[Stevep]

...am i the only person here that doesn't 'get' the fascination with her? No doubt she is a decent singer, but nothing more than that IMO!

That squeaky, out of tune voice technique thingy she does will begin to grate on people in a few weeks time, i guarantee it!

[LaLaLand]

She bores me witless.

Also, how is she going to cope in the 'themed' weeks? Big band week and her won't go together well...

[Jords]

Her voice is unique and easily identifiable and she doesnt have to sing hard to capture attention. Shes great.

[Lewis.]

I love her voice but I can see a Diana V.2 eventually happening and she'll eventually lose her support to some of the bigger singers because her performances will sound very similar each time.

[reece(:]

trying to be a diana vickers, not liking it

[Jordan.]

She is good but definitely overrated. Diana was better too.

[Novo]

Janet is possibly the most gormless person the X Factor has ever seen.. Diana actually had a personality but Janet seems to have lost hers

[MeMyselfAndI]

Janet is amazing. Although Diana was better.

[Locke.]

She is really good but I hate supporting the favourite there is no fun in it and it puts me off them

[Visage]

I don't think it's about 'getting' someone, probably more about taste in music/voice.

Some people like that style and some people don't. It would be a very boring place if we all liked the same thing.

[Saph]

she makes me feel ill

[Pyramid*]

Janet should have gone.

[BigBrotherfan4ever]

Originally Posted by reece(:

trying to be a diana vickers, not liking it

I think she is very like Diana Vickers in the way she sings, I also think Janet is very overrated in my opinion.

[MusicXian]

She's awesome, but she won't win it unless she proves to be more versatile with her style.

[Niamh.]

I love her voice, similar-ish to Dianas but not as irritating. I think she's more Ellie Goulding than Diana actually

[nanaimo]

Janet is great and a down to earth girl, hope she goes far

[Visage]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

I love her voice, similar-ish to Dianas but not as irritating. I think she's more Ellie Goulding

Yes, her version of 'Your Song' was identical to that of Goudling.

[MusicXian]

Can anyone find her 2nd Judges House song in full? I only got a short 28 second clip so far of it. Sounds really good.

[Marc]

She's unique but boring. I don't blame people for not liking her. The public will see, in about 4 weeks time, just how boring she is and how undiverse she is.

[MusicXian]

I don't think she is boring at all.Of course she has her style and they shouldnt try to change her too much from that, but she sang Aerosmith and Coldplay whos songs I think are far from boring. Plus if you see on her youtube videos she even sang Cee Lo Green and other such songs in her version. I think they should try to test her though in later weeks instead of play safe as she did in week 1 with Fix You.