[Joe.]

Does anyone else think it's unfair that she's in the final 5?

I mean she was told to go home week one, cos she was the weakest performer that week.

If it wasn't for Frankie 'choosing to leave' then she wouldn't be back.

Last sunday she got the sympathy vote but this week she was in the final 2.

I don't think it's fair that Craig has gone home before her, I mean he's survived 6 weeks and then is defeated by her.

I think that she dosen't deserve to be in the final 5 whatsoever!

[Locke.]

She has the best voice, so no.

[Joe.]

Shouty. Arrogant. Annoying.

[Niamh.]

Yeah, I think it was unfair to skip her through basically to the final when all the other acts to work to get there and survive all those eliminations

[Lee.]

Yeah, I agree Joe. I don't really think much of her at all and isnt likable either

[blandchild]

Mealies!

[Joe.]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

Yeah, I think it was unfair to skip her through basically to the final when all the other acts to work to get there and survive all those eliminations

Exactly. If she wins i'd feel kind of well...cheated. I mean to survive Week 2,3,4,5 + 6 isn't exactly easy, you have to be liked and perform well each week, I don't think that if Amelia had have stayed she would have lasted to Week 4 max.

It's like she's been given a free pass to the final imo. I mean she's got the sympathy votes last week and will again next week so basically has secured her place in the semi-final. She's overated aswell. She's shouty and annoying. It's ridiculous Craig has gone before her.

[Jords]

Its definitely unfair, and to a certain extent I wanted Craig to stay because of this but in the sing-off she was incredible and at the end of the day if shes got the talent why not?

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Joe.

Exactly. If she wins i'd feel kind of well...cheated. I mean to survive Week 2,3,4,5 + 6 isn't exactly easy, you have to be liked and perform well each week, I don't think that if Amelia had have stayed she would have lasted to Week 4 max.

It's like she's been given a free pass to the final imo. I mean she's got the sympathy votes last week and will again next week so basically has secured her place in the semi-final. She's overated aswell. She's shouty and annoying. It's ridiculous Craig has gone before her.

Yeah, I agree. She won't win though, not a chance, she's gone either next week or the week after

[Joe.]

My Prediction-

Next Week- Misha will go, Amelia will get the sympathy votes.

Week after (Semi Final)- I HOPE Amelia will go, quite confident she will!

Final- 3rd- Janet
2nd- Marcus
1st (I Hope)- Little Mix

[Strictly Jake]

I think she is really good. But I dont know whether she is likeable or not. She pulls some strange angry faces. But she can sing! Whereas little mix arent the best singers left. They are good but what makes them better is they are likeable. So if she won over little mix or the other 4 I wouldnt be very happy even though she has a great voice I dont connect with her. She wont win anyway

[joeysteele]

I agree not because she is not a good singer, she does have talent but I agree she shouldn't be there because I didn't like the bringing an act back.
They could have instead had a 'special' week,like the first week, where the public weren't consulted and not had an elimination from the show for one week.

For that reason I firstly don't think it fair Amelia is there at all and also I don't want her to win it either.
She was deemed by Kelly not to be good enough to be kept in right at the first week and tonight she has been voted into the bottom 2 by the public after only 2 other weeks performances. No, she should not even be there at all.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Shes the best!!

[Cherie]

Really sorry to see Craig go, I loved his version of Jar of Hearts, and tonights sing off song, Amelia has a good voice but can be a bit screechy, and she has really dead eyes....not sure I liked the whole bringing her back thing, I think the person who had the most votes from The Risk and Johnny should have returned.

[BigBrotherfan4ever]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

Shes the best!!

Totally agree

Originally Posted by CherieB

Really sorry to see Craig go, I loved his version of Jar of Hearts, and tonights sing off song, Amelia has a good voice but can be a bit screechy, and she has really dead eyes....not sure I liked the whole bringing her back thing, I think the person who had the most votes from The Risk and Johnny should have returned.

I think that would have been the fairest way to do it.

[Mystic Mock]

It proves she would have coasted past the first 6 weeks when she beat Craig in the votes tonight after only being in the competition for 2 weeks.

Craig also didnt have the best of sing-offs,he has done much better in the live shows imo,where as Amelia was superb in the sing-off tonight and Gary saying she shouted through the performance was a ridiculous comment imo.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by CherieB

Really sorry to see Craig go, I loved his version of Jar of Hearts, and tonights sing off song, Amelia has a good voice but can be a bit screechy, and she has really dead eyes....not sure I liked the whole bringing her back thing, I think the person who had the most votes from The Risk and Johnny should have returned.

Johnny had but they would have had to refund peoples money if they did that, wouldn't they?

Personally, I think they should have just left it alone and had one less person in the final

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

It proves she would have coasted past the first 6 weeks when she beat Craig in the votes tonight after only being in the competition for 2 weeks.

Craig also didnt have the best of sing-offs,he has done much better in the live shows imo,where as Amelia was superb in the sing-off tonight and Gary saying she shouted through the performance was a ridiculous comment imo.

I think Craig was far better in the sing off. Although I disagreed with Gary making that comment to her when it was a sing off, I did agree with him, I thought she was awful in it.

[Locke.]

Craig was average in the sing off and has been average for about 5 weeks

[Glenn.]

Craig had the lowest votes. The public obviously didnt like him.

Plus Amelia has the better voice.

Don't know what all this screeching bollocks is about.

Fair enough people think she screeches.

At least she screeches in tune.

[Jack_]

Amelia was the best act of all 16, Kelly made the wrong decision sending her home in the first week, it should have been dull Sophie. She's far and away the most talented, and thankfully she returned and she deserves her place.

[MusicXian]

I like Amelia, but indeed its unfair and I also dislike how Amelia and her parents slagged off the XF after week 1, but now it's some amazing opportunity again.

[Brother Leon]

Just catched up on yesterday.

Lol at her Kat Moon outfit.

[HBB1508]

Originally Posted by CherieB

Really sorry to see Craig go, I loved his version of Jar of Hearts, and tonights sing off song, Amelia has a good voice but can be a bit screechy, and she has really dead eyes....not sure I liked the whole bringing her back thing, I think the person who had the most votes from The Risk and Johnny should have returned.

Totally agree with this post - also Amelia has an unfair advantage having a free ride this far into the show - she is fresher and hasn't had to cope with the pressure of the other live shows and evictions. When Frankie went they should have either bought back Johnny or had a week with no eviction imo.

[Jordan.]

No.