[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

I know there is no rule saying you can't but the judges, particularly Simon have always worked off the principle that the more times you're in the bottom the less likely it is that people actually like you and therefore would choose the other person. If she ends up in the bottom, she will be there 4 times against someone who has never been there, it would only seem fair to get rid of Katie at this point as all her chances should well and truly be up!

I totally agree with you, It would look terrible and very suspicious if Katie survived this week if in the bottom 2 again.
She would then have been there 4 weeks out of 6,and I recalee when Simon had the Conway Sisters,they had been in the last a few times and he said. as he voted out his own act, it was clear they were never going to be able to win the competition because they were in the bottom 2 again.
So off they went.

I really cannot see, other than Wagner, who Katie could now stay over in the bottom 2. All the others are superior to her in style and vocals,they also remember the words to whatever song they do too.

I have a feeling that it may not be that unlikely that the public will put Cheryl in the same position again this week, with 2 of her acts again making the bottom 2.

As Jeff Brazier said though, they still have to have one more week of a double elimination and if that is the case this week, then Katie is well gone,I feel sure the public and those who voted for Treyc will want to ensure Katie goes this week.

I doubt the double elimination will happen this week though as what seems to be the desired thing from Simon and and the producers is that they want Katie on the tour but I hope she's gone this week,its very long overdue and no other acts should lose out now for her failure to be popular.