[Shasown]

Originally Posted by lostalex

Why should the USA return any extradition request, when Roman Polanski, who admits to raping and drugging a small girl, is allowed to live freely in Europe with no extradition to the USA???

If you give us Roman Polanski, then maybe we can talk about Amanda Knox. Until then, you have NO room to talk about extradition.

Europe is not one country, if the US negotiates an extradition treaty with a country, the treaty should stand for both sides.

Having seen the way the US backed out of ratifying the US/UK Extradition treaty and still expect the UK to turn over anyone the US want, most countries wont bother listening to the US.

Just to reiterate, Amanda Knox trial - Italy Roman Polanski - France and Switzerland.

You appear to have also overlooked in the Polanski case the fact he did undergo trial and thought a bargain had been reached by the reduction of charges and probation and treatment in a clinic at the courts order. The judge then indicated to Polankski's attroney that he had changed his mind and though jail and deportation to be a more suitable punishment even though the prosecuting attorney asked for probation.

Even the prosecuting attorney stated that Polanski's treatment at the hands of a fame hungry judge was unfair. France doesnt have an extradition treaty with the US and Switzerland stated that Polanski had indeed served his original sentence.

Cant wait to read the garbage you will write in defence of the US legal system regarding extradition in rebuttal.

[lostalex]

Originally Posted by Shasown

Europe is not one country, if the US negotiates an extradition treaty with a country, the treaty should stand for both sides.

Having seen the way the US backed out of ratifying the US/UK Extradition treaty and still expect the UK to turn over anyone the US want, most countries wont bother listening to the US.

Just to reiterate, Amanda Knox trial - Italy Roman Polanski - France and Switzerland.

You appear to have also overlooked in the Polanski case the fact he did undergo trial and thought a bargain had been reached by the reduction of charges and probation and treatment in a clinic at the courts order. The judge then indicated to Polankski's attroney that he had changed his mind and though jail and deportation to be a more suitable punishment even though the prosecuting attorney asked for probation.

Even the prosecuting attorney stated that Polanski's treatment at the hands of a fame hungry judge was unfair. France doesnt have an extradition treaty with the US and Switzerland stated that Polanski had indeed served his original sentence.

Cant wait to read the garbage you will write in defence of the US legal system regarding extradition in rebuttal.

really? drugging and rapping a child should just cary a punishment of rehab??

Sorry, but in America, when you drug and rape a child, you get jail time.

Here's a messege to all people who want to drug and rape children, don't do it in America, because we'll put you in jail!

If you want to drug and rape children, do it in Europe.

[lostalex]

Originally Posted by Shasown

Europe is not one country, if the US negotiates an extradition treaty with a country, the treaty should stand for both sides.

Having seen the way the US backed out of ratifying the US/UK Extradition treaty and still expect the UK to turn over anyone the US want, most countries wont bother listening to the US.

Just to reiterate, Amanda Knox trial - Italy Roman Polanski - France and Switzerland.

You appear to have also overlooked in the Polanski case the fact he did undergo trial and thought a bargain had been reached by the reduction of charges and probation and treatment in a clinic at the courts order. The judge then indicated to Polankski's attroney that he had changed his mind and though jail and deportation to be a more suitable punishment even though the prosecuting attorney asked for probation.

Even the prosecuting attorney stated that Polanski's treatment at the hands of a fame hungry judge was unfair. France doesnt have an extradition treaty with the US and Switzerland stated that Polanski had indeed served his original sentence.

Cant wait to read the garbage you will write in defence of the US legal system regarding extradition in rebuttal.

tell me how it was unfair. he drugged and rapped a child by his own admission. Tell me what YOU think is a fair punishment for drugging and RAPING a child. having sex with a CHILD that is unconcious on drugs that he gave her,. please tell me what YOU think would be a fair punishment.!

I'm curious to know.

I'd like to know what punishment you think is fair if it was your daughter who was drugged and raped.

An old man gave drugs to a child and then had sex with the child while the child was unconscious., what punishment do YOU think would be fair???

Please explain how thew US justice system is wrong for demanding he pay for that crime. Tell me what YOU think would be fair punishment.

Please tell me what is the "fair" punishment for someone who RAPES A CHILD. You tell me.

[Livia]

Originally Posted by lostalex

tell me how it was unfair. he drugged and rapped a child by his own admission. Tell me what YOU think is a fair punishment for drugging and RAPING a child. having sex with a CHILD that is unconcious on drugs that he gave her,. please tell me what YOU think would be a fair punishment.!

I'm curious to know.

I'd like to know what punishment you think is fair if it was your daughter who was drugged and raped.

An old man gave drugs to a child and then had sex with the child while the child was unconscious., what punishment do YOU think would be fair???

Please explain how thew US justice system is wrong for demanding he pay for that crime. Tell me what YOU think would be fair punishment.

Please tell me what is the "fair" punishment for someone who RAPES A CHILD. You tell me.

What's this got to do with the Amanda Knox case?

[Shasown]

Originally Posted by lostalex

tell me how it was unfair. he drugged and rapped a child by his own admission. Tell me what YOU think is a fair punishment for drugging and RAPING a child. having sex with a CHILD that is unconcious on drugs that he gave her,. please tell me what YOU think would be a fair punishment.!

I'm curious to know.

I'd like to know what punishment you think is fair if it was your daughter who was drugged and raped.

An old man gave drugs to a child and then had sex with the child while the child was unconscious., what punishment do YOU think would be fair???

Please explain how thew US justice system is wrong for demanding he pay for that crime. Tell me what YOU think would be fair punishment.

Please tell me what is the "fair" punishment for someone who RAPES A CHILD. You tell me.

I didnt say it was fair or unfair, please READ my posts properly, if you have problems with any big words ask an adult to explain them to you.

If you had read up on the Polanski case you would find out that a plea bargain had taken place with the judge involved and punishments etc already agreed upon. That was the reasoning behind the Swiss refusal to extradite.

But why let the facts get in the way of your usual "America is wonderful" rants.

Just to reiterate the point, the Amanda Knox trial and potential retrial doesnt have anything to do with the Polanksi case, there are three (thats three - pointee finger, middle finger and ringo) separate countries involved in the two different cases.

[lostalex]

Originally Posted by Shasown

I didnt say it was fair or unfair, please READ my posts properly, if you have problems with any big words ask an adult to explain them to you.

If you had read up on the Polanski case you would find out that a plea bargain had taken place with the judge involved and punishments etc already agreed upon. That was the reasoning behind the Swiss refusal to extradite.

But why let the facts get in the way of your usual "America is wonderful" rants.

Just to reiterate the point, the Amanda Knox trial and potential retrial doesnt have anything to do with the Polanksi case, there are three (thats three - pointee finger, middle finger and ringo) separate countries involved in the two different cases.

Rreally this is about my being American? so now being American means that justice isimpossible. Has Roman Polanski ever denied drugging and raping a child?? no.

So why are you defending him??

I've asked you dozens of times now, what do you think is fair punishment for drugging and raping a child?? Why can't you answer that question??