[poppsywoppsy]

Originally Posted by Yaki da

I'm not talking about episodes I'm talking about hours upon hours of unseen footage not used in the episodes. You're assuming she hasn't spoken about her child because it hasn't been included in a HL show. It's silly.



The criticisms of Zoe are persuasive.

The others have spoken and it has been shown, several times,

Sian has not. Doesn't it make you wonder why, hasn't it been normal to speak about your loved ones in there?

There is no reason why Sian would be treated differently from others and her comments excluded.

[Yaki da]

Originally Posted by poppsywoppsy

The others have spoken and it has been shown, several times,

Sian has not. Doesn't it make you wonder why, hasn't it been normal to speak about your loved ones in there?

There is literally hours upon hours of unseen footage of Sian in that house. She's been in there as long as any of them and you have seen less of her than probably any of them. The only thing you know is that she hasn't been shown talking about her son.

There is no reason why Sian would be treated differently from others and her comments excluded.

Of course there is. If she's just having a normal conversation about her son liking football rather than blubbing like an idiot about missing him they're not going to include that.

[poppsywoppsy]

Originally Posted by Yaki da

There is literally hours upon hours of unseen footage of Sian in that house. She's been in there as long as any of them and you have seen less of her than probably any of them. The only thing you know is that she hasn't been shown talking about her son.



Of course there is. If she's just having a normal conversation about her son liking football rather than blubbing like an idiot about missing him they're not going to include that.

Why not, we have had all sorts of conversations about family and loved ones, why doesn't she contribute because she hasn't.

Throw up all sorts of tenuous reasons, such as funerals and such, it doesn't turn her into anything more than a very bitchy smirky cold woman.

[Yaki da]

Originally Posted by poppsywoppsy

Why not, we have had all sorts of conversations about family and loved ones

We haven't. It's rare that we do. And again, the only time they tend to show this stuff is if someone has broken down when speaking about a family member. Sian certainly isn't the type to break down. but to say she doesn't speak about her child when you know there's hours upon hours of footage you haven't seen is moronic, and I won't respond to you making this silly point again.

Throw up all sorts of tenuous reasons, such as funerals and such, it doesn't turn her into anything more than a very bitchy smirky cold woman.

Your arguments are empty and all you can do is return to the same remarks over and over. Tedious.

[reece(:]

Originally Posted by poppsywoppsy

The others have spoken and it has been shown, several times,

Sian has not. Doesn't it make you wonder why, hasn't it been normal to speak about your loved ones in there?

There is no reason why Sian would be treated differently from others and her comments excluded.

We see 40 mins a day ffs how do you know she hasn’t spoke about her family unless you have some insider info ???

[poppsywoppsy]

Originally Posted by reece(:

We see 40 mins a day ffs how do you know she hasn’t spoke about her family unless you have some insider info ???

Right back at you

How do you know she has because everyone else's comments have been aired.

[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by poppsywoppsy

Right back at you

How do you know she has because everyone else's comments have been aired.

It would be very odd for any of them to not speak about their families, being stuck in there with nothing else to do but talk. I would say it's logically more plausible to think she probably has spoken about them than not

[poppsywoppsy]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

It would be very odd for any of them to not speak about their families, being stuck in there with nothing else to do but talk. I would say it's logically more plausible to think she probably has spoken about them than not

Why?

When we have heard from everyone else again and again.

It doesn't make sense, they won't air it as the housemates often spoke of their home and family, why not air hers too?

[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by poppsywoppsy

Why?

When we have heard from everyone else again and again.

It doesn't make sense, they won't air it as the housemates often spoke of their home and family, why not air hers too?

I haven't heard hardly any of them talk about their families much? We get about 45 minutes of footage a night, it's probably not that interesting, I mean it's just not realistic to think she never speaks about her family but whatever if it suits you narrative of her being a cold evil robot than carry on

[poppsywoppsy]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

I haven't heard hardly any of them talk about their families much? We get about 45 minutes of footage a night, it's probably not that interesting, I mean it's just not realistic to think she never speaks about her family but whatever if it suits you narrative of her being a cold evil robot than carry on

I do think she is cold but you are maligning me as I have never called her evil, there is a difference and I would like it known.

I will hold my hands up to what I have written but I have not called her that.

I have in fact said I liked her initially but she has failed to sustain her initial promise.

My point is that it is not realistic not to talk about her family but isn't it strange that of all the housemates from Day 1 it is only her comments which don't get aired.