[tanussa]

Originally Posted by lewys

not go against Lewis is the actual answer lmao, Brooke and Sian have had pretty much the same amount of airtime in recent weeks, Brooke is liked and is friends with Lewis, Sian is disliked and doesn’t understand him

are you saying that she has actually done enough to win this. shes wallpaper. pretty wallpaper but nothing else, except for a cold heart & a sharp tongue

[lewys]

Originally Posted by tanussa

are you saying that she has actually done enough to win this. shes wallpaper. pretty wallpaper but nothing else, except for a cold heart & a sharp tongue

did I mention anything about her winning in my post !! she actually has a lovely heart and is always looking out for people

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by Calderyon

Most of the dislike is because she dared not to like Saint Lewis the Hollow one.

At least that's what it seems like.

and on the flip side I think that is why people like her as well, she has been true to herself, she has never flip flopped on her friends like Zoe, or Brooke and though a pretty girl is not up her own arse, she also doesn't appear to try to get airtime or hog the camera it is very nice to have an housemate who is not following a tried and tested format like playing dumb, or jumping into bed with someone

[Ant.]

Y'know maybe I've been guilty of this in the past but I've always tried to word it so that it comes off as my opinion, but do people realise people can like housemates for different reasons to them?

Like, people think Sian is good-hearted and has great one-liners. Is that not a valid reason to like her?
Like none of her fans are saying she does a lot. I don't think any will argue against the fact she was barely shown for three weeks at the start. And you may not like her because you prefer housemates who have more screentime (Lewis F) but no one ever really says "I don't like Sian because what she does and says when she's on screen doesn't interest me", they just say "Sian does nothing she's wallpaper" which is.. ridiculous because she clearly does something and has been doing something, hence her increase in popularity lmao. She certainly does less and not liking her for not doing as much as others is certainly a valid reason but when people speak superlatively as if she's how she was in week 1 and doesn't come out with one-liners (and humour is subjective, but it's one of the reasons she's loved now) and contributes more to conversations is a tad... ridiculous?

idk I just think the whole "haha how can anyone like Sian she DOES NOTHING" is just ridiculous because like. she does stuff. Not as much as Lewis F but she does stuff. And if your preference is the likes of Lewis F who is OTT and is on the telly more than Sian that's fine! But I've never seen anyone use that rationale for their dislike of Sian. They just rather say she does nothing and is 'wallpaper'

like tl;dr people are allowed to prefer housemates that get less screentime and are nice and funny and bc Sian doesn't fit the ideal cookie cutter of some viewers DOESNT MEAN she aint a good housemate

[lewys]

Originally Posted by Lilbro

Y'know maybe I've been guilty of this in the past but I've always tried to word it so that it comes off as my opinion, but do people realise people can like housemates for different reasons to them?

Like, people think Sian is good-hearted and has great one-liners. Is that not a valid reason to like her?
Like none of her fans are saying she does a lot. I don't think any will argue against the fact she was barely shown for three weeks at the start. And you may not like her because you prefer housemates who have more screentime (Lewis F) but no one ever really says "I don't like Sian because what she does and says when she's on screen doesn't interest me", they just say "Sian does nothing she's wallpaper" which is.. ridiculous because she clearly does something and has been doing something, hence her increase in popularity lmao. She certainly does less and not liking her for not doing as much as others is certainly a valid reason but when people speak superlatively as if she's how she was in week 1 and doesn't come out with one-liners (and humour is subjective, but it's one of the reasons she's loved now) and contributes more to conversations is a tad... ridiculous?

idk I just think the whole "haha how can anyone like Sian she DOES NOTHING" is just ridiculous because like. she does stuff. Not as much as Lewis F but she does stuff. And if your preference is the likes of Lewis F who is OTT and is on the telly more than Sian that's fine! But I've never seen anyone use that rationale for their dislike of Sian. They just rather say she does nothing and is 'wallpaper'

like tl;dr people are allowed to prefer housemates that get less screentime and are nice and funny and bc Sian doesn't fit the ideal cookie cutter of some viewers DOESNT MEAN she aint a good housemate

maybe she snapped !

[Ant.]

(and yes, I'm using Lewis F as an example. Not because I'm 'obsessed' (which is also a silly argument that's brought up unironically sometimes which is... ridiculous lmao) but because Sian contrasts with Lewis F the most imo. especially when the majority of Lewis F fans don't like Sian and vice versa)

[Elliot]

Originally Posted by Lilbro

Y'know maybe I've been guilty of this in the past but I've always tried to word it so that it comes off as my opinion, but do people realise people can like housemates for different reasons to them?

Like, people think Sian is good-hearted and has great one-liners. Is that not a valid reason to like her?
Like none of her fans are saying she does a lot. I don't think any will argue against the fact she was barely shown for three weeks at the start. And you may not like her because you prefer housemates who have more screentime (Lewis F) but no one ever really says "I don't like Sian because what she does and says when she's on screen doesn't interest me", they just say "Sian does nothing she's wallpaper" which is.. ridiculous because she clearly does something and has been doing something, hence her increase in popularity lmao. She certainly does less and not liking her for not doing as much as others is certainly a valid reason but when people speak superlatively as if she's how she was in week 1 and doesn't come out with one-liners (and humour is subjective, but it's one of the reasons she's loved now) and contributes more to conversations is a tad... ridiculous?

idk I just think the whole "haha how can anyone like Sian she DOES NOTHING" is just ridiculous because like. she does stuff. Not as much as Lewis F but she does stuff. And if your preference is the likes of Lewis F who is OTT and is on the telly more than Sian that's fine! But I've never seen anyone use that rationale for their dislike of Sian. They just rather say she does nothing and is 'wallpaper'

like tl;dr people are allowed to prefer housemates that get less screentime and are nice and funny and bc Sian doesn't fit the ideal cookie cutter of some viewers DOESNT MEAN she aint a good housemate

Ugh her mind

[pontyboi]

Well basically because its only 13 days to the final so she has coasted through by doing nothing.

Its to little to late.

Why do Sian fans expect us to support a housemate who has done nothing to contribute to the majority of the series apart from smoking, cooking and a few one liners now and then.

90% of threads are about what a disappointment she has been so its not an unpopular opinion.

[Elliot]

Originally Posted by pontyboi

Well with basically because its only 13 days to the final so she has coasted through by doing nothing.

Its to little to late.

Why do Sian fans expect us to support a housemate who has done nothing to contribute to the majority of the series apart from smoking, cooking and a few one liners now and then.

90% of threads are about what a disappointment she has been so its not an unpopular opinion.

I guess I missed the posts of the hoards of Sian fans saying they’ll hold you at gunpoint if you don’t like her

[pontyboi]

Originally Posted by Elliot

I guess I missed the posts of the hoards of Sian fans saying they’ll hold you at gunpoint if you don’t like her

This makes no sense.

[Ant.]

Originally Posted by pontyboi

Well with basically because its only 13 days to the final so she has coasted through by doing nothing.

Its to little to late.

Why do Sian fans expect us to support a housemate who has done nothing to contribute to the majority of the series apart from smoking, cooking and a few one liners now and then.

90% of threads are about what a disappointment she has been so its not an unpopular opinion.

I don't see how how close the final is should affect people's enjoyment of a housemate?

Like RileyH is referring to the people who, a few weeks ago, said Sian does nothing and needs to be shown more, and when she was shown more, their rationale to not liking her turned to "well she should've been shown from the beginning"

But aye, you at least admit she's done something, which is more than can be said for most posts criticising Sian

And perhaps its other people exaggerating their dislike of Sian that makes me sceptical of this, but I doubt 90% of threads re: Sian are about how she's been disappointing, but I need to check. Regardless, I fail to see how people making threads about Sian and how she's a 'disappointment' backs up your point. OP literally acknowledges she's been criticised for being 'boring' and a 'disappointment'

[poppsywoppsy]

if she didn't have a pretty face, no one would vote for her

I know, I know, I nicked it from the posters who disliked Lewis

Sorry couldn't resist

[montblanc]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

For me, just leave on Friday hopefully.

[DouglasS]

People are only hating on Sian because her and Lewis aren’t pals. Quite sad really that people make their assessments and opinions on people based on if their favourite housemate likes them rather than forming their own opinion.

[DouglasS]

Originally Posted by poppsywoppsy

if she didn't have a pretty face, no one would vote for her

I know, I know, I nicked it from the posters who disliked Lewis

Sorry couldn't resist

Considering 90% of her supporters on here are women and gay men that is not likely... lewis’ main fan base on here does seem to mainly consist of women..

[Elliot]

Originally Posted by poppsywoppsy

if she didn't have a pretty face, no one would vote for her

I know, I know, I nicked it from the posters who disliked Lewis

Sorry couldn't resist

If Lewis was ugly nobody would vote for him
You know this is true