[Lewis.]

Leona:

Youtube video

Lucy:

Youtube video

(HOW SHE DIDN'T WIN THAT YEAR IS BEYOND ME, AND TO GO OUT TO JEDWARD?!??!!?!)

Sami:

Youtube video

Nikki:

Youtube video

Think they are the only main performances of the song over the years.

[Lewis.]

Has to be Leona, but I loved Lucy Jones's version of the song too.. really raw and believable.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Leonas obvs.

Leonas > Lucies > Nikkis > Samis

[Patrick]

I honestly don't get how some people can remember performances on X Factor, who sang them, where each contestant finished, what weeks certain things happened etc

I mean I know Big Brother of the back of my hand - but how the hell can people do that with XF? There's no depth, it's not even interesting.

[Doogle]

Originally Posted by Patrick

I honestly don't get how some people can remember performances on X Factor, who sang them, where each contestant finished, what weeks certain things happened etc

I mean I know Big Brother of the back of my hand - but how the hell can people do that with XF? There's no depth, it's not even interesting.

Yes because you don't find it interesting, we do and we know this stuff

For me it's gotta be Niki

[MeMyselfAndI]

This Poll is hilar

[MeMyselfAndI]

Patrick did you just vote for the "hottest girl"?

[Z]

Obviously Leona.

As for what Patrick said - do you remember where BB contestants finished? Probably, because the eviction shows are a weekly highlight. The X Factor runs in the same way - every week, somebody is kicked off the show, fans get annoyed and bicker over who deserved to go instead, people vote and the winner is usually the most entertaining participant, but sometimes you get a surprise, boring winner who amounts to nothing. They are so comparable that the mind boggles that you'd say such a thing?!

[Lewis.]

Originally Posted by Zee

Obviously Leona.

As for what Patrick said - do you remember where BB contestants finished? Probably, because the eviction shows are a weekly highlight. The X Factor runs in the same way - every week, somebody is kicked off the show, fans get annoyed and bicker over who deserved to go instead, people vote and the winner is usually the most entertaining participant, but sometimes you get a surprise, boring winner who amounts to nothing. They are so comparable that the mind boggles that you'd say such a thing?!

I'd say it's even more difficult to remember everything that happens on Big Brother - It's on 7 days a week compared to The X Factor which is on twice a week. It's the same with everyone who has a favourite TV show, you just tend to remember everything about it because you enjoy it. If I went on mastermind with The X Factor (especially series 5, the best one) and there wasn't a general knowledge round I'd smash it

[Princess]

Is this the song where whoever sings it either goes that night or wins? It might have been another song but it was definitely some song, there was a thread about it at some point.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Princess

Is this the song where whoever sings it either goes that night or wins? It might have been another song but it was definitely some song, there was a thread about it at some point.

Yeah that was my conspiracy but it was Mariah Carey- Can't Live. I made that thread when Alexandra sung it in week 5 or 6 and noone thought she would win at that stage. I was scarily right . Noone has sung it since, but Sami will probably do it at some point (and be eliminated in that week).

[Shaun]

Dolly Parton xo

[BB_Eye]

Rik

[Adamw92]

I voted for Leona obviousy!

Originally Posted by Princess

Is this the song where whoever sings it either goes that night or wins? It might have been another song but it was definitely some song, there was a thread about it at some point.

There may be more than one song that gives either of those results but I think you're talking about 'One Moment in Time', Both times its been performed on the show, the performer has been eliminated that week.

[Princess]

Originally Posted by Tom

Yeah that was my conspiracy but it was Mariah Carey- Can't Live. I made that thread when Alexandra sung it in week 5 or 6 and noone thought she would win at that stage. I was scarily right . Noone has sung it since, but Sami will probably do it at some point (and be eliminated in that week).

That was it!! And Leona sang it as well.

[joeysteele]

I am sick of this song being sung on X Factor, for me the truly best version is by the person who wrote it Dolly Parton,all this screaming and screeching on what is a tender song is awful.

Sami had a good try at it on Saturday though,to be fair.

[StraightEdge695]

lucy