[Apple202]

Originally Posted by Doogle

But people always go "oh they had a bad week give them another chance" and Tulisa is the one to blame because Melanie would've survived otherwise, people aren't using it as an excuse to slag off Tulisa again, she deserves to be after making such a bad decision.

Plus she is a slut anyway so it's just stating facts.

You're whole post made invalid by one sentence. She gave her boyfriend a blowjob, the horror!!!!

And technically it wasn't her fault, it was the public's for not voting Melanie enough

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by Apple202

point proven.

She's a skank with no morals

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by Jamie585

first bad decision and everyone hates her suddenly? She hasn't made one bad decision yet, he's been the best mentor so far, She has picked great songs for all her acts and is the only Judge not to have had a contestant in the bottom 2, says it all really

Jamie talking sense once again

[Doogle]

Originally Posted by Apple202

You're whole post made invalid by one sentence. She gave her boyfriend a blowjob, the horror!!!!

And technically it wasn't her fault, it was the public's for not voting Melanie enough

Blowjobs are sinful she will pay for what she did

[Merry Mockmas]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Shes allowed her opinion...

Personally I dont see the point in having 2 boybands in the competition though, but I dont think Melanie was actually too good in the singoff either....I expected her to absolutely wipe the floor with district3, THEN I probably would have joined in the tulisa bashing if she sent her home. But she screwed up...and in the end the public got their choice. Cant complain really

Do you honestly think that was her opinion though? or was it just the fact that in future weeks Melanie would be more of a threat to win than The Backstreet Boys was ever going to be?

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by Salman!

She's a skank with no morals

Again, because she gave her boyfriend a blowjob? Get a grip.

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

Do you honestly think that was her opinion though? or was it just the fact that in future weeks Melanie would be more of a threat to win than The Backstreet Boys was ever going to be?

Why would Melanie be more of a threat if she got less votes than District 3?

[Jamie585]

Love Tulisa.. Don't hate!!

[Ramsay]

Not surprised people have lowered themselves to calling her a slut

[Merry Mockmas]

Originally Posted by Apple202

Why would Melanie be more of a threat if she got less votes than District 3?

Because she got lost in the crowd of 12 contestants where as District3 are only gonna average about 5 to 7% each week.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by Apple202

Again, because she gave her boyfriend a blowjob? Get a grip.

No thanks I'll leave that to Tulisa

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

Because she got lost in the crowd of 12 contestants where as District3 are only gonna average about 5 to 7% each week.

You can think of all the excuses you like, but seen as though Melanie had the least votes, she quite clearly was the smallest threat.

[Merry Mockmas]

Originally Posted by Apple202

You can think of all the excuses you like, but seen as though Melanie had the least votes, she quite clearly was the smallest threat.

She wasn't as you will see when the voting results come out and District3 pull in the same percentages in every week, where as if Melanie was given more interesting song choices she would've been much higher in the votes.

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

She wasn't as you will see when the voting results come out and District3 pull in the same percentages in every week, where as if Melanie was given more interesting song choices she would've been much higher in the votes.

You can't build your hate of someone on a presumption.

[Merry Mockmas]

I can and especially when Melanie wiped the floor with The Backstreet Boys in the sing-off.

Although Carolynne wiped the floor with Rylan last week and yet Louis ****ed up, and Simon's decision to save Katie over Aiden a couple of years ago so I don't know why I am shocked anymore tbh.

[Raph]

Yeah like Rachel Adedeji was sent home over Lloyd.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Raph

Yeah like Rachel Adedeji was sent home over Lloyd.

And Lucie sent home over Jedward

So many bad decisions. But thats what keeps people talking about the show.

[Ramsay]

Mock you're making an embarrassment of yourself

[Jamie585]

She's not going anywhere! her job is safe as houses!!

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by Karl

Mock you're making an embarrassment of yourself

^

[Merry Mockmas]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

And Lucie sent home over Jedward

So many bad decisions. But thats what keeps people talking about the show.

Yes but normally they are not in the first two weeks.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

Yes but normally they are not in the first two weeks.

I think this week just seems worse because of all the controversy of last week...had it been a 'normal' elimination last week noone would really care this week.

I dont think a joke act has been in the bottom first before? With the exception of cocozza, but the group he was against were absolutely ****e. This is probably why it stands out more...coz carolyn was a decent singer. But they cant lose the characters early, people would lose interest with noone to hate so early on

[In the Drunk Tank]

The two acts this series weren't really "sent home" considering it went to public vote though, in a way it's the fairest result

[Merry Mockmas]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

I think this week just seems worse because of all the controversy of last week...had it been a 'normal' elimination last week noone would really care this week.

I dont think a joke act has been in the bottom first before? With the exception of cocozza, but the group he was against were absolutely ****e. This is probably why it stands out more...coz carolyn was a decent singer. But they cant lose the characters early, people would lose interest with noone to hate so early on

But District3 aren't characters, they are just a very boring boyband and at best average vocalists (that's me being kind btw) noway should they have stayed tonight.

[Merry Mockmas]

Originally Posted by MTVN

The two acts this series weren't really "sent home" considering it went to public vote though, in a way it's the fairest result

The judges are suppose to be there to amend any wrong results and they have failed in both weeks now, im wondering how they are gonna mess up next week tbh.

Will it be Kye losing to Christopher? anyone losing to District3? or Ella losing out to Rylan?