[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by ILoveDC

the housemates create the story lines

And the producers.

[ILoveTRW]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

And the producers.

id say there is more influence from the producers in big brother

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by ILoveDC

id say there is more influence from the producers in big brother

Definately but BB producers don't tell the HM's how to act, while MTV does in their shows.

[ILoveTRW]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

Definately but BB producers don't tell the HM's how to act, while MTV does in their shows.

will you please stop grouping all of mtvs reality shows together because the arent all produced in the same way

BB producer deliberately manipulate situations by having twists and adding housemates that have a relation to a current housemate

that doesnt happen in the real world

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by ILoveDC

will you please stop grouping all of mtvs reality shows together because the arent all produced in the same way

BB producer deliberately manipulate situations by having twists and adding housemates that have a relation to a current housemate

that doesnt happen in the real world

So naive....ALL MTV shows are pretty much staged as is most Reality TV. American reality TV STRIVES on 'drama' and since the Real World is pre-recorded it's very easy for the producers to tell participants how to act, producers want drama and contestants want media careers so they work together. It's the same as the hills. Life is nothing like what you see on The real World, they're not real people they're just talentless hacks trying to get their 15 minutes.

BB do use twists to manipulate situations but they ultimately don't tell HM's how to act, it's a gameshow so it's meant to have twists and tasks. The comparision in your post is pretty terrible.

[ILoveTRW]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

So naive....ALL MTV shows are pretty much staged as is most Reality TV. American reality TV STRIVES on 'drama' and since the Real World is pre-recorded it's very easy for the producers to tell participants how to act, producers want drama and contestants want media careers so they work together. It's the same as the hills. Life is nothing like what you see on The real World, they're not real people they're just talentless hacks trying to get their 15 minutes.

BB do use twists to manipulate situations but they ultimately don't tell HM's how to act, it's a gameshow so it's meant to have twists and tasks. The comparision in your post is pretty terrible.

all your statements have nothing behind them to back them up. it is nothing like the hills they even have totally different filming styles ffs

it like me says that BB must be fake because hollyoaks has actors

the things that you are saying are all the things that BBUK haters say about BBUK

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by ILoveDC

all your statements have nothing behind them to back them up. it is nothing like the hills they even have totally different filming styles ffs

We've had this argument before and me and Stu managed to put down any point you came up with. If I remember right you never did manage to prove it wasn't faked... You stalled a lot but never actually could prove it to us that it was all real.

Originally Posted by ILoveDC

it like me says that BB must be fake because hollyoaks has actors

That's one of the silliest comparisions I've ever seen. When has Hollyoaks ever claimed to be a reality Show? TRL and The Hills are a good comparision because they both claim to be 'reality' shows. Next time you try to disprove a point find a comparision which works.

Originally Posted by ILoveDC

the things that you are saying are all the things that BBUK haters say about BBUK

I've never heard anyone claim that BB is faked on here or in real life. Clasping at straws are we? Plus the BB comparision is sucky because they have different styles entirely, BB happens as we watch it and the Crew never interact with the HM's apart from the Diary roomunlike MTV shows where the Crew can talk to them any time between shots, directing them and such. This isn't possible on BB otherwise it'd look more like any MTV reality show, Badly acted.