[kefln]

Originally Posted by sampvt

Give her a break, you are asking for a war and peace novel size reply knowing it cant be or wont be done just so you can poke fun. I have a suggestion. watch the series and base your decisions on facts not personal preferences.

But BB is all about personal preferences and I've asked a fellow forum member to elaborate on a statement that they have made. Its completely up to Chuff to answer, or not.

And don't question my motives or slip things in like "so you can poke fun". Thats putting words in my mouth and ideas in peoples heads.

I've asked a reasonable question and have opened the floor to debate, which is what a forum is all about.

[sampvt]

Originally Posted by kefln

But BB is all about personal preferences and I've asked a fellow forum member to elaborate on a statement that they have made. Its completely up to Chuff to answer, or not.

And don't question my motives or slip things in like "so you can poke fun". Thats putting words in my mouth and ideas in peoples heads.

I've asked a reasonable question and have opened the floor to debate, which is what a forum is all about.

I agree what you say but anyone can ask how many people died on the titanic, you are asking for their names and address.

[kefln]

Originally Posted by sampvt

I agree what you say but anyone can ask how many people died on the titanic, you are asking for their names and address.

No, I'm asking for a compare and contrast.

By using the words "list of the vilest" it implies that Chuff has a list, so that is a good place to start.

I suggested that we might begin with the current HM's and mentioned two serious events that have occurred. This would naturally have to be taken into account when it comes to deciding who has been the most "vile" HM of 2012.

Again, this is completely up to Chuff, as I for one as interested in understanding why Deana is "vile" in their opinion.