[cub]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

Dermot and the Producers ought to have gone back to Cheryl.

Cheryl had made her decision by then. She had refused. Dermot asked her again. She refused again. What was the point in going back to her.

The error was going to Cheryl second. Mentor's always go last.

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by cub

Cheryl had made her decision by then. She had refused. Dermot asked her again. She refused again. What was the point in going back to her.

The error was going to Cheryl second. Mentor's always go last.

I agree with you mostly, but its not the same as before as Cheryl had been willing to vote after Dannii and Louis,he should have gone back to her but he didint so thats the end of that.It is not the same and is new in the fact she would have been willing to vote had he gone back after Dannii and Louis had voted, that is a major difference from the only other time a majority vote was used with Sharon who not only said in no circumstances she would not vote but that she was finished with the show and quitting it.

Cheryl only said she was not voting at that point,not never.

[nanaimo]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

I agree with you mostly, but its not the same as before as Cheryl had been willing to vote after Dannii and Louis,he should have gone back to her but he didint so thats the end of that.It is not the same and is new in the fact she would have been willing to vote had he gone back after Dannii and Louis had voted, that is a major difference from the only other time a majority vote was used with Sharon who not only said in no circumstances she would not vote but that she was finished with the show and quitting it.

Cheryl only said she was not voting at that point,not never.

yes exactly, she called deadlock and was ignored

[Marsh.]

Well, Simon didn't vote the other week when two groups were in the bottom 2. Yes, the other three judges had already made a majority decision but what was with Dermot pressuring Cheryl to vote second.
The way he said "So you're point blank refusing to vote?" I felt like smacking him the stupid idiot. He acted like a ***** last week when he was saying to Simon "Come on, who would you have gone for?" Even though one act had already been eliminated and Simon didn't need to vote.
It was like come on, they've already been booted out of the show so let's stick the knife in and say that Simon would have also gone for you if he had the chance.
Didn't anyone else not think that Simon, Dannii and Louis would have done the exact same thing in Cheryl's position.