[Jords]

Originally Posted by Zee

I think that would just flop; IMO they couldn't work as anything but a five piece with all of the same members; they were formed that way by the public on a reality TV show, anything different to that formula and they'd lose a lot of support regardless of the reasons behind it. I think it's Nadine who's preventing a reunion from happening, going by the media.

If the music is good it will sell either way. Nicola and Kimberly's popularity has risen quite a bit and the focus was no longer just on Cheryl anyway. And if its Nadine, she flopped hard as a solo so maybe losing her wouldnt affect the group all that much, perhaps and introduction to a new member but they have to be careful they dont do a Sugababes.

Admittingly Id like GA back as the original 5-piece, but if thats not gonna happen the remaining girls should get a stab at it - might ruin their rep or it could relight their flame. Nobody's know until they actually go ahead with it.

[Z]

Originally Posted by Jords

If the music is good it will sell either way. Nicola and Kimberly's popularity has risen quite a bit and the focus was no longer just on Cheryl anyway. And if its Nadine, she flopped hard as a solo so maybe losing her wouldnt affect the group all that much, perhaps and introduction to a new member but they have to be careful they dont do a Sugababes.

Admittingly Id like GA back as the original 5-piece, but if thats not gonna happen the remaining girls should get a stab at it - might ruin their rep or it could relight their flame. Nobody's know until they actually go ahead with it.

All Saints attempted a comeback with some good music and that didn't take off, plenty of girl groups have gone off the boil, attempted a comeback and it's ruined them - same will happen to Girls Aloud if they try anything other than the original five, and they'd need to do it very well to pull it off. I think they're dead :/