[setanta]

I don't think you can put Lucie in the same class as Leona though, that's the difference. And no, her up tempo song wasn't very good. It'll be very interesting to see how herself and Stacey get on in Rock week.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by 30stone

And Rachel will never blow me away just not good enough. See i thought that about Ruth, before purple Rain...didnt think much of her, thought she was quite average, maybe slightly above...it can happen...

as for this..
"Theres not much point in having a winner who can only sing one type of song though"

Leona? She can sing up tempo but people never like it as much as the slower songs same with lucie.

I like leonas uptempo songs as much as the slow ones, they are just as good...the only difference is, leona is very well known for her ability to hit seemingly impossible notes...which she cant really show off in a faster song

Talking of leona...I sang her 'run' at one of my gigs this week...oh my god...couldnt fecking breathe afterwards...but apprently did it quite well...just the really high notes got me...i didnt even attempt one of them as I knew I couldnt do it without a LOT of practise

[Lewis.]

Lucie was sensational this week. It gave me goosebumps. I would definately put that performance in with Leona's in terms of Goosebumb factor.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by 30stone

I didnt think duane was that good to be honest, joe was supposedly rubbish and he has shone.


and setanta, Tom said Despina should have gone through over lucie.
i thought she should have gone through aswell but the weakest of the girls there for me is rachel.

The thing about Lucie is the obvious Leona comparison. Leona ***** allover her and Lucie just can't match up and can't sing anything that isn't a ballad, so shes irrelevant imo

Originally Posted by setanta

Weakest of the girls is Stacey by far, while Lucie doesn't have the strength or passion that Rachel possesses. Despina was beautiful looking but ultimately her voice failed her somewhat.

Duane was great and should have been in ahead of Rikki or Lloyd.

Stacey went through on personality, I want her to win but vocally I don't think shes all that. And I think Duane could have won it, RnB is huge atm and he was one of very few possible long lasting winners from this years show

[Marc]

Rozelle Philips

[30stone]

I only compared her to leona because someone said you cant really have a singer that can only sing one type of song well.. and leona does that.

Lucie can sing uptempo songs though and shes not like leona but she is very very good in her own way.

[Beastie]

Scott!

[MeMyselfAndI]

Ethan and Miss Fitz should of made top 50

[Beastie]

I hope Scott is back next year (the one with autism ) but he was a really good singer!

[Jack_]

Curtis Moore, I was convinced he would be in the Top 12. Was very shocked when he didn't even make Judge's Houses.

Oh, and that Dominic guy who made Dannii's Judge's House in Leon's year.

[Beastie]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Curtis Moore, I was convinced he would be in the Top 12. Was very shocked when he didn't even make Judge's Houses.

Oh, and that Dominic guy who made Dannii's Judge's House in Leon's year.

Err.. Leon.

Curtis had as asbo didnt he? He didnt come across as likeable..

[CaraRawr]

Daniel Fox, Ethan and Katy Bullock.

[Deirdre]

Dannii should have picked Stacey McClean over Rachel

[teabag.]

Originally Posted by Tom

Cheryl picked the wrong three boys, she should have picked the other three

Simon should have picked Daniel and Treyc over Danyl and Jamie

Dannii should have picked Despina over Lucie

I also quite liked Sian, the one who John & Edward sung over, as well as Miss Fitz but lead singer went AWOL (them that did jazz version of Toxic)

i agree with despina instead of lucie!!

[Beastie]

Originally Posted by Deirdre

Dannii should have picked Stacey McClean over Rachel

maybe the show didnt want 2 stacey's? lol

so they went for the one with the bigger bubbly personality