[NeoPhoenix]

Trying to be as objective as possible here, I haven't seen the LF so I'm just going by what I've heard in this thread. If it is true that JJ warned her before she threw water on him, then she deserves what she got.

Hypothetical situation: If I tell a guy I'm going to punch him in the stomach, and he warns me that if I do, he is going to kick my ass, what right in the world do I have to complain when that man makes good on his promise and beats me to a bloody pulp?

It makes no sense to me whatsoever that someone would defend SS in this situation. She did something to JJ that he obviously didn't want to happen to him. He gave it back to her in return. Why is he the bad guy in this situation? If SS didn't want to end up in the pool, she shouldn't have thrown water on JJ, simple as that.