[MusicXian]

It is her style of singing, just because she doesnt prance around stage shouting high notes galore when there is no need doesnt mean she is boring. There are people out there who would buy this type of music, I think she needs a band though to get her music out there and be make things a little more up tempo.

[Pyramid*]

Originally Posted by MusicXian

It is her style of singing, just because she doesnt prance around stage shouting high notes galore when there is no need doesnt mean she is boring. There are people out there who would buy this type of music, I think she needs a band though to get her music out there and be make things a little more up tempo.

It is her style of singing and I agree with you, and imo, it's suited to folk songs - not for the X Factor and someone who has that special something. She will appeal to a certain market: but not to the masses, and that's what X Factor is about.

[MusicXian]

Originally Posted by Pyramid*

It is her style of singing and I agree with you, and imo, it's suited to folk songs - not for the X Factor and someone who has that special something. She will appeal to a certain market: but not to the masses, and that's what X Factor is about.

That is why since week 3 when XF production realised this they have absolutely destroyed her. She didnt deserve to win this based on a couple of performances. Forgetting words is a no-no. I would not have voted her to win it despite being my favourite, however I wanted her to get further than Misha and Amelia because IMO it would have stuck up 2 fingers at XF.

However she has been absolutely killed off by XF with song choices, the VTs, judges comments etc. and her confidence is somewhere down at zero I would think at this moment.

[fruit_cake]

Originally Posted by Pyramid*

It is her style of singing and I agree with you, and imo, it's suited to folk songs - not for the X Factor and someone who has that special something. She will appeal to a certain market: but not to the masses, and that's what X Factor is about.

Janet has only been once in the B2, whereas Misha has been in it three times, so Janet is more popular than Misha B as voted by the public!

[Pyramid*]

Originally Posted by fruit_cake

Janet has only been once in the B2, whereas Misha has been in it three times, so Janet is more popular than Misha B as voted by the public!

How many times has Misha forgotten words to songs? Janet did it a few weeks back, and twice last night (at the very start and midway through her first song).

Janet's singoff performance alone was enough to not have her go any further, it was painful to listen to.

We don't know if Janet is more popular at this point -unless of course, you have the public voting figures to hand.

[Doogle]

Originally Posted by Pyramid*

How many times has Misha forgotten words to songs? Janet did it a few weeks back, and twice last night (at the very start and midway through her first song).

Janet's singoff performance alone was enough to not have her go any further, it was painful to listen to.

We don't know if Janet is more popular at this point -unless of course, you have the public voting figures to hand.

Agreed with this, I don't like Misha much but the fact is, she was better than Janet and as you said Pyramid, she has not forgotten her words. Despite being in the Bottom Two 3 times now, Misha did a good enough job to remain.