[Novo]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

absolutely 100% agree, they're saving Katie for some reason, I think she knows someone involved in X factor or something. Why would they do that????

LOL!!!!!!!!!

I've heard it all you bitter little thing

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Novo

LOL!!!!!!!!!

I've heard it all you bitter little thing

she messed up her song...........again, she's w hinging horrible drama queen

[Kerry]

How can it be a fix though? Cheryl said she'd have taken it to deadlock had she been last to vote. Plus can nobody remember the crap TV companies got into for vote fixing a year or two ago? Theres no way they can get away with that now

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by ~Kerry~

How can it be a fix though? Cheryl said she'd have taken it to deadlock had she been last to vote. Plus can nobody remember the crap TV companies got into for vote fixing a year or two ago? Theres no way they can get away with that now

Its not fixing the actual public vote though.

And yes, cheryl said she would take it to deadlock...so her vote was disallowed. Thats my point, obviously cheryl wouldnt have wanted to kick one of her own acts out, obviously she would take it to deadlock...which is WHY they went to her second instead of last. The judge with two acts always goes last, so they have the chance of deadlock. But this week, I think katie got the least votes, so they panicked. Knowing full well cheryl would take it to deadlock

[Novo]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

she messed up her song...........again, she's w hinging horrible drama queen

Well Unlucky she is here for another week

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Novo

Well Unlucky she is here for another week

well it's quite obvious the public hate her, so once it's taken out of the judges hands or she's up against someone decent she's toast

[Kerry]

Still doesn't discount the fact that they don't HAVE to vote. If time runs out they don't vote. If they refuse (obviously) they don't vote. Theres never been a rule that they HAVE to vote. Can no one remember Simon not voting before? Louis hasn't voted before and Sharon Osbourne on one the talent shows hasn't voted before. Not once has it been ever said the judges HAVE to

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by ~Kerry~

Still doesn't discount the fact that they don't HAVE to vote. If time runs out they don't vote. If they refuse (obviously) they don't vote. Theres never been a rule that they HAVE to vote. Can no one remember Simon not voting before? Louis hasn't voted before and Sharon Osbourne on one the talent shows hasn't voted before. Not once has it been ever said the judges HAVE to

Everyone seems to be totally missing the point.

Everytime there is two acts of the same mentor in the bottom, the mentor gets to pick last, and to my recollection always choses to take it to deadlock.

This week that was changed, for seemingly no reason...

[Kerry]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Everyone seems to be totally missing the point.

Everytime there is two acts of the same mentor in the bottom, the mentor gets to pick last, and to my recollection always choses to take it to deadlock.

This week that was changed, for seemingly no reason...

OK I get you. Just making the point that she didn't have to vote. There seems to be some vendetta against her for not doing so.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by ~Kerry~

OK I get you. Just making the point that she didn't have to vote. There seems to be some vendetta against her for not doing so.

Yeah, I was raging at her to start with for not voting. until I realised it was totally unfair the way that the order of it all changed this week.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by ~Kerry~

OK I get you. Just making the point that she didn't have to vote. There seems to be some vendetta against her for not doing so.

it's not about Cheryl though Kerry, it's about who ever told Dermot to go to Cheryl second rather than last as would be normal procedure for the judge with 2 acts in the bottom

[patsylimerick]

Originally Posted by ~Kerry~

Still doesn't discount the fact that they don't HAVE to vote. If time runs out they don't vote. If they refuse (obviously) they don't vote. Theres never been a rule that they HAVE to vote. Can no one remember Simon not voting before? Louis hasn't voted before and Sharon Osbourne on one the talent shows hasn't voted before. Not once has it been ever said the judges HAVE to

But what's being argued is that it was all part of the plan. Go to Cheryl second, take her vote out of the equation; then it's down to a majority vote, no option for deadlock, which the producers knew TreyC would win because Katie finished last. Not that I know that, that's just the highly plausible, IMHO, explanation that's being posited.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by patsylimerick

But what's being argued is that it was all part of the plan. Go to Cheryl second, take her vote out of the equation; then it's down to a majority vote, no option for deadlock, which the producers knew TreyC would win because Katie finished last. Not that I know that, that's just the highly plausible, IMHO, explanation that's being posited.

exactly, everyone seems to be completely missing the point here!