggman" so in that case the whole case is a total lie ,Im hoping they have done a deal with Tanner that if she speaks out they will not charge her with perjury and hindering a police case as the are able to do now ,Then it would be classed as new evidence ,Kate IMO will HAVE to answer police questions this time or Sy will wonder why she refused ,Im no optimist Im not expecting anything out of this but we can but hope ,I love how in news Mcs are"delighted" its getting reopened, ? Kate could have had it reopened on the same day it was shelved ,if she answered the police questions ,did recon that would be new evidence, she chose not to ,Dont believe this "Its what they wanted" because this is NOT what they wanted this is their worst nightmare come back to bite them on the arse

everyone should be grilled thoroughly
in particular everyone at that table. who was the last person to check maddie before kate found her? wasn't there another doctor there who went to see her half an hour earlier? he needs to be regrilled

[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by the truth

everyone should be grilled thoroughly
in particular everyone at that table. who was the last person to check maddie before kate found her? wasn't there another doctor there who went to see her half an hour earlier? he needs to be regrilled

Funny you say that as from what I read about him it unnerves me, think his name is David Payne but not sure.