[hulakula]

Originally Posted by sampvt

TBH Naimh I dont want to get infracted for being out there against him, I simply cant see a great deal of commitment there. Maybe I am wrong but I was reading other posts on other sites and these other sites seem to be running with the idea that all is not clear and I wanted to see if we on here were any different. The problem is as I have stated, that as soon as his transgender is discussed, it creates a minefield of venom and nasty posts. That wasnt my aim.

In closing if you want my personal and unbiased opinion, I would venture to suggest that like people before him, nadia etc, he will still be the same person in many years to come. but thats my opinion based on the fact that I cant see in his eyes or actions that he is fully commited.

None of us are in any position to question his commitment to his gender assignment surgery . We don't know him. Medical professionals have determined that he is and that the hormone treatment and surgery are necessary, they are more informed than any of us. I don't understand why you feel the need to speculate.

[sampvt]

Originally Posted by hulakula

None of us are in any position to question his commitment to his gender assignment surgery . We don't know him. Medical professionals have determined that he is and that the hormone treatment and surgery are necessary, they are more informed than any of us. I don't understand why you feel the need to speculate.

Speculation is the bread and butter of a free serving discussion forum. Trying to supress someones ideas and opinions by calling them names and casting aspertions of doubt on the posters methodology is called bullying.

[rayheartbliss]

Originally Posted by sampvt

Speculation is the bread and butter of a free serving discussion forum. Trying to supress someones ideas and opinions by calling them names and casting aspertions of doubt on the posters methodology is called bullying.

is this serious?

[kistar]

Originally Posted by sampvt

Speculation is the bread and butter of a free serving discussion forum. Trying to supress someones ideas and opinions by calling them names and casting aspertions of doubt on the posters methodology is called bullying.

Exactly

[hulakula]

Originally Posted by sampvt

Speculation is the bread and butter of a free serving discussion forum. Trying to supress someones ideas and opinions by calling them names and casting aspertions of doubt on the posters methodology is called bullying.

Your speculations appear to be based on nothing but prejudice. You're not providing any solid evidence to support your ideas. You seem fixated on the idea that Luke isn't commuted gender reassignment based on on concrete evidence.

[Jayson]

Originally Posted by sampvt

Speculation is the bread and butter of a free serving discussion forum. Trying to supress someones ideas and opinions by calling them names and casting aspertions of doubt on the posters methodology is called bullying.

Everyone's ideas will be met with equal opposition. That is the bread and butter of a free serving discussion forum.

[Gizmo]

Originally Posted by Jayson

Everyone's ideas will be met with equal opposition. That is the bread and butter of a free serving discussion forum.

Relativism is rife on forums. Posters who have more expertise aren't perceived as more informed, whatever their background or qualifications. That's the essence of modern society anyway whether you agree with it or not. Ignorance is tolerated and remains unchallenged.

[rachelricci]

Originally Posted by sampvt

Speculation is the bread and butter of a free serving discussion forum. Trying to supress someones ideas and opinions by calling them names and casting aspertions of doubt on the posters methodology is called bullying.

ok. every time ive seen you, you have been commenting harsh trans based comments, i am now going to speculate that you are prejudist does that sound ok

p.s sorry about mah spelling