[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

Probably not, it's suits her vocal range and she's got the ability to pull it off. She's been in the bottom 2 twice when she wore silly outfits, It's more the outfit's fault then hers I think.

it doesn't help but she has a mediocre voice and is unlikable, that also doesn't help her

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

it doesn't help but she has a mediocre voice and is unlikable, that also doesn't help her

I disagree, I think she's got a good voice. Just because she ain't Leona Lewis doesn't mean she's a bad singer, she's got a more intimate voice, very retro in a way. She's only considered unlikable because the press has made her the pariah of the series.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

I disagree, I think she's got a good voice. Just because she ain't Leona Lewis doesn't mean she's a bad singer, she's got a more intimate voice, very retro in a way. She's only considered unlikable because the press has made her the pariah of the series.

her not being leona Lewis is absolutely not the reason I dislike her or think she isn't a good singer I can assure you. I'm not a fan of that type voice at all (Leona style) . Aiden has an unusual voice which I like as does Rebecca and Matt (ish)

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

her not being leona Lewis is absolutely not the reason I dislike her or think she isn't a good singer I can assure you. I'm not a fan of that type voice at all (Leona style) . Aiden has an unusual voice which I like as does Rebecca and Matt (ish)

All three are among my favourites but I wouldn't say any of them have unique voices. Matt's not got a unique voice, you'd find thousands of him in America, Rebecca's got that retro voice and Aiden's voice can be found in a lot of music outside the top 40.

What makes Aiden & Rebecca stand out though is their niches, which Matt needs to find ASAP.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

All three are among my favourites but I wouldn't say any of them have unique voices. Matt's not got a unique voice, you'd find thousands of him in America, Rebecca's got that retro voice and Aiden's voice can be found in a lot of music outside the top 40.

What makes Aiden & Rebecca stand out though is their niches, which Matt needs to find ASAP.

I think Rebecca and Aidens voices are far more unique than Katies. And Matt well, yeah, I do really blame that on Dannii though!

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

I think Rebecca and Aidens voices are far more unique than Katies. And Matt well, yeah, I do really blame that on Dannii though!

I'd disagree, Katie hasn't got a unique voice either but I'd say you don't hear her voice as often as the other two. It's difficult to explain but with Rebecca she's very comparable to Amy Winehouse and Aiden could be compared with David Gray and other Singer Songwriters. Katie's in a similar retro vein as Rebecca but her's is more different.....I'm probably not making much sense as I can't really explain it well. I don't think Katie's got many modern comparisions really.

With Matt I think it's more his fault then Dannii's really. He's still one of my favourites but there's nothing unique about him. He's the male Treyc, good voice and a jack of all trades but a master of none. It's gonna cost him in the end, unless he can find that star quality and that niche which he lacks he won't make it to the final.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

I'd disagree, Katie hasn't got a unique voice either but I'd say you don't hear her voice as often as the other two. It's difficult to explain but with Rebecca she's very comparable to Amy Winehouse and Aiden could be compared with David Gray and other Singer Songwriters. Katie's in a similar retro vein as Rebecca but her's is more different.....I'm probably not making much sense as I can't really explain it well. I don't think Katie's got many modern comparisions really.

With Matt I think it's more his fault then Dannii's really. He's still one of my favourites but there's nothing unique about him. He's the male Treyc, good voice and a jack of all trades but a master of none. It's gonna cost him in the end, unless he can find that star quality and that niche which he lacks he won't make it to the final.

I think we'll just have to agree to disagree on this one Dezzy, I do see what you're saying yes there is a unique tone to her voice but it's just not very good imo but that is just my opinion.

Still disagree with you about matt and do think it's Danniis fault as she has been picking his songs and you can tell by him that he's not happy about it all