I've been searching for like 5 years to find a horror film that I find
remotely scary at all so not sure I can help with "scariest". I generally find them either boring, or funny

.
The only media of any sort that has genuinely scared me in recent years, is a couple of sections of "The Last of Us". The first "Clicker" section, the first "Bloater" section, and one other part where you get rushed by a large group of runners all freaked my **** right out. I actually stopped playing for like 36 hours after the first dark Clicker section because I was jumpy as ****

.