[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by Anthony Hatface

I doubt she is consciously racist, as she is such a gameplayer most of the time that would be a stupid strategic error (There is an extensive briefing given to prospective HMs, leaving no doubt that intentional racism is an automatic disqualification). However, there is a distict undertone to some of what she says, and she does come from that background where patronising attitudes to other races and classes has been de rigeur until recent times. At least her presence goes to demonstrate what a sad anachronism it is that the upper class continues to reign ... though I'm certainly not won to the idea that is enough reason for her to stay.

Just re-watched the scene in which Shievonne gets her birthday message from her nieces, in which the whole house (including Conor, whom I am normally quick to dismiss as an emotionally-crippled ape) is looking genuinely moved and uplifted by the occasion except for Caroline, who appears bemused, indifferent, and faintly contemptuous. I sometimes wonder if she just had an empathy-bypass operation early in life ...

Great post Anthony, I think all your points are pretty valid.