[AbbieJ]

Apparently Nick Cotton is NOT dead

[LukeB]

Abi due to exams stress as she always have exams

[Benji_]

I genuinely think it was Abi and the reason Jay was on that bus with Lucy was to try and stop Abi but he was too late hence why he broke up with her and he will take the blame for Abi and then sooner or later it'll all come out that it was Abi

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

I think the DS theory that Charlie Cotton, Nick Cotton and the Undertaker being involved will come true.

I think this more than ever now. Who Killed Lucy? and the Nick Cotton story will merge by Christmas.

[LukeB]

IT WAS ME

[Vanessa]

Abi.

[Loukas]

no bloody clue yet

[Ramsay]

I hope it's Abi so she can go to jail and they write her off as she's always wrecking my head

[Smithy]

Peter or Jane

[Black Dagger]

Definitely think it's Abi now they are painting her as this vile, cold blooded, nasty, selfish bitch.

[waterhog]

more reason for it not to be her.

[Vanessa]

She could be a red herring. After last night now i'm not so sure it was her. Yes, she can be a bitch, but is she capable of murder?

[Niamh.]

Lauren and I think she's freaking out because she thinks Lucys ghost is following her woooooooo

[Ramsay]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

Lauren and I think she's freaking out because she thinks Lucys ghost is following her woooooooo

ooooooooo

[Liam-]

I'm on the Lauren train as well, i just have a gut feeling it will end up being her for some reason.

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by LiamPRW

I'm on the Lauren train as well, i just have a gut feeling it will end up being her for some reason.

Could be.

[Niamh.]

They're making it too obvious to be Abi now

[Shaun]

My serious answer was Aleks at the time of this thread being posted but all of his family drama has thrown me off the scent and he's too irrelevant a character to be given two big storylines in a row.

I don't think it's Lauren/Abi... or Peter... or Ian... and I hope it's not a Cotton :/

I sort-of hope it's Shabnam. Have those hate messages she left at the funeral, or rather that fell out of her pocket at the funeral, been explained yet? Edit: just read up on it... Tamwar recognised the writing... ok well where the hell has this subplot gone

[Tom4784]

I think the only way Peter, Lauren or Abi will be involved is if Lucy's death was ultimately accidental and not murder. I'm guessing that Nick or Deano was involved somehow.

[Braden]

I think it's someone that could potentially kill again. I don't think it's realistic to be anyone who has been on the show for a while, I'm thinking someone new or someone who hasn't been important for a while.

Shabnam is a good good shout...maybe Lee, or even Tosh. I had a dream ages ago that Tosh's gf was being questioned at a police station and thought it was a sixth sense telling me that Tosh killed Lucy and was trying to kill her gf too.

[Ramsay]

Originally Posted by Shaun

just read up on it... Tamwar recognised the writing... ok well where the hell has this subplot gone

Think it was Whitney

[Shaun]

I know Whitney was responsible for the Facebook stuff, but the letters/messages too?

[Ramsay]

I think so. might be wrong though i have horrible memory

[Firewire]

It said "ROT IN HELL" and it was Whitney's note

[Niamh.]

I missed that stuff, why did Whitney do that?