[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Zee

She's not dull though! She's just been overshadowed by the personality emphasis on the likes of Wagner, Katie and Cher for the entire competition - IMO her talent is what counts, if you have to rely on your personality as much as your vocals to carry you through the X Factor then you're not going to win. Having said all of that, the only winner to date who, IMO, has had both a lot of talent and a personality that leaves an impression on you, is Alexandra Burke. I guess you need a combination of both, but talent is more important. None of the contestants are anything new so I don't think that particular argument stands up.

I'm not really referring to her personality, I'm referring to her lack of stage presence, movement around the stage, etc etc. Perhaps I should've made that part more clear, sorry. She never has any choreography - and when she does the most it is is her moving her hips from side to side. That's what I'm referring to - because I wouldn't pay money to see her standing in a black dress singing fifteen ballads for two hours on her tour. I'd want to see a show as well.

When I say something 'new', I mean in terms of the X Factor. Cher's definitely something we haven't seen before, IMO, and One Direction would be 'new' in the sense that we haven't had a group win before...so that would be good. I'm just a bit fed up of having the same, predictable winners year on year. Rebecca's got a good voice, yes, but then so did Leona [although hers is far superior]. Matt's another Shayne Ward, IMO, even though I like him. I just think we need a different type of winner for once.

[Legend killer]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

2 weeks longer then Wagner then.

That's a cheap shot

[Mr XcX]

Cheryl is such a chav she would vote for Cher over Rebecca!!!

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

Every female winner is always going to be compared to Leona whether fans like it or not and IMO Leona will not be topped especially by someone like Rebecca who is almost the same as her.

+ How is she nothing new? Has there ever been an act like Cher before on XF?
Theres no current big artist in the UK atm who fits Chers genre of music so tbf she is something new.

Well is Cher not going to be a female winner?? Cher will look like Dog shit in comparison to her.

And she's is something new, theres never been anyone with a voice like hers, able to do soul jazzy music. Cher is just a wannabe Nicki Minaj/Cheryl/Tulisa

[Jordan.]

Originally Posted by Jack_

I'm not really referring to her personality, I'm referring to her lack of stage presence, movement around the stage, etc etc. Perhaps I should've made that part more clear, sorry. She never has any choreography - and when she does the most it is is her moving her hips from side to side. That's what I'm referring to - because I wouldn't pay money to see her standing in a black dress singing fifteen ballads for two hours on her tour. I'd want to see a show as well.

When I say something 'new', I mean in terms of the X Factor. Cher's definitely something we haven't seen before, IMO, and One Direction would be 'new' in the sense that we haven't had a group win before...so that would be good. I'm just a bit fed up of having the same, predictable winners year on year. Rebecca's got a good voice, yes, but then so did Leona [although hers is far superior]. Matt's another Shayne Ward, IMO, even though I like him. I just think we need a different type of winner for once.

Best post ive seen in a while and very true.

[Mr XcX]

Seriously though!!

Cher can stay this week as long as WANDERECTION GO!!!

[Jordan.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Well is Cher not going to be a female winner?? Cher will look like Dog shit in comparison to her.

And she's is something new, theres never been anyone with a voice like hers, able to do soul jazzy music. Cher is just a wannabe Nicki Minaj/Cheryl/Tulisa

Like I said every female winner will be compared to Leona but Cher is so different it probably wont even cross peoples minds, Rebecca on the other hand is always going to have her voice compared to her because they are similar.

Oh and Nikki Minaj is not big in the UK, shes nothing like Cheryl because Cheryl doesn't rap and neither does Tulisa.

[Mr XcX]

Originally Posted by Jack_

I'm not really referring to her personality, I'm referring to her lack of stage presence, movement around the stage, etc etc. Perhaps I should've made that part more clear, sorry. She never has any choreography - and when she does the most it is is her moving her hips from side to side. That's what I'm referring to - because I wouldn't pay money to see her standing in a black dress singing fifteen ballads for two hours on her tour. I'd want to see a show as well.

When I say something 'new', I mean in terms of the X Factor. Cher's definitely something we haven't seen before, IMO, and One Direction would be 'new' in the sense that we haven't had a group win before...so that would be good. I'm just a bit fed up of having the same, predictable winners year on year. Rebecca's got a good voice, yes, but then so did Leona [although hers is far superior]. Matt's another Shayne Ward, IMO, even though I like him. I just think we need a different type of winner for once.

Do not be silly! IMO this is why these silly cretins are still in the show! Because people think they are unique!

Plus, You better be prepared for a predictable winner again this year then!!!

[Legend killer]

^ Although i hate OD , i would prefer Cher to go just for the look on Cheryl's face

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Mr XcX

Do not be silly! IMO this is why these silly cretins are still in the show! Because people think they are unique!

Plus, You better be prepared for a predictable winner again this year then!!!

Okay, let me pose two questions to you:

1) Have we had a group win the show before? No? Have we? In that case, they would be unique winners, no?

2) I've asked you before, but...why do you watch these shows when you slate all of the contestants in them? Pretty pointless, isn't it?

[Mr XcX]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Okay, let me pose two questions to you:

1) Have we had a group win the show before? No? Have we? In that case, they would be unique winners, no?

2) I've asked you before, but...why do you watch these shows when you slate all of the contestants in them? Pretty pointless, isn't it?

I am not here to answer your Questions however interesting you find my opinions

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Mr XcX

I am not here to answer your Questions

Clearly there's some flaws in your 'arguments' then, if you're not willing to justify and defend them. Oh dear...

Originally Posted by Mr XcX

however interesting you find my opinions

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Very much doubt it, but hope so. Rebecca is nothing new and is far, far too dull, unfortunately.

Her voice is very distinct and quite unique imo. I would sit and listen to an album of hers, I wouldn't do for one of Chers no matter how interesting her personality is, at the end of the day all I'm interested in when I turn on my ipod is liking what I hear.

[Adamw92]

I'm sure Cher will get more attention but thats okay, Rebecca is amazing enough to have gotten through 8 weeks already with Cheryl focusing more on Cher and Katie.

[robb]

[QUOTE=Legend killer;3950830]I think she will the face last night when Rebecca went through said it all

I'm amazed that 'face' she made hasn't attracted more press TBH......and faced with the choice I think she would abstain.....and leave it to Simon and Louis to put Cher through.

[robb]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

Her voice is very distinct and quite unique imo. I would sit and listen to an album of hers, I wouldn't do for one of Chers no matter how interesting her personality is, at the end of the day all I'm interested in when I turn on my ipod is liking what I hear.

Apparently you are in good company.....Nicole pussycat doll thinks the same.....about Rebecca that is, 'unique in this generation' is how she put it. Now its up to Rebecca to show the passion and fight that the others will this week.