[MrGaryy]

Originally Posted by smithy

you cant really call an album a flop if it sells over a million copies and goes platinum in the US

even her manager who she fired after the album said the album was a sucess and shes said multiple times in interviews that she wants to try something different on every album All I Ever Wanted is completely different to breakaway & my december

and if i compare kellys earlier stuff with Xtinas i still prefer kellys

I can when I compare it to her previous album honey.

and you can;t honestly tell me that All I Ever Wanted is even remotely different from Breakaway? It's practically a carbon copy, she went crawling back to pop rock after My December was sucha fail.