[Zippy]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

Thing is Zip. You started the thread and her actions tonight dont add up. That IS why you started this thread, isnt it? Or was it just to praise little miss perfect? She wasn't so perfect tonight.

Her actions were very simple. She was asked to choose between them at an unnecessary point and refused to do so. If you want to build up a whole conspiracy story around that then thats your sad business.

Cheryl didnt eliminate one of her acts so she does not have their blood on her hands. Nor does she need to...just like Simon didnt a few weeks ago and many judges in past series. She should have been asked her opinion last which would have given her the option to take it to deadlock and let the public decide.