[setanta]

Weakest of the girls is Stacey by far, while Lucie doesn't have the strength or passion that Rachel possesses. Despina was beautiful looking but ultimately her voice failed her somewhat.

Duane was great and should have been in ahead of Rikki or Lloyd.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by setanta

Weakest of the girls is Stacey by far, while Lucie doesn't have the strength or passion that Rachel possesses. Despina was beautiful looking but ultimately her voice failed her somewhat.

Despina should be there instead of stacey.

Lucie is by far the best singer out of the girls, but rachel has a 'different' kind of voice. Stacey is meh.

I did like Daniel fox (the guy with the green mohecan?). Its going to be an unpopular opinion but i think he should have gone through instead of Olly. I dont get the hype about him, hes ok. But I think simon didnt put him through, because he had already had a shot at fame...and failed.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by 30stone

I didnt think duane was that good to be honest, joe was supposedly rubbish and he has shone.


and setanta, Tom said Despina should have gone through over lucie.
i thought she should have gone through aswell but the weakest of the girls there for me is rachel.

The thing about Lucie is the obvious Leona comparison. Leona ***** allover her and Lucie just can't match up and can't sing anything that isn't a ballad, so shes irrelevant imo

Originally Posted by setanta

Weakest of the girls is Stacey by far, while Lucie doesn't have the strength or passion that Rachel possesses. Despina was beautiful looking but ultimately her voice failed her somewhat.

Duane was great and should have been in ahead of Rikki or Lloyd.

Stacey went through on personality, I want her to win but vocally I don't think shes all that. And I think Duane could have won it, RnB is huge atm and he was one of very few possible long lasting winners from this years show