[Princess]

Of course everyone has a soul!That's our consicence and the essence of who we are.

[Dom:)]

Originally Posted by Princess

Of course everyone has a soul!That's our consicence and the essence of who we are.

Well said

[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by Princess

Of course everyone has a soul!That's our consicence and the essence of who we are.

What about people who don't have a consicence then, they have no souls????

[Princess]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

What about people who don't have a consicence then, they have no souls????

Yeah basically. Or well bad souls.

[InOne]

Originally Posted by Princess

Yeah basically. Or well bad souls.

Hmmm I think I heard an argument for that in the book 'The Mask of Sanity'

[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by Princess

Yeah basically. Or well bad souls.

That's a bit unfair!! So, it's just luck of the draw whether or not you have a good soul or no soul/bad soul???

[Lauren]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

That's a bit unfair!! So, it's just luck of the draw whether or not you have a good soul or no soul/bad soul???

What makes a murderer a murderer? What initially makes them evil? No matter what answer you give, I could then argue "That's unfair, it's luck of the draw".

(Not arguing against your point, by the way, just showing how everything is basically luck of the draw).

[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by Lauren

What makes a murderer a murderer? What initially makes them evil? No matter what answer you give, I could then argue "That's unfair, it's luck of the draw".

(Not arguing against your point, by the way, just showing how everything is basically luck of the draw).

Different things make different murderers, murderers I guess. Circumstances, up bringing, traumatic events,etc. but I don't think having no soul is one of them! But I could be wrong, I hope we all have souls but I just don't think we do

[Lauren]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

Different things make different murderers, murderers I guess. Circumstances, up bringing, traumatic events,etc. but I don't think having no soul is one of them! But I could be wrong, I hope we all have souls but I just don't think we do

All of those things could be luck of the draw though. So although I disagree with the soul-conscience theory - it's not just cos it's luck of the draw.

Btw, I think we do all have souls, but it's separate from conscience.

[InOne]

Originally Posted by Princess

Of course everyone has a soul!That's our consicence and the essence of who we are.

What about people who have no conscience, do they have a soul?