[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Pyramid*

Oh really. The mentor of that category didn't have the say in who was going through in her own group. Right then!

No, she didn't, because all four Judges chose who go through at Bootcamp, and Cheryl was away at Bootcamp this year anyway, as was Dannii...

[Pyramid*]

Originally Posted by Jack_

No, she didn't, because all four Judges chose who go through at Bootcamp, and Cheryl was away at Bootcamp this year anyway, as was Dannii...

I'm not talking about that Jack,I'm not talking about which judges chose who was going to bootcamp... I'm talking about the fact that despite Cher and Katie not even being able to perform at bootcamp - when the mentors HAD been decided, they were still allowed to get through - remember Cheryl on the sofa, going up and cuddling Cher,telling her to try again and Cher 'dismising' Cheryl with her, "I'm done with this".

Same as Katie, messed up her song, and still got through.

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Pyramid*

I'm not talking about that Jack,I'm not talking about which judges chose who was going to bootcamp... I'm talking about the fact that despite Cher and Katie not even being able to perform at bootcamp - when the mentors HAD been decided, they were still allowed to get through - remember Cheryl on the sofa, going up and cuddling Cher,telling her to try again and Cher 'dismising' Cheryl with her, "I'm done with this".

Same as Katie, messed up her song, and still got through.

That wasn't Bootcamp

[Pyramid*]

Originally Posted by Jack_

That wasn't Bootcamp

You are quite correct. It wasn't bootcamp...it was at the judges houses! Sorry for the confusion!!. That was was I was referring to - it was Cheryl who put Cher and Katie through as their finalists.