[30stone]

Its who has the full package type show.

Not just a singer, but a good personality, likeability, look..

[WOMBAI]

Originally Posted by 30stone

Its who has the full package type show.

Not just a singer, but a good personality, likeability, look..

The key point being - a singer. Some might prefer the winner to have what they consider a good personality, the likeability factor etc - as well as being able to sing.

J&E - whether or not people believe they have other attributes - no doubting the fact they can't sing. Therefore on the wrong show.

[30stone]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

The key point being - a singer. Some might prefer the winner to have what they consider a good personality, the likeability factor etc - as well as being able to sing.

J&E - whether or not people believe they have other attributes - no doubting the fact they can't sing. Therefore on the wrong show.

You have to be able to sing to win for me, but you cant be cocky rude or anything, and have to look at least half decent.

John and Edward wont win it, its just fact, and they dont deserve to.

[Tracyjay]

Sting was on bbc this am and he said that the trouble with the X factor is the ability to mimic another talent such as Whitney or Mariah is encouraged and the true x factor, which is about having your own interesting, unique sound is discouraged.
so its really just a karaoke, impression show