[Stevep]

Did a poll a few weeks back asking who everybodys favorite judge was (forgot who came top, think it was Dannii?), so thought it would be interesting to see who everybodys worst judge would be.

[Stacey.]

Dannii.

[King Gizzard]

Cheryl, just given the catergory that needs the least work each year

[Novo]

Louis

[Tom]

Simon, hes just a parody of himself

[Stephanie]

would have been cheryl, but now simon. he's lost everything that made him a good judge.

[Smithy]

Louis. no competition.

[Callum]

Simon, he always praises the acts these days and it's a rare occasion to see him criticising someone now. Even if he does say something negative, it will always be followed with something nice.

[Jordan.]

Louis

[Zippy]

Louis. So useless they make him speak first when the audience are at their loudest and drown him out.

Afraid to get booed by the audience and when he does slag an act its usually just to get at Simon or Cheryl.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Louis. So useless they make him speak first when the audience are at their loudest and drown him out.

Afraid to get booed by the audience and when he does slag an act its usually just to get at Simon or Cheryl.

He's good entertainment value though and he does say it as it is. He's not scared to admit his own acts are crap

[Legend killer]

Cheryl about as useful on the judging panel as a used condom

[alc09]

Dannii - she shouldn't be there.

[Jack_]

Cheryl/Dannii - I'd probably opt for the former. Simon carries the show and Louis is fantastic entertainment.

Dannii/Cheryl are bores [bring back Sharon plz] but Dannii gives good comments - so that only leaves Cheryl who is just 'nice' and 'pretty'.

[bbfan1991]

Cheryl.

[Mystic Mock]

the top one means who i think is the worst.
1.cheryl


























































2.louis
3.simon
4.dannii

[Adamw92]

Louis. He puts through sh*t acts and we're left to watch as they get to like week 7 and we lose 2-3 good acts who can actually sing

[Barbie]

Louis, Not only have they gotten rid of him once, he brought Jedward to the world, that in itself is enough, not only that but then be brought Storm and Wagner! I know he had a bad category anyway but his choices were bad!

[Crimson Dynamo]

Biffa is mince

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Adamw92

Louis. He puts through sh*t acts and we're left to watch as they get to like week 7 and we lose 2-3 good acts who can actually sing

if thats a hint at jedward then im gonna disagree with you.